• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

What's compatible with my 2 x 256MB DDR RAM?

maharito

Member
Jan 21, 2005
38
0
0
Well, okay, it was only a silicon flesh wound...

I posted on here earlier about how I couldn't get any motherboards to work, and now I have found a solution.

Here's what happened: My parents were wanting to replace an ailing K7S5A PRO motherboard. Since we aren't big in pocketbooks, we wanted the cheapest fix we could find, so we ended up getting the SV266AD and KT600-A motherboards to try to replace it. However, using all the available spare parts we had, we couldn't get either mobo working. The ONLY kind of spare parts we couldn't exchange for testing purposes was the DDR RAM. I carefully bought them 512MB DDR RAM, with 64x4 internal configuration, and it worked like a charm. Beforehand, I was getting beeps that indicated a video error (1 long, 2 short), and it was only luck that saved their hinds. So now they use the (better rated) KT600-A mobo.

BUT WHAT ABOUT LIL OLD ME?? Now I want to use their memory to make another computer, but how the heck do I find a motherboard that is compatible?

Someone please tell me.

I have two identical-make 256MB DDR RAM sticks (184-pin, since they're for desktops), rated PC266 (PC2100 in modern numeration). I have no information about their origins, but they have 'VIO' stamped all over them. Markings would indicate they have 32x8 internal configuration (better than the rare 32x4 one, at least). I do not know whether they are 4-layer or 6-layer modular design sticks. Now, could someone tell me what motherboards out there can support this kind of memory? Obviously there are websites to help you get memory for a specific motherboard, but they don't discuss the specifics that could help an independent researcher such as myself. Personally, I'm rather peeved with how little this important matter is discussed. It seems more like the only winners are the few sites that obtain the most compatible memory available and then say they are the ones who can help you find the RIGHT memory, when they have simply used some insider information to circumvent the step that cripples techies most (memory layout/chipset compatibility).

So, since I somewhat doubt anyone would know the memory compatibility scene a whole lot better, testimony will do. Anyone with 256MB sticks of memory that is 32x8, and an Athlon XP, tell me what motherboard you are using, please! (No, I will not get another K7S5A PRO--it will not properly support CPUs at 133Mhz FSB, and its other various complaints make it seem more like a miracle it worked in the parents' computer!)

Additional note: I can be sure that the DDR RAM was not the problem in the parents' computer because that motherboard also supports SDRAM, and using available SDRAM produced the same symptoms in the board that the DDR RAM did (i.e. computer would hang frequently at power-on and always on reset).

Another note: I just found a really nice post in ArsTechnica that highlights compatibility and debunks the myths of getting RAM to work. Apparently, the seller I went to was actually fooling me! The internal configuration 'density' configurations are supported much better in the DDR RAM generation than they were in the SDRAM days. It's probably CLS timing that is the problem. However, since I no longer possess a board that can run these sticks, I can't tell what timings they have. I figure my best option is just to look for a board that came out when PC2100 was new, and it should work fine. (Too bad I won't get full AGPx8 out of my GeForce FX... *sigh*)

Still, any testimony may be used for a motherboard purchase. Any help would be appreciated.
 

Fern

Elite Member
Sep 30, 2003
26,907
174
106
Originally posted by: Kensai
They should work in about any mobo.

Agreed.

Plus, I would just get a more modern NF2 mobo supporting 400mhz instead of one that came out when PC2100 was new.

Also, no real world diff between AGP 4x v 8x

Fern
 

maharito

Member
Jan 21, 2005
38
0
0
Originally posted by: Kensai
They should work in about any mobo.


Any mobo but the SV266AD and the KT600-A, natch...

Until I know why it didn't work in those two different, fully functional boards (both of these support 400Mhz FSB, for modernness reference), I'm waiting on word of a board that supports older PC2100 memory of some kind.
 

Fern

Elite Member
Sep 30, 2003
26,907
174
106
A very rational & cautious approach. However some mobo's are picky about ram, particularly no-name brands (as well as well known good brands). Could be difficult to pinpoint if thats the case.

I realize you already have the ram, but strikes me a bit to build a rig aroung PC2100 just because you have it already. It's not like 512MB of no-name PC2100 is expensive anyways.

Anyhoo, Good Luck with it.

Fern
 

maharito

Member
Jan 21, 2005
38
0
0
HAPPY ENDING!

Fern, you make a good point...though I implied earlier that I am not only frugal but I really don't like throwing out functional hardware ^_^;

Well, I got it working!! The motherboard I chose to get was a board from Syntax (same as the SV266AD) with an SiS chipset (all the previous boards we've had were VIA)... The S746FX is being used to post this, along with my spare Athlon XP 2400+ and the oddball PC2100. I had a feeling that SiS was generally more compatible with stuff. I've read my share of 'if you want stability, avoid VIA' threads. I guess it was time for change...

And I lucked out on the price too! There's a warehouse stock of retail box boards at www.txmicro.com, if anyone is interested. Though it doesn't support 100mhz and thus wouldn't be good for older comps, I would initially recommend this board to anyone looking for something cheap and reliable!!!

Viva la SiS!

Update: Also, I only needed to update drivers in order to get the new motherboard running in my well-worn Windows XP SP1 install. This is my first ever 'seamless' install of a motherboard into an established environment! I thought it broke my Norton Antivirus, but surely enough, Auto-Update fixed that too. Three cheers!