What would a Palestinian state be like for gay people?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: Siwy
Human rights issues in Palestine are the result of radical factions in the government. Radical factions, on the other hand, exist because the oppression and collective punishment of Israeli government creates a situation where they can flourish.

This is precisely the kind of naive, muddle-headed or just plain stupid attitude I am talking about.
 

shrumpage

Golden Member
Mar 1, 2004
1,304
0
0
Originally posted by: Siwy
Originally posted by: aidanjm
I'm wondering how support for a Palestinian state can be a progressive cause, when the Palestinian Authority and Hamas have a record of persecuting harrassing and/ or killing gay people. What would "human rights" for gay people look like in a Palestinian state? I suspect there would be none. I fail to understand why some liberals/ leftists are so gung-ho in their support for Palestinians and so anti-Israel. I think it is interesting that Israel is basically the only state in the entire Middle East where gay people have any rights and are left free to live their lives.

Gay in Palestine

Gay Rights Before Palestinian Statehood

"Are these the laws for which the Palestinian street is waiting? For us to give rights to homosexuals and to lesbians, a minority of perverts and the mentally and morally sick?" - Mahmoud Zahar, Hamas

The suggestion that all Palestinians hate gays and because of that do not deserve their own statehood is ridiculous. Being gay, I would think you?re a bit more open minded but maybe I should not generalize. ;)

Human rights issues in Palestine are the result of radical factions in the government. Radical factions, on the other hand, exist because the oppression and collective punishment of Israeli government creates a situation where they can flourish.

The solution is obvious?I do not think I have to spell out for you what the solution is?do I?

And that is based on what? All the other ME countries respect human rights? I don't think so. Those other countries aren't being oppressed yet they violate human rights all the time. Women, religous, sexual -its not a response to being oppressed its based on culture and religon.

My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

How are gays treated in Isreal? anyone know?
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: shrumpage
How are gays treated in Isreal? anyone know?

Gays in Israel are treated just like heterosexual citizens, basically. They aren't singled out for special punishments. a gay couple in Israel has the same rights as any common-law heterosexual couple. they serve in the military. etc. Israel is actually a sanctuary for Palestinian gays fleeing from persecution by their own people. Basically Israel is the only state in the Middle East where gay people are treated like human beings instead of animals.
 

natto fire

Diamond Member
Jan 4, 2000
7,117
10
76
Originally posted by: aidanjm
What would a Palestinian state be like for gay people?

Why don't you move to the middle east, start one, and find out. Please make it in a place that does not have internet connectivity. If you really are upset about not being able to join the military just get a bucnh of people together and run around a field with guns shooting at each other. It would probably be about the same.
 
Jun 27, 2005
19,216
1
61
Originally posted by: EatSpam
Probably the same as any other fundie state.... like Oklahoma.

Probably... Minus the hangings and beheadings of course. And the right to sue for legitimizing marriage. And the ability to be with the one you love without the constant fear of death by stoning. And of course, no castration.

But yeah, other than that, it's probably just the same. :disgust:
 
Jun 14, 2003
10,442
0
0
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
You're talking about Islamic culture here, where women are executed for defending themselves against rapists, and where they're also forced to burn to death rather than be allowed to escape a burning building without proper attire. You could not possibly ever imagine them being accepting of gay people.

They are barbarians, worthy of only derision, scorn, and carpet bombing.


heh for what its worth, i got a LOL from that last bit

cheers!
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0

No dancing and no gays if Hamas gets its way

By Stephen Farrell

A VISION of an Islamic society that bans mixed dancing and sternly disapproves of homosexuality has been given by Mahmoud Zahar, the most senior leader of Hamas in Gaza.

After controversies when a Hamas-led council halted a dance festival and Islamist gunmen stopped a rap band performing in Gaza, Dr Zahar defended the enforcement of a strict interpretation of Islam.

?A man holds a woman by the hand and dances with her in front of everyone. Does that serve the national interest?? Dr Zahar said on the Arabic website Elaph. ?If so, why have the phenomena of corruption and prostitution become pervasive in recent years??

Because of successes by Hamas in municipal polls and its likely strong showing in January?s parliamentary elections, secular Palestinians fear that it will try to impose its ultraconservative vision on them. Its Gaza heartland has no cinemas or bars, yet the West Bank has a brewery and Ramallah restaurants serve wine.

Dr Zahar condemned homosexual marriage, saying: ?Are these the laws for which the Palestinian street is waiting? For us to give rights to homosexuals and to lesbians, a minority of perverts and the mentally and morally sick??

He denied that Hamas wanted a puritancial regime, and said its political and social institutions included women.
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.
 

compuwiz1

Admin Emeritus Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
27,112
930
126
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

What is that supposed to mean?
 

compuwiz1

Admin Emeritus Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
27,112
930
126
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

What is that supposed to mean?

It means, maybe you ought to tone it down a bit. If you do not understand that, go look up alot of your recent posts / threads. I see lots of flame baiting, but maybe you enjoy that.

 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

What is that supposed to mean?

It means, maybe you ought to tone it down a bit. If you do not understand that, go look up alot of your recent posts / threads. I see lots of flame baiting, but maybe you enjoy that.

and what exactly needs toning down in this thread?

I think it's amazing that people like you see fit to declare my legitimate threads as flame bait. newsflash, people are allowed to bring up provocative or controversial ideas.
 

compuwiz1

Admin Emeritus Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
27,112
930
126
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

What is that supposed to mean?

It means, maybe you ought to tone it down a bit. If you do not understand that, go look up alot of your recent posts / threads. I see lots of flame baiting, but maybe you enjoy that.

and what exactly needs toning down in this thread?

It's not just about this thread, Aiden, it's your posts in general.

 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

What is that supposed to mean?

It means, maybe you ought to tone it down a bit. If you do not understand that, go look up alot of your recent posts / threads. I see lots of flame baiting, but maybe you enjoy that.

and what exactly needs toning down in this thread?

It's not just about this thread, Aiden, it's your posts in general.

if you are going to address me by christian name (and I would prefer you didn't) have the decency to use correct spelling
 

MikeMike

Lifer
Feb 6, 2000
45,885
66
91
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

What is that supposed to mean?

It means, maybe you ought to tone it down a bit. If you do not understand that, go look up alot of your recent posts / threads. I see lots of flame baiting, but maybe you enjoy that.

and what exactly needs toning down in this thread?

It's not just about this thread, Aiden, it's your posts in general.

if you are going to address me by christian name (and I would prefer you didn't) have the decency to use correct spelling

Aidan, we're very sorry you think that you arent trolling, but in reality, its hatred overtime that mods build up (im at 98% hatred) and its not just one thing usually that gets people banned, but a conglomeration of many trolling threads. what you are posting is called trolling. you are using your known sexuality to your advantage by asking what other countries, which we dont live in, and to have our opinions on something we have no idea about. you are basically waiting for this thread to become a "gay bashing" thread and then jump in and shove your bigotry down others throats.
 

compuwiz1

Admin Emeritus Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
27,112
930
126
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: compuwiz1
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: shrumpage
My guess a Paletinian state would be just like every other ME country when it comes to respecting human rights.

The irony is that Arafat was a promiscuous homosexual.

You know, maybe it's time I ran around here pushing my heterosexual agenda. :roll:

What is that supposed to mean?

It means, maybe you ought to tone it down a bit. If you do not understand that, go look up alot of your recent posts / threads. I see lots of flame baiting, but maybe you enjoy that.

and what exactly needs toning down in this thread?

It's not just about this thread, Aiden, it's your posts in general.

if you are going to address me by christian name (and I would prefer you didn't) have the decency to use correct spelling

I apologize for the typo, Aidan. :)

 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
Originally posted by: Czar
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
You're talking about Islamic culture here, where women are executed for defending themselves against rapists, and where they're also forced to burn to death rather than be allowed to escape a burning building without proper attire. You could not possibly ever imagine them being accepting of gay people.

They are barbarians, worthy of only derision, scorn, and carpet bombing.

go see a shrink, you have issues


wake up, its reality.


and the reality is the islamic culture is highly bigoted against gays. it is funny how they get support from some so called leftists who should frankly know better than to support intolerance and oppression. and don't even get into rights of women:p

just look at the contrast that israel gives. sure its not perfect and the gays had to fight for their rights, but they do have some making discrimination on sexual orientation illegal in the workplace/military..and theres even a gay pride festivals:p course this is yet another reason for the "islamic" world to hate israel
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gay_rights_in_Israel



Aidan, we're very sorry you think that you arent trolling, but in reality, its hatred overtime that mods build up (im at 98% hatred) and its not just one thing usually that gets people banned, but a conglomeration of many trolling threads. what you are posting is called trolling. you are using your known sexuality to your advantage by asking what other countries, which we dont live in, and to have our opinions on something we have no idea about. you are basically waiting for this thread to become a "gay bashing" thread and then jump in and shove your bigotry down others throats.

lol, so he's bigoted for being intolerant of intolerance. its sad how twisted the thinking of some has become. and for too long we've turned a blind eye to the bigotry of the islamic world.
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
Originally posted by: Moonbeam
Originally posted by: Zysoclaplem
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
You're talking about Islamic culture here, where women are executed for defending themselves against rapists, and where they're also forced to burn to death rather than be allowed to escape a burning building without proper attire. You could not possibly ever imagine them being accepting of gay people.

They are barbarians, worthy of only derision, scorn, and carpet bombing.

I would have to agree. As mean as it sounds, it seems to be the only way to correct the problem.


The problem with being able to see an inch past your nose is that it produces the notion you can see generally.

The cure for an infected finger is to blow off the arm.

Moonbeam, your analogy is pointing in the right direction, but doesn't go quite far enough. The cure for gangrene really IS to amputate...
 

PentiumIV

Member
Feb 19, 2001
56
0
0
In the best case a gay would be beheaded in the central square in "Palestine".
Far more likely for him isto be lynched or stoned to death.

Remember there is a "honor killing" culture in Islam: a father/brother can kill a daughter for having pre-marital sex.
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: PentiumIV
In the best case a gay would be beheaded in the central square in "Palestine".
Far more likely for him isto be lynched or stoned to death.

Remember there is a "honor killing" culture in Islam: a father/brother can kill a daughter for having pre-marital sex.

Yes, and if that is the case then these barbarians don't deserve their own state in my opinion. Let them keep living in the mud and squalor until they are ready to grow up and behave like civlized human beings.
 

Czar

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
28,510
0
0
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: PentiumIV
In the best case a gay would be beheaded in the central square in "Palestine".
Far more likely for him isto be lynched or stoned to death.

Remember there is a "honor killing" culture in Islam: a father/brother can kill a daughter for having pre-marital sex.

Yes, and if that is the case then these barbarians don't deserve their own state in my opinion. Let them keep living in the mud and squalor until they are ready to grow up and behave like civlized human beings.

what gives you the right to deny them anything?
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: Czar
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: PentiumIV
In the best case a gay would be beheaded in the central square in "Palestine".
Far more likely for him isto be lynched or stoned to death.

Remember there is a "honor killing" culture in Islam: a father/brother can kill a daughter for having pre-marital sex.

Yes, and if that is the case then these barbarians don't deserve their own state in my opinion. Let them keep living in the mud and squalor until they are ready to grow up and behave like civlized human beings.

what gives you the right to deny them anything?

what gives them the right to kill gays, christians or women who leave their husband?

the fact is, those barbarians won't get their own state without heavy involvement and pressure from the international community. So the international community is in a position to make their getting their own state dependent on human rights.

 

Czar

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
28,510
0
0
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: Czar
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: PentiumIV
In the best case a gay would be beheaded in the central square in "Palestine".
Far more likely for him isto be lynched or stoned to death.

Remember there is a "honor killing" culture in Islam: a father/brother can kill a daughter for having pre-marital sex.

Yes, and if that is the case then these barbarians don't deserve their own state in my opinion. Let them keep living in the mud and squalor until they are ready to grow up and behave like civlized human beings.

what gives you the right to deny them anything?

what gives them the right to kill gays, christians or women who leave their husband?

the fact is, those barbarians won't get their own state without heavy involvement and pressure from the international community. So the international community is in a position to make their getting their own state dependent on human rights.

what gives us the right to kill cows? what gives us the right to have abortions? what gives us the right to say what is universaly right and wrong?
 

aidanjm

Lifer
Aug 9, 2004
12,411
2
0
Originally posted by: Czar
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: Czar
Originally posted by: aidanjm
Originally posted by: PentiumIV
In the best case a gay would be beheaded in the central square in "Palestine".
Far more likely for him isto be lynched or stoned to death.

Remember there is a "honor killing" culture in Islam: a father/brother can kill a daughter for having pre-marital sex.

Yes, and if that is the case then these barbarians don't deserve their own state in my opinion. Let them keep living in the mud and squalor until they are ready to grow up and behave like civlized human beings.

what gives you the right to deny them anything?

what gives them the right to kill gays, christians or women who leave their husband?

the fact is, those barbarians won't get their own state without heavy involvement and pressure from the international community. So the international community is in a position to make their getting their own state dependent on human rights.

what gives us the right to kill cows? what gives us the right to have abortions? what gives us the right to say what is universaly right and wrong?

The UN was formed and universal standards for human rights were established in response to the atrocities commited by the Nazis during WWII. Any country that is a member of the UN has agreed to uphold these standards. Ultimately moral standards are established by the community, the UN essentially represents the global community.