In all honestly, no one can answer that for you. The absolute best thing you can do, plug one set in, lsiten to 5 or 6 songs that have a wide range of frequencies and music types, then plug in the other set and do the same. Which ever sounds better is what you should keep. Speakers are alot like monitors, specs are a good basis, but DONT let that be the judge! Which monitors, buy what your eyes like, with speakers, buy (In this case keep) what your ears like. Just make sure you try to play a sample of all the types of music you like on them, to see which has the best bass, the best staging etc etc.