I've had experience with my Voodoo3 3500 TV and the Phoebe TV Tuner. I think the image quality is about the same for both although the Phoebe was easier to install in Windows XP than the Voodoo. Neither have XP drivers, but the Win2k drivers worked for the most part. My friend uses the ATI TV tuner (don't remember what the name is) and according to him, it was next to impossible to install in XP but easy in all of the other OSes. The image quality was again, about the same as the other ones. I think that the standalone cards have more features than the integrated although both the person with the Phoebe and the ATI complain that their CPU is just about maxed out when they watch TV; my computer barely even notices it and we use very similar configurations. I hope this helps you.