How could you possibly know how much you'd pay under Romney? You're comparing the existing tax structure with an undefined one that probably will never get passed?
Do you think that a Senate containing 41 Democrats is going to allow ANY substantive legislation to pass, after 2 years of complete Republican obstructionism?
Keep smoking whatever it is you're smoking.
Do you realize there's several key assumptions here?
1) How much I'd pay under Obama is simply letting the Bush tax rates expire.
- One could argue Obama could suddenly extend them for a year.
- Or perhaps Obama extends only certain parts of it.
2) I'm calculating how much I'd pay under Romney's plan.
- One could argue that it won't pass, but does the whole thing not pass or do parts of it not pass? You don't even know that. If his 20% across the board slash passes, I pay less. If he provides any relief for capital gains taxes compared to Obama, I pay less. If he allows me to opt out of social security, I pay less.
The point is how do I benefit from Obama's plan to let the Bush taxes expire? I don't.
Just to be fair I'll tell you my taxes did decrease under Obama in 2009 when he passed some sort of relief measure. It was like $10 a paycheck or something very minimal. But that was soon offset when taxes rose in the state of CA.
The point is there are assumptions and its based on what the candidates have said will happen. It's just like Tax Policy Center and all those 3rd party research groups. You perform analysis on people's PLANS. Things end up differing in the end, but that's out of our control. If you're going to make assumptions based on gut feeling, then your assumptions are as good as anyone else's pulled out of their ass.