Skoorb - My problem with that old russian system or what you see now in Cuba (was there a couple months back) is that there isn't always much motivation to work as hard as you could or should and so productivity goes down.
I think this is a big misconception. When I met my friend from Russia, I had all these nasty stereotypes that I was thinking of. The US focuses on "evil Commies", so I could only think the worst. But as I got to know more about him and what it was like for him growing up over there, I was amazed at some of the things which I didn't know about Russia.
Like for instance, the company his dad worked for over there would give away trips to a resort the company owned on the Black Sea (similar to us going to Florida or Cancun) as rewards for exceptional employees. This would be rotated around so that eventually, almost all the employees could have a chance to go. Not exactly a "communistic" idea, but yet it was pretty common at many of the workplaces there.
You talk about them not having access to any of the "media" that we have in the US. Yet, he knew so many of the rock songs that we have over here. Even stuff from the 70's like Supertramp, the Who, etc., supposedly when Russia was behind the "Iron Curtain". He had seen US movies and even US commercials and some US television shows were played. He knew about the "California Raisins" and about magazines like "Playboy".
His family owned a summer cottage, like most of the families over there, called a "dacha" which they would go to for their summer vacations and grow their own fruit trees, vineyards, and do their own fishihg. They could stay and relax there for their summer vacations.
When I heard about this, I was surprised. Many US families can't even think about having someplace in the country to go for their vacations. Especially people in the inner cities. Yet, here they were, average, inner city people, and they had this. Why, because the government owned much of the land and it came cheap. And they were listening to US rock songs and watching the "California Raisins" on TV. Not what I expected, either.
Of course, it did matter where you were in Russia. Many villages were behind the times and people were trapped because they couldn't move about. This was hard. And has only become harder for villagers with the onset of capitalism because they still can't move about. But for people like him, growing up in one of the larger cities, their urban life was not nearly as bad as some of the urban life in the US. They certainly weren't having race riots and dodging hunger (homeless people) like over here.
But they have all that nowadays since capitalism has come to town. People being killed for their apartments in Moscow, food prices skyrocketing, no jobs, significant drop in college attendance because no one can afford to go, huge increase in crime, people selling their kids organs. Some people have become phenominally rich while others have becomes so much worse off.
It's all a tradeoff.
Linflas - I know that the apartments were small, but that's typical for Europe. When I was in Paris, I stayed at a "luxury" hotel in which my room was so small I could barely open the bathroom door and get inside. And I am a smaller person. A larger, heavier American would have had much difficulty. And this was Paris. I know alot of Americans like "bigger" but I'm not one of them, so it really didn't bother me. I've lived in small apartments in the US for so long, I don't really care for large spaces. I prefer "cozy" instead of "spacious". That's just me. In fact, the house I have now only had 1500 SF and I don't even use the upstairs. Haven't been up there for weeks cause I don't really need it.