• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

What is the best Heatsink to get for this setup

S0Y73NTGR33N

Senior member
I want to upgrade from the retail heatsink, what's the best to get. Not looking for liquid cooling or anything crazy like that.

ASUS k8vse-dlx with a 3400+ Athlon 64

Thanks,

-green
 
The pipes are thermal pipes... They move the heat from the base of the heatsink to the fins better. Heatpipes/thermal pipes have been used to help cool laptop processors for quite a while now. It was only a matter of time until they made the move to desktops too.

As for the fan, you'll need to pick one. Go for either high airflow/cooling and noise, or silent and less airflow (CFM)...
 
You should do a little web-shopping, and make some decisions about cool versus quiet. Like guns and butter, you get so much Y with your choice of X, except that some options provide slightly better combinations.

For instance, watch the forum-gremlins come out of the woodwork when I invoke the fan-word "Delta":

Delta 92mm Fan

Yet this fan only generates about 42-something dB/A of noise and pushes about 72 CFM of air. We do not, however, know [meaning I don't know -- myself] whether this is a combination of motor or bearing noise and air turbulence, or mostly air turbulence, because there's a difference in "irritation-level" given the mix in noise-components. 🙂

Here's another idea that will bring out the gremlins. This thing is a combination ball-and-sleeve bearing, but you would rather have double-ball bearings for several reasons. It's rated at 50,000 hours MTBF, but generates up to 48 dB/A and pushes around 79 CFM of air:

Blue LED goo-gah Fan

Tune it down to 3,000 rpms, and the noise level is probably in the low 30's if that, but the throughput is probably still in the 60's of CFMs.

Vantec Tornado

Here, you get lots of noise of various types at all levels of CFMs. But -- you DO get nearly 119 CFMs of throughput. Check, but I think it's a double-ball bearing, and I'm also pretty sure the "life-expectation" or MTBF is 100,000 hours. Here, you can keep your computer very cool in total happiness if you are a student at the school for the deaf.

Now take a look at this Panaflo:

[High Speed Panaflo 'H1']http://www.sidewindercomputers.com/pa92hisp.html[/L]

It only has a throughput of 57 CFMs, with a noise-level around 35 dBA. I would almost guarantee that the noise is more turbulence than motor-torture.

You can find the "L1" Panaflo on the same web site, or you can check "FrozenCPU" or "BuyExtras" or any number of places to compare fans.

There MAY BE A POINT in conjunction with the XP90 or any other cooler where more CFMs do not buy further reductions in temperature. You can pretty much assure yourself that fewer CFMs will lead to increases in temperature, even as the slower fan speed will lead to decreases in noise. Personally, I think you're better off with a range of speed and CFMs for any given fan you choose, but that means, in some cases, you either have to change the fan tail from 12V to 7V, or buy a fan controller. And if you change the tail, you really can't change the CFMs and RPMs on the fly, now, can you?

Remember also that the XP90 comes with silicone-rubber grommets to deaden fan vibration transmitted through the CPU to motherboard to computer-case-sounding-board. And further, the CPU fan is almost dead-smack-center inside the computer case, and that a "closed" computer case (without a CPU blow-hole) will cut the noise significantly.

Shop until you drop!!


 
i just installed the zalman cnps7700 on an asus k8n-e deluxe w/athlon64 3400 cpu. i am waiting a week for the arctic silver 5 to cure.
 
I've been looking at some and I think I'm going with

Vantec "Tornado" Double Ball Bearing Cooling Fan, Model "TD9238H" -RETAIL
I notice it has both 3 and 4 pin connectors.. does this mean I need to plug both in or just one or the other?

Now what kind of thermal paste should I use... I've always just used Arctic Silver...

thanks again

-green
 
Originally posted by: S0Y73NTGR33N
I've been looking at some and I think I'm going with

Vantec "Tornado" Double Ball Bearing Cooling Fan, Model "TD9238H" -RETAIL
I notice it has both 3 and 4 pin connectors.. does this mean I need to plug both in or just one or the other?

Now what kind of thermal paste should I use... I've always just used Arctic Silver...

thanks again

-green

Thats going to be really really loud, consider yourseff warned.
 
Originally posted by: S0Y73NTGR33N
I've been looking at some and I think I'm going with

Vantec "Tornado" Double Ball Bearing Cooling Fan, Model "TD9238H" -RETAIL
I notice it has both 3 and 4 pin connectors.. does this mean I need to plug both in or just one or the other?

Now what kind of thermal paste should I use... I've always just used Arctic Silver...

thanks again

-green

The 3 pin connection is just the rpm sensor (I believe) while the 4 pin (molex) is for power from the PSU. You'll need to connect both up in order to use it (or at least the molex).

As for the compound, I'd suggest getting the AS ceramic compound. I believe the costs between the different AS compounds are close enough to make it an easy choice. At least it was for me.

BTW, the tornado is spec'd out at 56.4 db... :shocked:
 
Originally posted by: akira34
Originally posted by: S0Y73NTGR33N
I've been looking at some and I think I'm going with

Vantec "Tornado" Double Ball Bearing Cooling Fan, Model "TD9238H" -RETAIL
I notice it has both 3 and 4 pin connectors.. does this mean I need to plug both in or just one or the other?

Now what kind of thermal paste should I use... I've always just used Arctic Silver...

thanks again

-green
BTW, the tornado is spec'd out at 56.4 db... :shocked:

More then that I'd say, and considerably more once it's mounted to a heatsink.
 
Well, you have no need to run a Vantec Tornado at its full rpm of (near) 5,000 -- when I suffered the Tornado's mournful moan, I ran it closer to 3,000. Seat of the pants: 0.60 x 56.4 dB/A almost seems optimistic. I don't know if the assumption behind this is valid, though. There's nothing to assure that noise is linear with rpms; only to assure that it varies positively with rpms.

Reminder -- to the question about which plug to connect to mobo or power -- don't connect both. Remove the red and black power leads from the three-pin plug, and only plug it in with the yellow monitoring wire-lead if you decide the fan is best powered from a 4-pin PSU Molex plug. As I said, some mobos supply enough amperage to the CPU_FAN pins to drive the 12-watt Tornado, but I've also been advised that you would want a little "leeway". Check the mobo manual.
 
Back
Top