What is better, XBOX or Wii?

AnthroAndStargate

Golden Member
Oct 7, 2005
1,350
0
0
Answer!

Edit: I am starting to change my mind on both. Nothing will ever top computers for gaming. Vote anyway! Im curious.
 

eleison

Golden Member
Mar 29, 2006
1,319
0
0
XBOX for lonely acne boys wanting the "best" graphics while playing games all alone..

Wii for people who don't really care about graphics and who just want to play games every now and then... wii is for people who would rather be outside doing something, but instead for some reason is chilling inside with a few friends (who may also be members of the opposite sex :)..

If super realistic graphics is your thing, the wii is not for you. Wii is more about having fun..

Just my opinion.. could be wrong..

-Eleison


ps. for times when I want to be alone and want realistic graphics.. I use a computer..
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
Both?

I have a gaming PC and a PS2. I'll probably be getting a PS3 and might even get an Xbox360 too eventually.

If a platform has games you want to play, why not play them? Gamefly and/or used FTW.

Like Japanese RPGs? PS2 or 3. Like American RPGs? PC and/or Xbox 360.
Like FPS? PC, PS3 and/or Xbox
Like RTS? PC
Like Mario and Zelda? Wii
. . .
 

Eeezee

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2005
9,922
0
76
Wii, 100x Wii. Xbox 360 doesn't have any good games. The Wii has only been out for a few days and it already has more exclusive titles that are worth playing than the 360.
 

DaveSimmons

Elite Member
Aug 12, 2001
40,730
670
126
Originally posted by: Eeezee
Wii, 100x Wii. Xbox 360 doesn't have any good games. The Wii has only been out for a few days and it already has more exclusive titles that are worth playing than the 360.
There's a perfect example of YMMV.

You're probably a Zelda fan, and don't like shooters like Gears of War or Rainbow Six or RPGs like Oblivion. That's fine, as long as you realize "worth playing" is very subjective.

Also, wii versions of multi-platform games are just not going to look as good as PS3 or Xbox360. Aside from being 480p instead of 720p, the wii just doesn't have the power of the other 2. Which is fine if you don't care, but again YMMV.

Edit: Bruce Lee, Coke, nVidia.
 

JujuFish

Lifer
Feb 3, 2005
11,185
897
136
Essentially everything I'd play on an XBox 360, I can play on the PC, and do. However, first party Nintendo games alone easily justify purchasing a Wii.
 

Eeezee

Diamond Member
Jul 23, 2005
9,922
0
76
Originally posted by: DaveSimmons
Originally posted by: Eeezee
Wii, 100x Wii. Xbox 360 doesn't have any good games. The Wii has only been out for a few days and it already has more exclusive titles that are worth playing than the 360.
There's a perfect example of YMMV.

You're probably a Zelda fan, and don't like shooters like Gears of War or Rainbow Six or RPGs like Oblivion. That's fine, as long as you realize "worth playing" is very subjective.

Also, wii versions of multi-platform games are just not going to look as good as PS3 or Xbox360. Aside from being 480p instead of 720p, the wii just doesn't have the power of the other 2. Which is fine if you don't care, but again YMMV.

Edit: Bruce Lee, Coke, nVidia.

Here's a little about me

I am a Zelda fan, but the ONLY Zelda I've owned and played all the way through was Link to the Past. So I'm no more of a fan than the average person who has owned one Zelda game. I watched my friend play some of the Zelda game that was on the N64, and I've seen a preview for the Gamecube Zelda. Oh, and I played about 3 hours of the Gameboy Zelda, borrowing it from a friend for a little bit.

I love Half-Life 2 and currently own Resistance: Fall of Man. I dislike Counterstrike, but I put hundreds of hours into Jedi Knight and Jedi Knight II and its expansion. Gears of War looks awesome, but 1 game does not make me want to buy a $300 system. I consider Halo to be a cheap ripoff of Unreal Tournament with a much better storyline, which I can respect, but no one plays multiplayer Halo because of the storyline.

I own Oblivion and love RPGs. I own every Final Fantasy ever made for a console except FF1, 2, 3, and 11 (didn't like the MMO aspect). Luckily for me, I used an escape clause, that the Wii has more good exclusive games. In other words, Oblivion for computer >> Oblivion for Xbox 360.

Why do I want the Wii? Lots of reasons. In particular,
1) Zelda (it will be the 2nd zelda I've ever owned and the 4th or 5th that I've ever played)
2) Huge selection of OLDER games, so now I can play great hits like Eternal Darkness, the Metroid series, etc. since I haven't owned a Nintendo console since the SNES
3) Red Steel looks awesome despite mixed reviews
4) Super Smash Bros is one of my favorite Nintendo games, and I look forward to playing the latest one
5) Did I mention the game library? This is an instant win for someone like me who hasn't owned a nintendo console in over a decade

As for graphics, I have seen a real Playstation 3 in action and a real Xbox 360 in action. From what little I have seen, the Playstation 3 is the clear winner. They were on identical TVs on a show floor in Best Buy. The Playstation 3 looked like it was prerendered real-life video, but sure enough, it was actually a playable game that just looked amazing.

Why did I prefer the PS3 over the Xbox 360? Again, gaming library. I'm not here for amazing graphics, I'm here for amazing GAMES. If I want graphics I'll buy a high definition movie. The PS3 has Resistance Fall of Man and will have Metal Gear Solid 4, FF13 (in 3 different games), and other appealing titles (some of the preview videos look awesome). Xbox 360 has Gears of War, which I'd love to play, but there just aren't enough great exclusive games there.

Frankly, PC gaming beats them all. I can't really compare PC gaming to the Wii since it's using some new tricks, but I'm sure the PC market will move to meet it.

Edit: In reply, Bruce Lee, Pepsi, ATI. Those are my preferences there. I absolutely agree, YMMV, but you can not assume anything about a person based on their console preference. I love RPGs and FPSs, but I dislike the Xbox 360. Why? Not enough exclusive titles. Clearly that's a big deal to me.
 

funboy6942

Lifer
Nov 13, 2001
15,309
393
126
Id say you have a better chance of the Wii still working 6monts or later. I keep reading about people getting pissed about the red rings of death in under a years time. If Im shelling out $400 for the console and another $200 for the HD dvd drive then damnit it better last me 5 years plus. My money as soon as I can afford it is on the Wii.
 

mugs

Lifer
Apr 29, 2003
48,920
46
91
Originally posted by: AnthroAndStargate

Edit: I am starting to change my mind on both. Nothing will ever top computers for gaming. Vote anyway! Im curious.

If you feel that way, I think Wii would definitely be a better choice for you. Wii will offer you an experience you can't really get with a PC, at least not yet. Xbox 360 will give you a lot of the same types of games you can play on your PC.
 

everman

Lifer
Nov 5, 2002
11,288
1
0
They're two different things. If you ask me which one will be more "fun" in a year, I'd say Wii. I think this new controller setup will help developers concentrate more on gameplay just as the DS did.
 

ntdz

Diamond Member
Aug 5, 2004
6,989
0
0
Originally posted by: Eeezee
Wii, 100x Wii. Xbox 360 doesn't have any good games. The Wii has only been out for a few days and it already has more exclusive titles that are worth playing than the 360.

Gears of War is quite possibly the best game ever and you're clamoring about how awesome Zelda and Mario are...yeah, 10 years ago when I was 12.
 

Fingolfin269

Lifer
Feb 28, 2003
17,948
31
91
Completely different systems. It's better to compare the 360 to the PS3 and the Wii as a secondary imho.
 

schneiderguy

Lifer
Jun 26, 2006
10,801
89
91
Originally posted by: Eeezee
Wii, 100x Wii. Xbox 360 doesn't have any good games. The Wii has only been out for a few days and it already has more exclusive titles that are worth playing than the 360.

the wii has no games that have gotten above a 9 on gamespot

the xbox360 has five

ouch