what fan for XP-120

ShadowBlade

Diamond Member
Feb 11, 2005
4,263
0
0
i searched for this and all the fans people reccomended had LED lights in them, i dont need any more of those
it also has to be quiet, i cant hear my computer at all from about 3 feet away, and id like to maintain that
 

Elfear

Diamond Member
May 30, 2004
7,165
824
126
Originally posted by: mariok2006
Originally posted by: Elfear
Sanyo Denki 120mmx38mm. 103cfm@39db

he said quiet...

I would suggest the panaflo also


Sorry, I use mine with a fan controller so noise isn't an issue. Should have read a little closer.
 

ericlala

Senior member
Apr 18, 2005
387
0
0
i use nexus 120 so i can just plug it in the psu to run at max speed without getting a fan controller
 

TheGoat Eater

Golden Member
Mar 20, 2005
1,044
0
0
thegoateater.com
Originally posted by: mariok2006
Originally posted by: Elfear
Sanyo Denki 120mmx38mm. 103cfm@39db

he said quiet...

I would suggest the panaflo also


If you want to cool the F*%k out of it these would also be great

SILVERSTONE FM121 -> 110.03CFM ; comes with a fan controller ;)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16811999344

Panaflo 120x38mm Ultra High Speed Fan (FBA12G12U) - 115 CFM
http://www.frozencpu.com/fan-157.html?id=Kbu5ILdz

YS Tech 120x38mm Fan - 125CFM
http://www.frozencpu.com/fan-22.html?id=Kbu5ILdz

Sunon 120x38mm Fan - 108 CFM
http://www.frozencpu.com/fan-24.html?id=Kbu5ILdz
 

imported_rod

Golden Member
Apr 13, 2005
1,788
0
0
Panaflo are great. Otherwise, a SilenX fan is quiet, but doesnt move huge amounts of air.

I guess it depends on whether cooling or silence is more important to you.

RoD
 

Jhhnn

IN MEMORIAM
Nov 11, 1999
62,365
14,685
136
The 120mm L- series panaflos and 4412FGL Papst fans are pretty much the standard in low noise 120mm fans. There are quieter ones out there, but the price can become astronomical.

This Yate Loon model has quite a following, as well-

http://www.jab-tech.com/catalog/YATE_LOON_120mm_Case_Fan__D12SL12_p_3009.html

If the color doesn't make you want to puke, that is... But, the price is right, and you don't seem like a windowed case kind of guy, anyway...

 

BonzaiDuck

Lifer
Jun 30, 2004
16,638
2,029
126
The XP-120 has a minimum thermal resistance of 0.167. In order to "get there," you need to push a certain airflow rate through its fins (in CFM). Anything above the required CFM will not improve thermal resistance of the cooler, nor will it cool down the CPU (for that reason) any more than at the "optimum thermal resistance."

However, the XP-120 was also thoughtfully designed to promote airflow around the hot motherboard components (mosfets, chipset -- even VGA card). It is with these components that pushing more air through the cooler than necessary to provide maximum CPU cooling will still pay off -- if that's what you want to do. Further, building a restrictive motherboard duct of foam-board or lexan to restrict CPU fan exhaust (low volume, high airflow) around those components and duct the air immediately from the back of the case -- will provide even greater advantage, but you must be willing to take the time to build and install the ducting.

All of the fans mentioned above -- I note the Silverstone, Sunon, YS-Tech and especially Panaflo models -- should do the job for cooling the CPU.

The ducting of the motherboard also serves to deaden fan noise. In my case, I chose a Delta fan (lighter than the Panaflo) which spins up to 3,700 rpm offering an airflow rate of 142 CFM. It only takes between 95 CFM and 120 CFM to maximize CPU cooling, and many of these fans will provide some of that CFM range by spinning around 2,400rpm.

What I did with the Delta proves something people looking for noiselessness in fans overlook with high-airflow/high-rpm models: at lower speeds, they can be just as quiet as fans made to run at those speeds. So I hooked up my Delta to the motherboard CPU fan-header, ducted the motherboard, installed Alfredo Comparetti's "SpeedFan," and set the program to hold the fan speed at around 2,600 rpm below a threshold that is close to my "load" CPU temperature. As it reaches that threshold, it spins up to its maximum 3,700 rpm. As the CPU drops below the threshold, it spins down again to its 2,600rpm setting.

This configuration lowered my chipset temperature by some 8F to 10F degrees at either idle or load CPU usage.

One more thing. I was disappointed with YS-Tech's 120x38mm offering. I do not believe it really provides the rated maximum airflow of around 110 CFM.

I must have tested some ten models of fans before settling on the Delta. Many here would favor Panaflo fans, and I agree that they are faithful to their air-flow spec while holding the noise level down. But the noise level of my Delta at the same rpm is about the same as the Panaflo. Also, I think the Panaflo model I looked at was a bit heavier than the Delta, while the lightest of all 120x38mm fans was the YS-Tech.
 

milleron

Senior member
May 20, 2005
241
0
0
Originally posted by: Jhhnn
The 120mm L- series panaflos and 4412FGL Papst fans are pretty much the standard in low noise 120mm fans. There are quieter ones out there, but the price can become astronomical.

This Yate Loon model has quite a following, as well-

http://www.jab-tech.com/catalog/YATE_LOON_120mm_Case_Fan__D12SL12_p_3009.html

If the color doesn't make you want to puke, that is... But, the price is right, and you don't seem like a windowed case kind of guy, anyway...
The original poster wants a fan for an XP120. For use on the Thermalright heatsinks, the corners must be open -- i.e., have no post conntecting the top and bottom surfaces where the mounting screw is inserted. I can't tell from the photo if the Yate Loon fits that spec. Does it?

Ron

 

JBDan

Platinum Member
Dec 7, 2004
2,333
0
0
Originally posted by: milleron
Originally posted by: Jhhnn
The 120mm L- series panaflos and 4412FGL Papst fans are pretty much the standard in low noise 120mm fans. There are quieter ones out there, but the price can become astronomical.

This Yate Loon model has quite a following, as well-

http://www.jab-tech.com/catalog/YATE_LOON_120mm_Case_Fan__D12SL12_p_3009.html

If the color doesn't make you want to puke, that is... But, the price is right, and you don't seem like a windowed case kind of guy, anyway...
The original poster wants a fan for an XP120. For use on the Thermalright heatsinks, the corners must be open -- i.e., have no post conntecting the top and bottom surfaces where the mounting screw is inserted. I can't tell from the photo if the Yate Loon fits that spec. Does it?

Ron

No it doesn't, but with a dremel tool, problem solved if you want to go through the trouble.
 
Feb 19, 2001
20,155
23
81
I say get the high speed panaflo that does like 40 DB or 45 DB. You can attach a voltage controller and drop it down to the low speeds.