Depends on the type and size of tire. Higher performance tires will have higher pressure ratings. That and I think my spare tire is something like 65 psi but the regular tires are 32/30 psi. I think the door sticker only applies to the stock tires, but I'm not too sure.40 psi on the tires? Read the sticker on the door. I am sure it tells you to do less than that...although mine is the 2.3L with 17inch money wasters.
Are you using stock tires? Changing the tires can radically change the gas mileage. Big grippy expensive tires are usually bad for gas mileage because they're built for performance.Also, if this is the big 2.3L, how did you get that mileage with an auto? I have taken straight highways trips for 400 miles and I had to refill before I got there.