what do you guys think of manufactured homes?

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.
Aug 27, 2002
10,043
2
0
My parents have a 4 year old Fleetwood (3bedroom, 2bath doublewide), it's actually very nice. They seem to have come a long way structural wise in the last 10 or so years.
 

imported_weadjust

Golden Member
Apr 23, 2004
1,561
1
0
I am a claims adjuster and have a large account with an insurance co. that insures manufactured homes. Inspected 5000 plus manufactured homes for damages due to fire, water, wind, etc.

I would avoid a manufacture home at all cost. Re-sale sucks. The payment on a new manufactured home is cheaper than a used one. People in this price range shop by payment amount.

House is stapled together. Roof shingles blow off in minimal wind. Plumbing is cheap and water damage from leaking plumbing is a common occurence. Vinyl siding cheap and will blow off or get holes from debris from lawn mower. HVAC unit is cheap. Fiberglass tubs and sinks very thin material that cracks. Get the picture.

Bottom line most everthing in the house is the least expensive product on the market.

If you want a second opinio ask Dale Earnahart, Jr. he lives in a manufactured home. Featured on MTV Cribs.
 

BriGy86

Diamond Member
Sep 10, 2004
4,537
1
91
i heard that now days if they lay down a neighborhood full of houses that are made up of about 3-4 diff plans

they are built very cheap

take a look at the warped siding and nonexistant overhangs
 

imported_weadjust

Golden Member
Apr 23, 2004
1,561
1
0
Crab

Yeah they make it look good on the inside and outside, but the quality of the products used for costrution are low quality. Light fixtures, doors, cabinets, plumbing, hvac, the list goes on.
 

crab

Diamond Member
Jan 29, 2001
7,330
19
81
Looks good to me

I've been in plenty of them. Quality is pretty much top notch as long as you pick a decent manufacturer. What is used is largely up to the buyer.
 

ColdFusion718

Diamond Member
Mar 4, 2000
3,496
9
81
Originally posted by: batmang
just curious... housing in tucson is RIDICULOUS. and im looking at newer manufactured homes... they arent too shabby. im used to living in a 1 bedroom apt, and im about ready to kill myself cause im so sick of having no space, etc.

used homes are unreasonably priced, and my lease is up soon.

some of these manufactured homes are very nice... and so is the price.
these newer manufactured homes are built very well compared to how they used to be.

a lot of the ones ive seen actually have cable tv and cable internet access.. and they dont have septic tanks. (yay!)

theres a couple i found that even have single car garages.

3 bedroom, 2 bath, single car garage, 1,600sq ft, $124k.

a house with the same features.... hell, lets take off the garge... easily $160-180 for a decent one... im talking on thats not even in a good area of town. if its in a good area of town.. $200k plus easy.

Dude, you think $200K is expensive for a house? Try $600K here for the same house in California. Stop whining; it's actually a pretty good deal for $125-200K.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
I think it comes down to the particular builder. Some of them flat out suck and bring down overall impressions of things.

My parents live in a modular home that is 2500 sq/ft with a full basement of equal unfinshed footage and a 1200 sq/ft garage. My father has bricked up the entire outside of the house. You'd never know the home was brought in on a couple flatbed semi trailers. And it's appraised at over $300,000 which is pretty good in Peoria, IL.

The only complaint with it is the nickel and diming as mentioned. My parents opted out of many of the "upgrades" and put in much better flooring/options on their own.

I'd rather have my home put together in an automated factory with studs that are actually every 16" apart than to be half assed stick built together by some moron with who couldn't use a tape measure to save his own life and has studs laid out completely all over the place.

I've seen some really shoddy stick built homes slapped together as absolutely fast as possible and with the lowest quality materials they could shove in there.
 
Aug 16, 2001
22,505
4
81
Originally posted by: caitlion
im sorry to be judgemental, but i dont think you will find a nice neighborhood to live in with a trailer.

just because the homes look nicer doesn't mean the residents living around you will be. you never know though.

oh and either way, if youre looking to buy... do it soon. housing in tucson is getting pretty ridiculous compared to how it used to be, but its still a lot cheaper than most places and the prices will just keep raising.

Oh man ain't that the truth.
I had planned to get a house in late 2003 (in Tucson) but before that ever happened our new POS Director said 'we're closing down the Tucson operations and move everyone to Charlottesville VA....'
Well fsck...... if I had a house I would have made close to a 75% gain by now.
Tucson is getting nuts.
 

vi edit

Elite Member
Super Moderator
Oct 28, 1999
62,484
8,345
126
Originally posted by: FrustratedUser
Originally posted by: caitlion
im sorry to be judgemental, but i dont think you will find a nice neighborhood to live in with a trailer.

just because the homes look nicer doesn't mean the residents living around you will be. you never know though.

oh and either way, if youre looking to buy... do it soon. housing in tucson is getting pretty ridiculous compared to how it used to be, but its still a lot cheaper than most places and the prices will just keep raising.

Oh man ain't that the truth.
I had planned to get a house in late 2003 (in Tucson) but before that ever happened our new POS Director said 'we're closing down the Tucson operations and move everyone to Charlottesville VA....'
Well fsck...... if I had a house I would have made close to a 75% gain by now.
Tucson is getting nuts.

I still kick myself for not buying in Phoenix (well Gilbert actually) in May '04.

Could have bought a very nice place for under $200,000. Could have sold it now for almost $400,000.

:(
 
Aug 16, 2001
22,505
4
81
Originally posted by: vi_edit
Originally posted by: FrustratedUser
Originally posted by: caitlion
im sorry to be judgemental, but i dont think you will find a nice neighborhood to live in with a trailer.

just because the homes look nicer doesn't mean the residents living around you will be. you never know though.

oh and either way, if youre looking to buy... do it soon. housing in tucson is getting pretty ridiculous compared to how it used to be, but its still a lot cheaper than most places and the prices will just keep raising.

Oh man ain't that the truth.
I had planned to get a house in late 2003 (in Tucson) but before that ever happened our new POS Director said 'we're closing down the Tucson operations and move everyone to Charlottesville VA....'
Well fsck...... if I had a house I would have made close to a 75% gain by now.
Tucson is getting nuts.

I still kick myself for not buying in Phoenix (well Gilbert actually) in May '04.

Could have bought a very nice place for under $200,000. Could have sold it now for almost $400,000.

:(

I just hate the circumstances. I love Tucson and wanted to stay for a long time.
Back in 2003 $150k got you a REALLY nice place, then something happened to the market there. This last spring the market was so hot the realtors couldn't keep up. :Q
A coworker here in C-ville (VA) quit and accepted a job in Tucson. He would call the realtor in the morning to see a new listing in the afternoon. Realtor called back 3 hours later and said it was sold. This happened many many times. :Q
 

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: SampSon
To clear up how nice manufactured homes can be, I appraised one that was 3000+- sq feet, 2.5 stories, full basement and worth approx. 350K.
Don't expect these idiots to understand modern manufactured home construction. They are not trailers.
Unfortunately, the negative attitude towards manufactured homes is infamous in lending, especially right now, so I recommend that people not buy them simply because of the difficulties in obtaining solid competitive financing with a manufactured home. This difficulty in obtaining financing has significant negative effects on resale value.

To clarify: trailers, manufactured homes, and modular homes are three entirely different animals.
A trailer is a freakin' RV or (if you must) an old single-wide mobile home built prior to 1977 (called "pre-HUD" in industry terms).
A manufactured home is constructed off-site and shipped in large pieces (usually semi-trailer size) for assembly at the site. It is built according to federal HUD codes, and each pre-assembled piece has a stamped HUD "tag" with specific ID number.
A modular home is constructed off-site and shipped in smaller pieces for assembly at the site and is built according to local county building codes. <-- that is the key difference

As far as lending is concerned, a trailer is a chattel -- private property, not real estate. Manufactured homes are, with certain conditions, considered real estate but are currently difficult to obtain premier financing with. Modular homes, because they are built to local codes, are generally considered the same as regular frame-built homes but appraisal comps must show that the modular home is typical and acceptable to the market.
 

BriGy86

Diamond Member
Sep 10, 2004
4,537
1
91
it doesn't matter what a house costs in cali vs. MN

people make more in cali. so they are able to blow more on a house, its all relative
 

PingSpike

Lifer
Feb 25, 2004
21,758
603
126
Some of the new ones are quite nice. I've heard a lot of places that they have improved signifigantly.
 

Fritzo

Lifer
Jan 3, 2001
41,920
2,161
126
Newer ones are actually really nice! You'd be suprised at the build quality and features you get in them now.
 

Anonemous

Diamond Member
May 19, 2003
7,361
1
71
I'm confused, what's the difference between manufactured homes and regular homes? :confused: Aren't they both built with the same materials? Always thought maybe manufactured homes may look alike, ie. cookie cutter homes, but if they are cheaper than I would go with them.
 

sygyzy

Lifer
Oct 21, 2000
14,001
4
76
Originally posted by: BriGy86
it doesn't matter what a house costs in cali vs. MN

people make more in cali. so they are able to blow more on a house, its all relative

Wrong. They don't make *that* much more. It's not all relative if you don't keep proportions the same.
 

mrrman

Diamond Member
Feb 8, 2004
8,497
3
0
manufactured homes to me are junk...no solid walls, cant hang pictures because no real support, cheap in my mind
 

GeekDrew

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2000
9,099
19
81
Originally posted by: mrrman
manufactured homes to me are junk...no solid walls, cant hang pictures because no real support, cheap in my mind

that depends on what company made it, etc. i've seen some that you can literally lean on and a wall will collapse... and i've seen some that are almost as sturdy as a "regular" house.
 

iamwiz82

Lifer
Jan 10, 2001
30,772
13
81
Originally posted by: mrrman
manufactured homes to me are junk...no solid walls, cant hang pictures because no real support, cheap in my mind

Have you not seen current stick builds?

 

imported_Pablo

Diamond Member
Jan 20, 2002
3,714
1
0
Originally posted by: caitlion
Originally posted by: SampSon
Originally posted by: caitlion
im sorry to be judgemental, but i dont think you will find a nice neighborhood to live in with a trailer.

just because the homes look nicer doesn't mean the residents living around you will be. you never know though.

oh and either way, if youre looking to buy... do it soon. housing in tucson is getting pretty ridiculous compared to how it used to be, but its still a lot cheaper than most places and the prices will just keep raising.
Not to be mean, but I suggest you stop talking about a topic you know nothing about.

thats not mean at all.

you see i live in tucson and i have lots of friends that live in different kinds of neighborhoods. one even that lives in a "nicer" trailerpark type place. i live in a pretty nice, middle-to-upper class neighborhood... someone moved into an empty lot and brought their house with them apparently. eventually they were forced to leave because they made a mess of the property and it was causing a decrease in the value of the houses near it. basically though, the low prices obviously attract people with less money, a lot of whom are not very good people. and thats not meant to be judgemental, because i know there are definitely very nice and good natured people as well, but im speaking about the majority of them from my personal experience.

unless of course you are talking about buying a house, which i admit i dont know too much about, but i certainly know that the prices are increasing like crazy.



Just to clarify here again, we're NOT discussing trailers. Or nice trailers. Talking about houses that are built in pieces and then brought in for final assembly on site. There are no wheels under these things.
 

imported_Pablo

Diamond Member
Jan 20, 2002
3,714
1
0
Originally posted by: iamwiz82
Originally posted by: mrrman
manufactured homes to me are junk...no solid walls, cant hang pictures because no real support, cheap in my mind

Have you not seen current stick builds?

Seriously. My house was built about 1991, and my buddy bought a modular home, and to me, his feels more solid.