I havent run a HD scan from my ultimate boot cd yet.
Just completed WD diagnostics tools, all passed.
Computer Management/Event Viewer/System Log gives me an atapi error on IDE port 2. 50% sure that is the port this HD is connected to.
Also, in the event viewer, there are quite a few errors titled "disc" with eventID 51. This is for another drive, that appears to be working 100%. Diagnostics compare it within 1% to another of the same drive model in my system. The error is listed as a controller error.