Well, I just got back from the Computer Store.
I returned my second P95f+ and took a third one, since they didn't have any other brands in stock. They could have ordered me an NEC/Mitsu AS900 (which doesn't have as high a refresh capability) but then I would have been waiting for a month to see if it was any good.
So, we pulled another P95f+ and tried it out, and it is the best yet of all three I've tried.
So far I have been able to run @ 1600x1200x85Hz with excellent clarity.
I have also tired it at the higher resolutions and found that 1856x1392x72Hz is very nice as well, although text is a bit small (but I might try it with larger fonts).
Anyhow, while I am still nervous about the reliability of the monitor, at least the initial quality of this particular sample is quite good.
After all this, all I can say is that if you are buying a CRT, be sure to go to a store and test out the actual monitor you will be taking home. Plan on spending some time so you can let it warm up (1/2 hour at least) and be sure to test it @ the resolutions at which you wish to use it.
I'm knocking on wood as I say this, but so far I am quite happy with this third (and hopefully final) p95f+
Also, I wouldn't take a Samsung 955 becaus the refresh on that is terrible. If you plan on using it @ 1280x1024, then it is OK, but if you want to run @ 1600x1200 then you are stuck @ 68Hz which is barely usable. If you want a Samsung, check out Best Buy because they have the 997 for the same price as the 955. The 997 has much better refresh rates, so is a better overall choice (IMO).
http://www.bestbuy.com/site/olspage.jsp?id=1077629948643&skuId=6554604&productCategoryId=cat01011&type=product
I would also check out the NEC/Mitsu's to see if you can find one with the features and performance you like.
Again though, after reading reviews online, it is evident that pretty much all the CRT MFG's have quality problems, and that's why I strongly recommend going to a store to buy the monitor.
Good luck!
-D'oh!