• We should now be fully online following an overnight outage. Apologies for any inconvenience, we do not expect there to be any further issues.

Viet Cong Vets for Kerry Refute Swiftboat Book

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Riprorin

Banned
Apr 25, 2000
9,634
0
0
Originally posted by: conjur
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
How lame you are Rip. If you had the slightist bit of knowledge about the Viet Nam War you'd know that the Viet Cong were South Vietnamese Irregular Guerillas, not North Vietnamsese.

Huh?

Viet Cong

<sigh>

http://www.encyclopedia.com/html/V/VietC1ong.asp
(v??t´ kông) , officially Viet Nam Cong San [Vietnamese Communists], People's Liberation Armed Forces in South Vietnam. The term was originally applied by Diem's regime to Communist troops (about 10,000) left in hideouts in South Vietnam after the Geneva Conference of 1954, following the French Indochina War (1946-54). Most Communist troops, according to the agreements, had withdrawn to North Vietnam. Supported and later directed by North Vietnam, the Viet Cong first tried subversive tactics to overthrow the South Vietnamese regime, then resorted to open warfare (see Vietnam War ). They were subsequently reinforced by huge numbers of North Vietnamese troops infiltrating south, and aided in the reunification of Vietnam following the collapse of South Vietnam in 1975.


It doesn't matter.

Your original post is from a satirical website and you still don't realize that your "article" is a j-o-k-e. Literally!

Obviously it's satirical. Geez.

I think it makes a valid point though.
 

conjur

No Lifer
Jun 7, 2001
58,686
3
0
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: conjur
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
How lame you are Rip. If you had the slightist bit of knowledge about the Viet Nam War you'd know that the Viet Cong were South Vietnamese Irregular Guerillas, not North Vietnamsese.

Huh?

Viet Cong

<sigh>

http://www.encyclopedia.com/html/V/VietC1ong.asp
(v??t´ kông) , officially Viet Nam Cong San [Vietnamese Communists], People's Liberation Armed Forces in South Vietnam. The term was originally applied by Diem's regime to Communist troops (about 10,000) left in hideouts in South Vietnam after the Geneva Conference of 1954, following the French Indochina War (1946-54). Most Communist troops, according to the agreements, had withdrawn to North Vietnam. Supported and later directed by North Vietnam, the Viet Cong first tried subversive tactics to overthrow the South Vietnamese regime, then resorted to open warfare (see Vietnam War ). They were subsequently reinforced by huge numbers of North Vietnamese troops infiltrating south, and aided in the reunification of Vietnam following the collapse of South Vietnam in 1975.


It doesn't matter.

Your original post is from a satirical website and you still don't realize that your "article" is a j-o-k-e. Literally!

Obviously it's satirical. Geez.

I think it makes a valid point though.

LOL!

Go ahead and try and play like you didn't know. You found that link in either an email or some right-wing nutcase website. You never read the link (that's rather obvious).

You pwned yourself! :laugh: :laugh:
 

Red Dawn

Elite Member
Jun 4, 2001
57,529
3
0
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Obviously it's satirical. Geez.

I think it makes a valid point though.
How the Fsck would you know? Were you even alive during that Fscked up war? If so do you have any recollection of it?
 

Riprorin

Banned
Apr 25, 2000
9,634
0
0
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Obviously it's satirical. Geez.

I think it makes a valid point though.
How the Fsck would you know? Were you even alive during that Fscked up war? If so do you have any recollection of it?

I was born in 1960, so yes, I have a recollection of it.
 

Shad0hawK

Banned
May 26, 2003
1,456
0
0
Originally posted by: LunarRay
Folks talk a lot different when they are out of harms way. Ever notice that? Folks getting a cut from shrapnel thank God or who ever they thank that the crap didn't do greater damage. Shrapnel flies in a randomly chosen path.


shrapnel really flies in a random path? WOW! of course many soldiers would not bother with a purple heart from scratches when others get much more seriously wounded, except of course glory hunting liars.


Originally posted by: LunarRayWhat Kerry said or did post his service in Vietnam has nothing to do with his time there. I don't care if he was there a week or a day or four months.. he was there and that says a lot about him.. Bush was where? In any event, Kerry and many folks saw the promise to end that war turn into a farce.. and, a waste of life. I am glad there were folks like Kerry to help stop the useless death.. what could we have gained there and what would it have taken to gain it.. Eliminate all the North to preserve the South?

that tops the list of ignorant statement s i have seen on this board

Originally posted by: LunarRayWhen folks use terms like 'Komrad' they need looking at the context of Kerry's efforts. It would be like sending thousands and thousands of kids to Iraq to die when at the end of the day nothing will be gained but freedom for those who survive there.. and all the dead ... what did they gain..?

context of his efforts? like medal hunting to make himself out the hero he is not, then participating in protests displaying the flag of the enemy, then turning out to not have thrown his medals way so he could later tell the ignorant sheep what a hero he is? of course all the deception on his part "does not matter"

Originally posted by: LunarRayYou do realize that the Vietnam issue was predicated on lie after lie. It is a patriot who'll stand up against the power of the government to expose the lies.

by telling more of them? what "lies" are you referring to?

Originally posted by: LunarRayWhen someone calls Kerry a commie or says that he is not welcome at Fort Hood they say that I am not welcome either... and to that I can only laugh.. the brush is painting very wide.. and it don't seem to touch Mr. Bush... whose efforts to avoid serving in Vietnam seem to be what the current crop of Veteran laud... well.. ok.. there it is.

go ahead and laugh, niether of you will be missed...as for bush not going, what exactly does that have to do with kerry?

not a blessed thing, that's what.
 

CaptnKirk

Lifer
Jul 25, 2002
10,053
0
71
I was born in 1960, so yes, I have a recollection of it.

What ? From 5 years old to a Pre-Teeny Bopper makes you an expert ?
It was done &amp; we were gone before you could even know that it happened.

Did you get together with the kids in your neighborhood and play 'Cowboys and Commies'

You don't have a clue, or even know where to buy a clue.
 

Riprorin

Banned
Apr 25, 2000
9,634
0
0
Originally posted by: CaptnKirk
I was born in 1960, so yes, I have a recollection of it.

What ? From 5 years old to a Pre-Teeny Bopper makes you an expert ?
It was done &amp; we were gone before you could even know that it happened.

Did you get together with the kids in your neighborhood and play 'Cowboys and Commies'

You don't have a clue, or even know where to buy a clue.

I was a precocious kid.
 

Perknose

Forum Director & Omnipotent Overlord
Forum Director
Oct 9, 1999
46,873
10,668
147
Originally posted by: Riprorin
I was a precocious kid.
Funny, that's how I think of you now!

. . . As a precocious nine year old whose computer skillz have amplified your shallow and severely lacking understanding of the world beyond all appropriate measure.

When you first posted this particular piece of trash yesterday, a deep anger welled up inside of me. I couldn't quite understand why. I mean, of all the worthless poo you've flung up here, this lame satrical piece seemed relatively inconsequential.

Still, I kept coming back to it, trying to resist the urge to reply. I even typed out a long response, then ultimately quashed it. Finally (the lovely and talented) Lunar Ray came along, and in a series of heartfelt posts, exposed the source of my all too strong emotions. LR said it all best:
Kerry was in Vietnam. Kerry was awarded the Silver and Bronze stars along with other awards. He earned them under the same process that all the rest of us did.
Now when Bushites call Kerry a fraud they call all the rest of us frauds too... To that all I can say is...
-----------------
What this does is puts a cloud on anything I and all the others may have done during the time I or they served there. And, I resent it..
----------------
Folks talk a lot different when they are out of harms way. Ever notice that? Folks getting a cut from shrapnel thank God or who ever they thank that the crap didn't do greater damage. Shrapnel flies in a randomly chosen path.
-----------------
When someone calls Kerry a commie or says that he is not welcome at Fort Hood they say that I am not welcome either... and to that I can only laugh.. the brush is painting very wide.. and it don't seem to touch Mr. Bush... whose efforts to avoid serving in Vietnam seem to be what the current crop of Veteran laud... well.. ok.. there it is.
And, yes, there it is. Thank you, LR

My response took a different tack. I was finally fully fed up with your worthless trash. In my quashed post, I asked how much money it would take for you to promise never to come back here again. $1,000? I was willing to put up the first $100. I was certain we could easily raise the rest.

But I knew in my heart you would never actually accept such an offer, so I let it go. I have to let your presence here, and the mindless crap you continually post here, go. I am forced to accept that you have no true idea of the deeper ramifications of the mindless mud you sling.

You don't have the first clue about the terrible, awful depredations of the Vietnam War or of the hundreds of thousands of men who fought in that runaway mistake.

Sometimes I think the nearly 60,000 dead are the lucky ones -- sometimes. At least, hopefully, their souls are at peace. But those many, many more who were maimed -- either physically or psychologically or both -- were also thrown to the endless hounds of hell, and for what?

The Vietnam War was tactical mistake, as I believe this Iraqi war is also. My father, a decorated WWII Navy combat veteran and a life long conservative Republican, was quietly but firmly oppossed to the Vietnam War from the get go.

We all made our choices back then, and many had that choice made for them. John Kerry went and served, and then made sure he got to the front lines of the shooting war. You who have not been under live fire haven't the first fvcking clue! He could just as easily have been killed out there on those narrow rivers, and you somehow make light of that!

You who sit there so safely behind your keyboards 35 years later and let your ideological dislike let you say that John Kerry risked death primarily for some tin make me want to puke. You can't even begin to know what you're talking about.

When his nation needed him, John Kerry served. He put himself in harm's way. For this, he has my knowing and unalloyed respect. I have none for the Dub.

And then Kerry came home and had the courage and integrity to speak out. If personal advancement were his primary goal, he could have easily used his decorated combat status as a ticket to political success. Instead, he risked all to speak the truth. He was the voice for all those kids who had gone there and done awful wrong and were now back in the World and had to figure out how to try and live with themselves, and what they had done.

For ALL of you who think for even one second that there weren't the most abominable atrocities committed in "Nam I can only say YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT THE FVCK YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT!

So I have to accept your presence here, Rip, and the crap you post. Them's the rules. Finally realizing that, despite your chronological age, you're just a precocious 9 year old in head and at heart, may somehow help.

You don't realize it, but you sometimes fling your poo on some very sacred ground.
 

fjord

Senior member
Feb 18, 2004
667
0
0
Newsflash:Both Viet Cong and Swift boat veterans agree that Bush should write a book explaining Native American Sovereign Nation state--and how that relates to Bush's pet goat.

Film at 11.
 

conjur

No Lifer
Jun 7, 2001
58,686
3
0
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: Red Dawn
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Obviously it's satirical. Geez.

I think it makes a valid point though.
How the Fsck would you know? Were you even alive during that Fscked up war? If so do you have any recollection of it?

I was born in 1960, so yes, I have a recollection of it.

*cough*BullSh*t!*cough*
 

Shad0hawK

Banned
May 26, 2003
1,456
0
0
Originally posted by: Perknose
Sometimes I think the nearly 60,000 dead are the lucky ones -- sometimes. At least, hopefully, their souls are at peace. But those many, many more who were maimed -- either physically or psychologically or both -- were also thrown to the endless hounds of hell, and for what?


hiya perknose, do not forget about the millions who are no suffering as a result of the NV victory, expecially the montagnards, the tribesman who are to this day dying due to the genocidal policy of vietnam of forcing abortions and sterilization...

Originally posted by: PerknoseThe Vietnam War was tactical mistake, as I believe this Iraqi war is also. My father, a decorated WWII Navy combat veteran and a life long conservative Republican, was quietly but firmly oppossed to the Vietnam War from the get go.

We all made our choices back then, and many had that choice made for them. John Kerry went and served, and then made sure he got to the front lines of the shooting war. You who have not been under live fire haven't the first fvcking clue! He could just as easily have been killed out there on those narrow rivers, and you somehow make light of that!

i would disagree, it was not a tactical mistake, but rather a strategic one...the politicians forgot somehwere that when you fight, you must fight to WIN. instead the war was used as political fodder..that guaranteed a disaster, but even then the soldiers fought like hell and without ignorant rules of engagement we proved we could win...except for when our hands were tied.

i also think your mistaken that kerry "made sure he got in the front lines" this is not true, he was under the assumption he would be on coastal patrol(which most of the time was actually rear area duty unless some sort of interdiction was required), which is what we used to refer to as "riding the gravy train"



Originally posted by: PerknoseAnd then Kerry came home and had the courage and integrity to speak out. If personal advancement were his primary goal, he could have easily used his decorated combat status as a ticket to political success. Instead, he risked all to speak the truth. He was the voice for all those kids who had gone there and done awful wrong and were now back in the World and had to figure out how to try and live with themselves, and what they had done.

where is the "integrity" of filing misleading reports to make himself look better to his commanders? where is the "integrity" in taking the medals he was supposed to despise and throwing them away at a protest, but not really throwing them away, decieving even his new lefist friends flying the NV flag? where is the "integrity" in years later taking those medals(now proud of them again...) and touting about how much of a $^#^ hero he was?

Originally posted by: PerknoseFor ALL of you who think for even one second that there weren't the most abominable atrocities committed in "Nam I can only say YOU DON'T KNOW WHAT THE FVCK YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT!

i do not know about others, i agree atrocities happened on BOTH sides(war itself is an atrocity). i do not deny it for a minute. in fact the atocities are still happening in vietnam at the hands of the communist's but no one seems to protest them.

i can tell you why atocities happened, some people just like to make others suffer to be sure, but the number one cause of atrocities, when you are fighting for your life most people will do ANYTHING to stay alive, and the only way you will ever win a fight like that is to be as mean as the other guy is that is.

back to work for me
 

LunarRay

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2003
9,993
1
76
Originally posted by: Shad0hawK
Originally posted by: LunarRay
Folks talk a lot different when they are out of harms way. Ever notice that? Folks getting a cut from shrapnel thank God or who ever they thank that the crap didn't do greater damage. Shrapnel flies in a randomly chosen path.


shrapnel really flies in a random path? WOW! of course many soldiers would not bother with a purple heart from scratches when others get much more seriously wounded, except of course glory hunting liars.
We were ordered to report to 'Sick Bay' for any and all injuries because of the infection issues that were afoot. This directive came from both I Corp up by Danang and Task Force 77.7. Folks reporting to 'Sick Bay' for these injuries were not only treated but they had to relate how they got them. This then was sent up to the appropriate authority for vetting and upon determination by the appropriate authority an award may be presented.
My larger point, however, is that being 'nicked' by a bit of shrapnel is a scary issue to me.. Depends on your frame of reference, I guess. At times I'd think growing up in the streets of Brooklyn was as dangerous and then at times I'd think Brooklyn was a whole hell of a lot safer.. But, again, I'm a coward.


Originally posted by: LunarRayWhat Kerry said or did post his service in Vietnam has nothing to do with his time there. I don't care if he was there a week or a day or four months.. he was there and that says a lot about him.. Bush was where? In any event, Kerry and many folks saw the promise to end that war turn into a farce.. and, a waste of life. I am glad there were folks like Kerry to help stop the useless death.. what could we have gained there and what would it have taken to gain it.. Eliminate all the North to preserve the South?

that tops the list of ignorant statement s i have seen on this board
That, of course, would be based on the intellectual capability of the person making the statement. I would not argue that my statement is the top of your list of ignorant statements... after all it (my statement) simply reflects the facts that are generally accepted by many and asks a question.

Originally posted by: LunarRayWhen folks use terms like 'Komrad' they need looking at the context of Kerry's efforts. It would be like sending thousands and thousands of kids to Iraq to die when at the end of the day nothing will be gained but freedom for those who survive there.. and all the dead ... what did they gain..?

context of his efforts? like medal hunting to make himself out the hero he is not, then participating in protests displaying the flag of the enemy, then turning out to not have thrown his medals way so he could later tell the ignorant sheep what a hero he is? of course all the deception on his part "does not matter"
The medals and awards are recorded on form dd214. They are replaced upon request.. so If I threw mine in the fire and wanted them back I would simply write and ask... it is the dd214 that denotes the awards.. (down at the bottom)...

Originally posted by: LunarRayYou do realize that the Vietnam issue was predicated on lie after lie. It is a patriot who'll stand up against the power of the government to expose the lies.

by telling more of them? what "lies" are you referring to?
Archie Bunker would ask 'Meathead' that question, why do you ask me? I'm neither 'Meathead' nor are you Archie. Does the reality of the Vietnam war and Kerry's testimony conflict? The 'Gulf of Tonkin' episode was the beginning of the Johnson Lies and the promise of Nixon to end the war in '68 began his.
The lies about kill ratios, locations, our dead and wounded, moral and the reality of the actions taken by our government is what I'm referring to. I really don't know where to start.. I went there cuz I was already in ... Joined 15 Oct '63 and stayed in until 15 Oct '69.. I don't think Kerry is a liar... he was there!


Originally posted by: LunarRayWhen someone calls Kerry a commie or says that he is not welcome at Fort Hood they say that I am not welcome either... and to that I can only laugh.. the brush is painting very wide.. and it don't seem to touch Mr. Bush... whose efforts to avoid serving in Vietnam seem to be what the current crop of Veteran laud... well.. ok.. there it is.

go ahead and laugh, niether of you will be missed...as for bush not going, what exactly does that have to do with kerry?

not a blessed thing, that's what.
Us intellectually superior folks don't get mad when we read what makes other lesser folks mad we just consider the source and laugh... Forgive them for they know not what they say... heheheheehe It is one of those 'sticks and stones may break my bones... but, truth will never hurt me. You can lead a horse to water but, a pencil must be lead!!!! Graphite really but who's counting...?
Bush cannot be compared to Kerry in this arena because he did go to Vietnam. So the only real issue should be related to Vietnam itself... should that matter when one went and another didn't... maybe and then again maybe not.. the fact that Kerry was awarded medals and Bush was not only distances Bush from Kerry and Bush must reduce that distance at all costs... or so he thinks.
 

CaptnKirk

Lifer
Jul 25, 2002
10,053
0
71
So then s'hawk -

An interogator snatching a 6 month old child from the arms of a mother who
was in a suspected Veit Cong village and cutting that child in half with a machete
is a justified defensive mechanism of wanting to stay alive ?

Do you think that the 6 month old child is that much of a threat ?

Maybe there are some power trip egomaniacs that do the wrong things,
in their showing how tough they think they are. Mai Lia is an example.

Thats where atrocities come in - like prisoner abuse.
 

LunarRay

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2003
9,993
1
76
Originally posted by: Riprorin
Originally posted by: CaptnKirk
I was born in 1960, so yes, I have a recollection of it.

What ? From 5 years old to a Pre-Teeny Bopper makes you an expert ?
It was done &amp; we were gone before you could even know that it happened.

Did you get together with the kids in your neighborhood and play 'Cowboys and Commies'

You don't have a clue, or even know where to buy a clue.

I was a precocious kid.


ROFL

That made my day... thanks Rip...:)
 

LunarRay

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2003
9,993
1
76
Originally posted by: DonVito
Originally posted by: Riprorin

I was a precocious kid.

If that's true, you suffered a precipitous intellectual decline in the intervening years.

You guys are way good at making me laugh.. hehehehe... love it..
 

LunarRay

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2003
9,993
1
76
Perknose said:
So I have to accept your presence here, Rip, and the crap you post. Them's the rules. Finally realizing that, despite your chronological age, you're just a precocious 9 year old in head and at heart, may somehow help.
You don't realize it, but you sometimes fling your poo on some very sacred ground

Firstly, thanks for your kind words directed to me.

I saw Rip's post and the others he's posted recently about Kerry's Vietnam issues and all sorts of memories came back.. and the emotions of being scared... very.. very scared. Then the reason for all that fear was apparent... it was because I was there and there were lots of other folks there too... And, some of them never came home and others came home but took those 'little scratch' hits like Kerry got but in areas that tore them apart or maybe they were lucky and only a scar remains.
I remember seeing a guy lying on the ground crying... he pointed to his wrist and the blood that was dripping from it... then at the body of another all crumpled and dead.... he was crying because he had been standing beside that other guy when a mortar or grenade or something blew... he was alive and this other guy was dead... I guess that guy was awarded the Purple Heart too... just like Kerry... probably a few of them just like Kerry...
The fact that a fragile human being is placed or requests to be placed in the arena of war is very much more likely to be wounded or killed as a result of being there than the folks who are having a beer in some downtown Conneticut bar. Getting 'hit' or not is not what makes a man a hero.... being there does that... getting hit... well that is a bit of a random event... that no one wants to have happen to them... Not the hero nor the coward!
 

CaptnKirk

Lifer
Jul 25, 2002
10,053
0
71
Luney -

I remember the helpless feeling of 'Incoming !' - all the training, all the do this,
get down, cover up, stay down - every thing that you did - it really didn't matter.

Even if you did everything right, you were still at the mercy of the randomness
of each individual round - where you happened to be when it detonated, the pattern
of the fragments. Big ones would cut you up while little ones killed those further away,
and your fate was completely out of your hands, survival was just a random event.
Sometimes you survived only because the person laying prone next to you just
happened to be between the round and your position - if he hadn't dived there for
cover you wouldn't have made it. If the round fell 2 feet shorter, neither would have.
 

LunarRay

Diamond Member
Mar 2, 2003
9,993
1
76
Originally posted by: CaptnKirk
Luney -

I remember the helpless feeling of 'Incoming !' - all the training, all the do this,
get down, cover up, stay down - every thing that you did - it really didn't matter.

Even if you did everything right, you were still at the mercy of the randomness
of each individual round - where you happened to be when it detonated, the pattern
of the fragments. Big ones would cut you up while little ones killed those further away,
and your fate was completely out of your hands, survival was just a random event.
Sometimes you survived only because the person laying prone next to you just
happened to be between the round and your position - if he hadn't dived there for
cover you wouldn't have made it. If the round fell 2 feet shorter, neither would have.

Ain't that the truth...
Both are heroes! Both equally as brave and one dead. Tis why I argue that it is insanity to downplay the role of anyone who served there. They are heroes even if they ain't the folks who in a fit of survival while trying to stay alive and help others survive were recognized as being worthy of receiving a Star or Cross or More.. The grunt sloshing in a rice paddy, climbing a numbered hill for the third time, trying to discern the friendly from the foe in some hamlet, racing up and down a river or just sitting on the beach looking up at some ape like mountain and never getting 'hit' is any man's equal when it comes to being a hero... in the dam war.. I figure the same goes for the folks in all the wars or war like events we seem to frequent.

There are some, I guess, that can go into harms way without a bit of fear... they are Trained Military Folks.. but, back then (as you know) these kids, many of whom were fresh from the slums and hadn't a clue.. went to 3 months of Army how to march and look pretty and then to Vietnam... Trained to do little other than pull a trigger... led by a kid not much older who fresh from OCS was told he could lead men in battle. But they went. Some were told to go... and went while others ran or found creative ways to avoid going.

IMO... Mr. Bush is not among those who'd I call a hero... his character is called into question because he too COULD have gone and earned his medals and maybe even ran for President without that issue being raised.
 

Harvey

Administrator<br>Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
35,059
73
91
Rip -- Thanks for the laugh. I'm actually stunned that you had the balls to post a parody of your own typical posts. I'm glad you showed a sense of humor about yourself. :laugh:

Now, I just wish you understood how much of a bad a joke Bushwhacko is. :(

I hope others cut Rip some slack for this particular thread. He has posted too many others far more worthy of tearing apart.
 

Perknose

Forum Director & Omnipotent Overlord
Forum Director
Oct 9, 1999
46,873
10,668
147
Originally posted by: LunarRay
Originally posted by: CaptnKirk
Luney -

I remember the helpless feeling of 'Incoming !' - all the training, all the do this,
get down, cover up, stay down - every thing that you did - it really didn't matter.

Even if you did everything right, you were still at the mercy of the randomness
of each individual round - where you happened to be when it detonated, the pattern
of the fragments. Big ones would cut you up while little ones killed those further away,
and your fate was completely out of your hands, survival was just a random event.
Sometimes you survived only because the person laying prone next to you just
happened to be between the round and your position - if he hadn't dived there for
cover you wouldn't have made it. If the round fell 2 feet shorter, neither would have.

Ain't that the truth...
Both are heroes! Both equally as brave and one dead. Tis why I argue that it is insanity to downplay the role of anyone who served there. They are heroes even if they ain't the folks who in a fit of survival while trying to stay alive and help others survive were recognized as being worthy of receiving a Star or Cross or More.. The grunt sloshing in a rice paddy, climbing a numbered hill for the third time, trying to discern the friendly from the foe in some hamlet, racing up and down a river or just sitting on the beach looking up at some ape like mountain and never getting 'hit' is any man's equal when it comes to being a hero... in the dam war.. I figure the same goes for the folks in all the wars or war like events we seem to frequent.

There are some, I guess, that can go into harms way without a bit of fear... they are Trained Military Folks.. but, back then (as you know) these kids, many of whom were fresh from the slums and hadn't a clue.. went to 3 months of Army how to march and look pretty and then to Vietnam... Trained to do little other than pull a trigger... led by a kid not much older who fresh from OCS was told he could lead men in battle. But they went. Some were told to go... and went while others ran or found creative ways to avoid going.

IMO... Mr. Bush is not among those who'd I call a hero... his character is called into question because he too COULD have gone and earned his medals and maybe even ran for President without that issue being raised.
Thanks, CK, and thanks, LR, for your simple eloquence -- for the truth of what it was like -- death as a random, uncontrollable fate; the impotence and rage and sadness and mind and soul numbing fear that can fill you with, how fvcking weary that can make you; and how every single young kid who went was a hero, just simply so.

I only wish those who would belittle John Kerry's service could realize they belittle us all. I wish they would step out of their partisan skins for one brief moment and fully take in what you two wrote -- the quiet, unblinking, unmistakable truth of it -- and change their tack here.

Folks, please re-read the quotes above me here. Take them in.

There are no doubt plenty of valid reasons to oppose Kerry's candidacy, for those so inclined. His service in Vietnam is not one of them.
 

Gaard

Diamond Member
Feb 17, 2002
8,911
1
0
Originally posted by: Harvey
Rip -- Thanks for the laugh. I'm actually stunned that you had the balls to post a parody of your own typical posts. I'm glad you showed a sense of humor about yourself. :laugh:

Now, I just wish you understood how much of a bad a joke Bushwhacko is. :(

I hope others cut Rip some slack for this particular thread. He has posted too many others far more worthy of tearing apart.


The problem though Harvey is that Rip was unaware that this was satire. He's just so zoned about posting his crap, that he didn't realize it until it was pointed out to him.
 

Zephyr106

Banned
Jul 2, 2003
1,309
0
0
Originally posted by: CaptnKirk
So then s'hawk -

An interogator snatching a 6 month old child from the arms of a mother who
was in a suspected Veit Cong village and cutting that child in half with a machete
is a justified defensive mechanism of wanting to stay alive ?

Do you think that the 6 month old child is that much of a threat ?

Maybe there are some power trip egomaniacs that do the wrong things,
in their showing how tough they think they are. Mai Lia is an example.

Thats where atrocities come in - like prisoner abuse.

Just blowing off some steam. That baby wasn't white anyway, why should we care.

Zephyr