Verizon iPhone 4 Engadget Review

zerocool84

Lifer
Nov 11, 2004
36,041
472
126
At the launch event for the Verizon version of the phone, carrier execs made a pretty big deal not only about the larger and more reliable network, but the fact that they were "ready" for the onslaught of new iPhone users and customers switching from AT&T. The indication is that Big Red has every intention of not getting caught in the same mess their competition has found itself in.

So, does the phone exhibit more favorable behavior in regards to dropped / failed calls? The answer is yes -- with a caveat. We had many, many perfectly connected and sustained calls while on the Verizon iPhone (many times during testing we actually had to switch from our AT&T device to the Verizon device just to complete the call). After a couple of days of use, the fear that normally sets in about five minutes into a connected call with an AT&T iPhone all but disappeared, and we found ourselves wanting to have longer talks and not worrying so much about the potential for dropped and interrupted calls.

But on to that caveat. While the phone did connect much more reliably and consistently, it wasn't impervious to broken connections and sound quality issues. In areas where we had a weak signal, or when moving around, we experienced call interference (our callers noted this as well), and in two instances, we did drop a call when moving from one place to another (clearly an area with less Verizon juice).

Let's be clear here, however. Calls were consistently connected and uninterrupted, far more often than our AT&T calls in the same time period in similar locations. There were sound quality issues (it seemed to be happening more on our outgoing audio than incoming), but they were few and far between according to our friends and family. Overall, our level of confidence in the phone's ability to handle one of its main tasks went way, way up during our testing. If you've been looking for relief from your woes of dropped or failed calls -- right now the Verizon iPhone is making a very serious case for itself. Keep in mind, however, that this network has yet to be hit with the traffic of millions of new iPhones, but given that Verizon is already pushing tons of Android devices into the market, we're not so sure that it's going to be the kind of mess it's been for AT&T.

Better call/data reliability is what people wanted and it seems they're going to get it. As said in the review, Verizon already has tons of Android phones so it doesn't look like the same problems AT&T had is going to happen with Verizon since Verizon has so many more towers.

http://www.engadget.com/2011/02/02/verizon-iphone-review/
 

MrX8503

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2005
4,529
0
0
I would wait and see what the iPhone 4 will do to Verizon's network. I'm not exactly sure which network has more strain because ATT has more smartphone users than Verizon.
 

zerocool84

Lifer
Nov 11, 2004
36,041
472
126
I would wait and see what the iPhone 4 will do to Verizon's network. I'm not exactly sure which network has more strain because ATT has more smartphone users than Verizon.

Well when AT&T had really bad reliability, they certainly had less smartphone users than Verizon does now so I'm sure it wouldn't be that bad at all.
 

OBLAMA2009

Diamond Member
Apr 17, 2008
6,574
3
0
why do iphones drop calls so much. i have iphone and verizon blackberry and iphone drops calls way more. is it because of iphone problems or just because of att's network?
 

XJustMeX21

Golden Member
Nov 26, 2005
1,606
0
76
I had no idea the battery life on an iphone was so good. I kill my droid 2 in half a day.
 

kaerflog

Golden Member
Jul 23, 2010
1,899
4
76
I had no idea the battery life on an iphone was so good. I kill my droid 2 in half a day.

One reason why I'm spoiled with the IP4.
When I got the Vibrant on stock, I was like WTF the first few days.
I don't see how in the hell anyone can survive using it stock.
After installing a custom ROM, I enjoy the Vibrant very much.
 

XJustMeX21

Golden Member
Nov 26, 2005
1,606
0
76
I live like a addict with my phone, always looking for a little juice...

I'm also up for an upgrade and I'm thinking I might have to order this tonight.
 

GregGreen

Golden Member
Dec 5, 2000
1,682
3
81
I haven't really noticed AT&T sucking in the areas I have lived -- in fact, when I lived in WNY, AT&T had better service than VZW in the boonies -- but one thing I realized from switching from my Droid to the iPhone 4 is that AT&T's network is MUCH faster for data (like 3x as fast).

Note: I went from 4 or 5 VZW non-smartphones to iPhone 3G to Moto Droid to iPhone 4.
 

shortylickens

No Lifer
Jul 15, 2003
80,287
17,080
136
i forgot to mention that i have 3gs so my question related to 3gs not 4. do apple phoes in general tend to drop calls more than blackberrys?

Hard to say for sure since up until now iPhones have only been on AT&T. We would need each phone on each network and tons of statistics to get an accurate assessment. But overall I hear a lot more complaints from iPhone users than Blackberry users.
Of course, that could say more about the people than the hardware.
:awe:
 

DivideBYZero

Lifer
May 18, 2001
24,117
2
0
Hard to say for sure since up until now iPhones have only been on AT&T. We would need each phone on each network and tons of statistics to get an accurate assessment. But overall I hear a lot more complaints from iPhone users than Blackberry users.
Of course, that could say more about the people than the hardware.
:awe:
I have both on the same network and the iPhone drops much more.
 

abaez

Diamond Member
Jan 28, 2000
7,155
1
81
NYTimes did a pretty damning test on the dropped calls issue in their review.
 

pm

Elite Member Mobile Devices
Jan 25, 2000
7,419
22
81
I have both on the same network and the iPhone drops much more.

I agree. My iPhone 3GS drops many more calls than than my wife's Nokia - although that said, my wife's Nokia drops more than it should too.

As far as battery life, I agree that for a smartphone the iPhone 4 (and 3GS) have very good battery life. With everything turned on (WiFi, 3G, Bluetooth) and synching of email and calendars and contacts, my iPhone 3GS will last two days of normal use (not a lot of surfing, not a lot of gaming) and it's about 18 months old (so you'd think the battery would have degraded a bit). If I power it off at night, I can get 3 days out of it. About the only weird thing with iPhone battery life and myself personally is sometimes I'll do an update of the software and the battery life will tank and then I'll update the same software again and it will get better...
 
Last edited:

KentState

Diamond Member
Oct 19, 2001
8,397
393
126
im guessing it has to do with where they are, im in the middle of one of our plants right now surrounded my tons of concrete. i still test 2.5/1

Where I sit, I get the same speeds on my Droid as in their test. Somewhat of a moot point as VZ is launching LTE phones in the near future.
 

MrX8503

Diamond Member
Oct 23, 2005
4,529
0
0
and it pretty much destroys everything in wifi/3g web browsing battery life.

smaller screen probably helps

Smaller screen
Underclock A4 (800mhz)
Efficient iOS
Multitasking freeze/suspended apps

All of these probably helps. The crazy thing is that its battery is slightly smaller than 1500mah.