PricklyPete
Lifer
Since I am inexperienced with a manual. I just went out for a late night drive.
Drove down a local highway very close to my neighborhood. Got on the interstate. Went to the next exit three miles down. Got back on the same highway (runs parallel to the interstate) and took it back home.
After coming from a Ford Ranger, the drive was so smooth. The acceleration felt good even in 5th gear. I travel some with my job, so I have driven quite a few small cars (such as the ford focus). Those drove nice, but something about this felt really good.
I had a long post about getting a stick. Now that I have one...I am still VERY weak on getting the ball rolling in first gear. Basically, I give it some major gas to make sure I don't stall. Hoping I get smoother at this.
The other thing I didn't think about...in an automatic if I want to make micro adjustments (such as moving up a few feet) all I have to do is put it in gear and the "idle speed" can carry me there.
In a stick, the only way I have been able to micro adjust is to keep holding the clutch down slightly and give it the gas to slowly move forward. I assume this is really bad on the clutch? Obviously if I let go of the clutch the car is gonna want to move much more than a few feet....or stall with my experience....
Believe me...once you get the hang of it...those micro adjustments will be even easier in a stick. I have way more control with my clunky truck (with manual) than I do with my wifes automatic. Modulating the clutch as needed allows you unbelievable control when needed.
And don't worry...you won't be having to apply the massive gas long. practice letting the clutch out without even applying gas and get used to the feeling of the clutch starting to catch...then push it right back in. This will wear the clutch a bit...but it will give you invaluable experience on where the clutch is catching so that you naturally start to understand when you need to start applying gas...and you'll slowly get a lot better at incremental adjustments in throttle input. Now some cars are famously difficult to drive stick in...your BMW definitely is not one of them (I'd say a lot of people would argue it is the easiest...with maybe the exception of some honda's).