Originally posted by: Chris
As I was saying, it's a misleading measurement. I'm sure a lot of the LED LCDs had 0.00 off ftl measurements as well.
Please explain how it is misleading when comparing a CRT and plasma's light measurements. I'd like to hear this. With an LED LCD, it is a different story. Turning off all LED zones to reach 0 idle lum to display a total black screen doesn't really count.
Then you contradict yourself:
As for a projector, you'll need a REALLY nice projector to outperform a Kuro.
Which is it?
No contradiction. I'm giving projectors the benefit of the doubt which was more than HTM says about them.
To which I said:
Plasma is only better than LCD. CRT and projectors outright rape plasma in PQ.
And the statement holds true. We were not talking about any specific viewing environment, we were talking strictly about technology.
You've already lost the battle with CRT vs plasma, and HTM has already said the 111FD can reach a deeper black level than theaters, so what else do you need?
There's also the diminishing returns when it comes to blacks. Per CNET:
We love deep blacks on HDTVs. Nothing makes a picture pop more than rich blacks, and it's the the biggest component of what makes an image look good. That being said, the closer we get to "absolute black" and infinite contrast ratios, the less incremental increases in black level affect the overall picture quality--in our experience. When we compared the PDP-5020FD and the TH-50PZ800U side-by-side, there was no doubt the that Pioneer is the black-level king, but both sets are so good at getting dark that we felt that color accuracy wound up being a more important factor--and the Panasonic easily trumped Pioneer in this regard.
Ouch. So much your statement:
Kuros are for people that don't want to settle for a G10.
And the Panny they are talking about is not even a G10. lol.
What's funny is how you are trying to wiggle out of this. It's pretty much well known that the 5020 lacks the accuracy due to Pioneer limiting the controls. With the 5020 there are some compromises, but the pluses DEFINITELY outweigh the negatives when comparing it to a G10 let alone an 800U. Differences that HT doesn't even bring up. Now if you want a no compromise Kuro (50"), that would be the KRP500M which is about the same price as the 5020. Deepest black level of any Kuro and color accuracy second to none. Do you want me to say it again? Kuros are for people that don't want to settle for a G10.
And by the way, if your emphasis is on color accuracy, the G10 falls behind the latest Samsung plasmas too. Sorry.
They don't even make Kuro displays anymore, do they? The business model of uber expensive sets to cork sniffers like yourself worked out really well for Pioneer, didn't it?
They don't make them anymore, but they are still available to purchase. And Pioneer's model was to make the best HDTV, period. No compromises. The only compromise they made was to differentiate their "lower end" model verses their high end model, however the tech was the same. Pioneer set the standard with the Kuro in 2007 and again in 2008 and has yet to be surpassed. You can throw all your jealous tirades all you want, but facts are facts. And every professional review says the Pioneer Elite still hold the crown for PQ and performance. Unfortunately delivering the best HD tech to the market wasn't what the market really wanted. The market wanted cheap, average tech. So in short, that's why Pioneer is no longer here.
If the average consumer goes to Amazon looking for a 50" set they see:
$3,499.99
$1,300
If the on-paper black levels are worth paying $2,200 more for you, well, good luck with all that. And they arguably don't even have the best PQ, especially the 9G with the gimped picture controls. But hey, if you're paying 3,500 for a set, what's another $500 for ISF calibration? (yeah I know you can get a 5020 for much cheaper, but point stands)
:roll: They'll also see
this @ $1999. Deepest blacks of any Pioneer, including the 111FD and just as accurate as the Elite series. Any other worthless points you'd like to make?
And BTW, this will be the last time I address your posts item by item. I can't believe I wasted this much time on you already. Your motive is clear. You're like a little jealous kid that can't stand for someone to have something better than he does. Pretty pathetic if you ask me.