- Apr 17, 2004
- 17,555
- 1
- 0
Hello all,
I don't frequent over to this neck of the woods often, but I used to when I tinkered with my desktop
Now I'm into laptops and I'm a senior editor at the website in my sig. We recently released a pretty in-depth article on the Pentium M vs Turion 64, analyzing the architectures and running benchmarks. And coincidentally, THG released a very similar article just after we did. Obviously we are nowhere near in size to THG, but frankly I wasn't impressed by their article. We've had a couple readers comment in the forums that the THG article was better and I just don't see it.
I was hoping to get some impartial feedback (since I know I'm not
) from some intelligent people, because frankly I think the people who commented on our forums are the sort of people who take THG as their end-all/be-all existence.
Whenever you all have some free time, I would appreciate you taking a look at both articles completely; it is a doozie
But look at not only the tests & results, but the testing methods, analysis, etc etc. I just wasn't impressed with THG and I need to know if its just me 
THG Part I
THG Part II
LaptopLogic Article
LaptopLogic discussion thread with THG comments
Also note that some users have questioned the battery results of our Acer 8104 tests: consequently we have another 8104 in-house and are re-testing it with the Winstone Batterymark and our new Bapco MobileMark (or whatever its called). We will be presenting updated results with the old & new batterytest platforms soon.
Thanks in advance!
I don't frequent over to this neck of the woods often, but I used to when I tinkered with my desktop
I was hoping to get some impartial feedback (since I know I'm not
Whenever you all have some free time, I would appreciate you taking a look at both articles completely; it is a doozie
THG Part I
THG Part II
LaptopLogic Article
LaptopLogic discussion thread with THG comments
Also note that some users have questioned the battery results of our Acer 8104 tests: consequently we have another 8104 in-house and are re-testing it with the Winstone Batterymark and our new Bapco MobileMark (or whatever its called). We will be presenting updated results with the old & new batterytest platforms soon.
Thanks in advance!