<< I think the ads force you to think. >>
I think that is the problem... they force you to think.
There is a saying I recall: "Convince people to think, and they will love you... Make people think, and they will hate you"
You are probably right that the campaign can prove effective on people who have not started smoking. But as a long time
ex-smoker, I find that those ads are so busy ramming the "truth" down my throat, it makes me want to light up just
to get the taste of fist out of my mouth. They go to such an extreme that the ads start to sound like those "Good Times"
virus hoaxes where a thousand misfortunes will befall you from reading an email. The brains of most media savvy
people start to automatically switch over to "BS mode" just so you don't feel like you're falling for some scam.
The truth ads are aimed at teens, who may not be as aware of health and social effects of smoking, so they do serve
some purpose; but I worry that they will get the same reaction that the "just say no" campaign faced when the teens
got a little older and started to question much of the things that authority figures were telling them.
Sad to say, As TheGrandCow mentioned, I actually find the Tobacco company settlement ads a better endorsement to
quit smoking than the truth ads.