True Server Cases

NightFalcon

Senior member
May 22, 2004
218
0
0
Over the summer I'm hoping to save up some money and finally build a nice server that I've always wanted. I'm still picking out all the components, but my main issue comes in with the server case. So far whenever I'm doing some searches on sites like newegg, most of the things that come up are either rackmount cases (which are nice, but I don't have a rack... yet :) ) or cases that are called server but are really for high-end workstations. So my question is this, what manufacturers and models would you recommend that I look at for true server cases that are only concerned with performance (cooling, functionality, etc.) and security as opposed to a cool window on the side?

So far I've looked at these types of things that got me a bit interested, but as there really aren't that many reviews on them around and I've never dealt with real server cases, it's hard to judge what's good and what isn't... (http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=11-182-548&depa=0 and http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?description=11-182-548&depa=0). Also, I'm thinking about implementing redundant power supplies since I will really need this thing to be up at all times, but this is another area that I've never entered before. Do you have any suggestions as far as where I should look for information on this? I noticed that the first case actually has a place for two power supplies, but I've also seen some that implement it in the normal space. What companies would you recommend and what prices should I be expecting?

Thanks for any help.
 

MichaelD

Lifer
Jan 16, 2001
31,528
3
76
Any "real" server case will fit an EATX motherboard. An EATX mobo is about 13"x13" square, IIRC.

Also, most "real" server motherboards use an EATX power supply. The "big" connector has 25 pins instead of the usual 20-pins that today's Intel and AMD motherboards have.

Just some things to mull over. :D

What are you going to do w/this server? Is this for your own home use? File Server? FTP/HTTP server? LAN-party server? I've been this route already, as have been many others on this board. Tell us what you want to do. You can build an awesome file server/home domain server out of common "everyday PC" parts. :)
 

NightFalcon

Senior member
May 22, 2004
218
0
0
Actually it's going to perform quiet a number of functions, but more important is that I want to build this thing and have it up and running for at least 3-4 years without needing any major maintenance other then the occasional manual software updates. Things it will be used for, let's see... First of all going to be the only storage space in my house (for major things anyway), right now I'm implementing a gigabit LAN for my other computers and I'm planning on having at least 600GB of space on this thing. Will be an FTP, HTTP, Mail, Jabber, Print, possibly Gateway, and DNS server. If that's not enough yet :) then once in a while it will also be acting as a dedicated game server for my LAN (mostly Counter-Strike). I'm trying to centralize my home LAN (which at this point is 6 computers) so that I don't have to constantly worry about where what files are, why can I get to one computer but not the other and so on... I'm even considering roaming profiles so that no matter what computer I'm using all the settings are the same everywhere and all my files are on the network. It really is a big project and not one that I am likely to finish any time soon (due to financial reasons mostly :) ), but it's a dream of mine...
 

MichaelD

Lifer
Jan 16, 2001
31,528
3
76
600GB of space? That's a lot of porn. ;)

No offense, but do your realize HOW MUCH space that is? My roaming profile at work, complete with all SysAdmin tools, shortcuts, drivers and everything else isnt' even 2 GB.

Anyway, my advice to you, based on what you have said, is to build for reliability, not necessarilly speed.

You want drives to run for 3-4 years constantly? SCSI is the way to go. No overclocking, I very cool running, fanless videocard (or onboard video..even better) and a rock solid PS.

Post your list of components and we'll critique.
 

Mellman

Diamond Member
Jul 9, 2003
3,083
0
76
Im currently doing my work in progress....its a XP2200+ with a GB of ram, its used both as my FTP server, and as a game server for our lan's (i host 50+ person lans) it runs BF1942 just fine and dandy...honestly if your going to play only CS with a dedicated server....an old P3 box would do you just fine, anything else is gonna be overkill...as far as storage goes...lets see, :) I have 1.73TB, yes thats Terrabytes. Im doing a custom paint job on my server case this summer and i'm working on a design with a buddy of mine.

In any case, if you want storage, and you want it right i'd reccomend a nice SCSI setup in raid for your primary array, and then maybe pickup 2x250GB WD drives. SATA Raptors can be used in place of the SCSI for cost reasons....but even those are overkill for your setup. FTP DNS etc... dont use many resources at all, the most cpu usage that thing is going to see is when you occasionally do your CS games, and 6 people aint much. It doesnt sound like you need a nice server case, it sounds like you need a nice desktop case, one that allows for plenty of ventilation, with some room for expansion.
 

Falloutboy

Diamond Member
Jan 2, 2003
5,916
0
76
Originally posted by: MichaelD
600GB of space? That's a lot of porn. ;)

No offense, but do your realize HOW MUCH space that is? My roaming profile at work, complete with all SysAdmin tools, shortcuts, drivers and everything else isnt' even 2 GB.

Anyway, my advice to you, based on what you have said, is to build for reliability, not necessarilly speed.

You want drives to run for 3-4 years constantly? SCSI is the way to go. No overclocking, I very cool running, fanless videocard (or onboard video..even better) and a rock solid PS.

Post your list of components and we'll critique.

600 gb isn't all that much....I have 400gb in my rig now and I'm constantly running out of space. planning on building a 2 TB fileserver myself this Fall.
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
my case suggestion
Dual 300w. For a file server, plenty of power, and a CS server shouldn't be stressfull on any new hardware.
Many Intel servers use that case and other variants. Plenty of room, nice design.

You should have done this a few months ago. Around January, that case and PSU was only $230--a real deal. Now it's at a fair price.