Heres my take on it.
Pros:
- Pretty much the same as tropico 3
- Dosent crash as often as tropico 3 or have that weird save bug they never fixed
- New buildings
- Islands 4 times larger
Cons:
- Pretty much the same as tropico 3, tropico 3 was awesome but there isnt much new here its just tropico 3 refined a little
- Only 1200 population limit whereas tropico 3 + AP had 2000, wtf islands are 4 times larger but the pop cap is smaller? Crazy
- Road limits still the same
- Pretty much no additional gameplay additions, the ministers thing thats mentioned in the features is shallow and just acts as a wall to issuing certain edicts early, have to have combat minister to issue military modernization for example
- No mod tools released by developer so according to people who know about modding the population caps and road limits will be difficult to modify
Overall its a disappointment, i play this game as a builder, i spent most of my time in tropico 3 with a sandbox island. Campaign was nice enough but i want to build stuff and the lack of new additions alone is pretty lame but the artificial caps and limits they have just ruins the game for me.