Originally posted by: dullard
Originally posted by: Flyback
A PhD that spans the other areas? You need the foundations, man!
I appreciate your feedback and all, I mean, hell, maybe you're right. I'm just not on the same wavelength.
You'll get the foundations along the way. Don't let that bother you.
I have three degrees myself. BS and MS in chemical engineering. The MS focus was on computer simulations of chemical engineering processes (spanning a lot of math and computer science work). My PhD is officially just in Engineering. However, it was my own mixture of mathematical modeling, computer science, electrical engineering, chemical engineering, and a tough of biochemistry.
Did I need a separate degree in Math, in CS, in EE, in ChE, and in Biochemistry to get my PhD? No. I simply took the accelerated foundation courses made for graduate students who don't have the undergraduate training in that field. Then, when I wanted more detailed learning, I took a MS or PhD level course in that field that covered exactly what I wanted to learn.
For example, in biology I took one accelerated MS level course which covered both of the undergraduate level biochem courses. Then I skipped right to a graduate level virology course. Sure I only had one of the 12 prerequisists for the virology course. But I managed to get through it all. I learned quite a bit in that course. I learned exactly what I wanted and what I needed for my PhD. I got the foundations and the depth that way.
Of all the people I've met in my years, the most employable (and therefore they got the most stimulating jobs) were people with a BS degree in math and a graduate level degree in science or engineering. Very few people span both worlds. Large companies have teams of mathematicians. They have teams of scientists. And they have teams of engineers. But none of those teams can talk/understand each other. So you have a 3-legged beast crawling in all directions without any coordination. These cross-major people had the ability to understand 2 or 3 of those groups and became the coordinators linking the math models to the fundamental science. Linking the science output to the engineer's products. Linking the engineer's results back to verify the math models. To me, those are wonderful careers. But, they are careers intended solely for people with graduate level education.