Towing with manual transmission...

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

lylecanterbury

Junior Member
Apr 26, 2010
1
0
0
Well first of all towing and pulling up stumps (or bushes) is two different things.
There is one rule in automotive that is ALWAYS right, and that is that manual transmissions are ALWAYS better than automatics lol. I wouldn't drive ANY vehicle with an automatic because it is a piece of junk. Yes I am joking, but I hate automatics. Secondly, reverse is not always a lower gear (numerically higher) than 1st. In my Jeep (NSG370 6sp manual) 1st gear is 4.46:1 and reverse is 4.06:1.
Thirdly, I once pulled out a job trailer that was stuck in the mud with a 4x4 Toyota after a one ton flat bed Ford with granny gear got stuck trying to pull it out, so don't make fun of any kind of truck because you have some kind of preconceived notion about what a truck is. A silverado with 400hp, 20" wheels and an auto trans is a piece of junk to me
 

GuitarDaddy

Lifer
Nov 9, 2004
11,465
1
0
I've had some luck pulling stumps with a pickup, here is how I did it

1. Used a large tractor rim as a pulley wheel to convert the pulling power from horizontal to vertical. Steel cable attached to stump at ground level, then over the tractor rim to the rear of the truck frame.

2. Used a HD dodge P/U with a Cummings turbo diesel and 600 ft lbs of torque

Even at this, bigger stumps required some cuttin and diggin
 
Aug 23, 2000
15,509
1
81
I've had some luck pulling stumps with a pickup, here is how I did it

1. Used a large tractor rim as a pulley wheel to convert the pulling power from horizontal to vertical. Steel cable attached to stump at ground level, then over the tractor rim to the rear of the truck frame.

2. Used a HD dodge P/U with a Cummings turbo diesel and 600 ft lbs of torque

Even at this, bigger stumps required some cuttin and diggin

Pulling a stump without doing a whole lot of digging is going to require some serious power.

I've pulled small shrubs with my Chevy and they give a good fight.
 

Bignate603

Lifer
Sep 5, 2000
13,897
1
0
He's lucky that he didn't have more power, he probably would have destroyed his gears if he had a bigger engine. Differential gears aren't cut to be abused in reverse.