• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Too small to cause damage? Bollocks!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
uh... aren't all asteroids space junk? And aren't all pieces of space junk asteroids?
Does the composition really change the classification? If it isn't something we made, and is in fact some random piece of space junk, it is exactly what an asteroid is, yes?

Unless, of course, it is some satellite from an alien civilization, or better yet, one that has an alien on board... as a fly-by observatory? How awesome would that be.
Surely they are checking us out, mocking our primitive we still are after all these years since they abandoned the ancient civilizations on Earth, and may even grant us their brief pity and smite us once and for all?
😀
 
uh... aren't all asteroids space junk? And aren't all pieces of space junk asteroids?
Does the composition really change the classification? If it isn't something we made, and is in fact some random piece of space junk, it is exactly what an asteroid is, yes?

Space junk is man made objects. Asteroids are not man made. Complex, I know.
 
Let thet 10m diameter hunk of rock fall on the Associated Press building at a few thousand kilometers per hour and see if it causes no damage.
Um, it'll be no where near 10 m wide when it hits the building. I know you pulled a 10 m diameter out of thin air, but do you have any idea what size it will be when it hits a building (if it can even reach that far before it has burned up entirely)?
 
Um, it'll be no where near 10 m wide when it hits the building. I know you pulled a 10 m diameter out of thin air, but do you have any idea what size it will be when it hits a building (if it can even reach that far before it has burned up entirely)?

10-15m was mentioned in the article. Depending on the angle of reentry, there could be a substantial chunk left if it hit.
 
If the object were 10 meters across and mostly iron, I really wonder how much of it would be left when it reached the ground. At the speed those things are moving, and considering thermal conductivity, just how much of it could really vaporize before it reached Earth's surface. Look at "shooting stars" - those things are just like grains of sand to the size of rice; not big rocks, and they travel a pretty significant distance. Big, impressive ones are rare & are only the size of a golfball. Look at how long their trails are. (their trails caused by ionizing the atmosphere)

I've unfortunately never taken an astronomy course, but I'm pretty skeptical of "most of it" being vaporized before it reaches the earth. Of course, a lot depends on how obliquely it strikes the earth. But still...

Also, 10m being harmless? The Tunguska event was estimated to be from a 50m object (of course, that's 125 times the volume, but even with one 125th of the energy, that's a hell of a wallop to whatever it hits.)

Took a while of searching, but "Typically, though, a meteoroid would have to be about the size of a marble for a portion of it to reach the Earth's surface. " is the only place that seems to confirm my thoughts. (I didn't find any to the contrary) - of course, and I realize this, most larger objects break up due to the enormous pressures involved as they plunge through the atmosphere.
 
Space junk is man made objects. Asteroids are not man made. Complex, I know.

what could possibly be man made, approaching out of nowhere, at that distance, and be unknown?

ancient soviet satellites that stopped functioning years ago would almost certainly be discerned from random material out there.

Complex? Certainly not. I may not understand quantum theory, but I assure you I have a grasp on rudimentary astronomy.
😉
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top