Tonic Water = Cures RLS

Page 2 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

KingGheedora

Diamond Member
Jun 24, 2006
3,248
1
81
Shh... don't blow their cover. It was invented as a way for them to get drugs. But then stupid people thought it was real and now need non-druggie remedies for their fake syndrome.

 

TallBill

Lifer
Apr 29, 2001
46,017
62
91
Originally posted by: SphinxnihpS
RLS is a fake neurological disorder where people claim they can't control their legs jumping all over the place. The real problems are lack of proper sleep, diet, and exercise. It generally only afflicts fat people.

Originally posted by: amicold

I'm gonna jump on the BS bandwagon people fucking move cause they're uncomfortable not because they have a disorder. I run, jog, and sprint at least 25 miles a week often near bed time due to my work schedule, and I have no gonorrhea sensation to move my legs or limbs when I lay down.


While I cant speak about what others have experienced, I actually do suffer from RLS, and have pretty much my entire life. It has nothing to do with my diet, excersises, or anything. Sometimes my legs just go nuts.

There are no words to describe what I feel in my leg. Varely rarely will it cause spasms, but often I have to move my legs around to ease the "pain". What I feel isn't a cramp or soreness. It just drives me fucking insane. I used to call them "crazy legs".

So go ahead and call bullshit all you want, but my legs are fucking crazy sometimes.
 

halik

Lifer
Oct 10, 2000
25,696
1
81
Originally posted by: destrekor
Originally posted by: halik
RLS is about as real as ADHD

so, chemical imbalances are fake, eh? Because that's what ADD/ADHD is.
Now, just because a chemical imbalance exists, doesn't mean it can't be controlled without medication. Proper diagnosis and careful planning are necessary to conquer ADD. And when you're as stubborn as I am, it's a bitch beating it without professional help and medication. Decades ago, the disorder existed but wasn't treated or even known about... and why is that? Because kids were beat in schools and thus the fear of pain forced the brain to work properly. Makes sense considering norepinephrine is involved in both: the feeling of fear produces it, and the brain is lacking the right amount of it, dopamine, and serotonin... which creates the disorder.

Don't know much about RLS though. I have twitchy legs, and in general twitch all over and generally can't keep my body perfectly still... but I don't think I have RLS. I don't really experience that burning/itching sensation in the legs.

Every single personality/character trait is chemical imbalance - aggressive/illtempered guys tend to have higher level of testosterone,shitty diet leads to lower levels of seratonin which effects REM sleep and that in turn can turn in you in one of those not-a-morning-people.

And yea sometimes i get muscle spasm on random parts of my body... OH NOES! I think I caught the muscle-twichinitis or MTS. Please sell me some drugs now.

This is pretty much the same thing like U.S. doctors wanting to pull everyone's wisdom teeth out. My first visit to a U.S. dentist (~2000) the guy was trying to sell me on the procedure. Low and behold, 5 years later a study comes out that removing impacted wisdom teeth has virtually no health benefits over leaving 'em in.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,505
146
I hate to say it, but this is why it's best to run/exercise in the AM. Exercise in the PM will screw with your sleep.

Get out of bed earlier and run before work. It is better for you in SO many ways. You will sleep better, have more energy thoughout the day and your stress levels during the day will benefit as well. ALWAYS workout in the AM. It's easy, go to bed earlier and get up earlier.

I do personally think that some of these guys that are supposedly getting RLS from ecxersise are falsely mis-diagnosing themselves.

You're probably right. But I've suffered the same thing from exercise and the symptoms are somewhat similar.

What he's more than likely suffering from is cramping, aches and pains. The aches and pains go away when he moves his legs. Therefore people confuse it with RLS. He feels the need to move his legs because they hurt. He's going from intense exercise to complete inactivity. This is why it's best to run in the AM and then use your legs all day. The cramping goes away because the chemical build up in the muscles is worked out.

http://www.peoplespharmacy.com...t_not_without_risk.asp

Tonic water is a CLASSIC cure for leg cramps. THIS is why it helps people who think they have RLS but really have cramps that ease when the legs are moved.

Google tonic water +cramps to find an endless number of references to this.

It's a pitty that simple exercise induced cramping is confused as "RLS" and now classified as a "disease" treated by expensive and dangerous drugs when simple timing of exercise and natural tonic water helps.
 

Cdubneeddeal

Diamond Member
Oct 22, 2003
7,473
3
81
Originally posted by: TallBill
Originally posted by: Cdubneeddeal
I think RLS is fake too. Perhaps it's more anxiety than anything. Stress maybe?

It's a proven nuerological disorder...

http://www.ninds.nih.gov/disor...ess_legs.htm#106053237

I do personally think that some of these guys that are supposedly getting RLS from ecxersise are falsely mis-diagnosing themselves.

From what I read of that is RLS is caused by something else. I'm not a doctor but wouldn't it be better to cure whatever is causing the RLS rather than taking a pill to treat RLS?
 

Megatomic

Lifer
Nov 9, 2000
20,127
6
81
Originally posted by: Amused
I hate to say it, but this is why it's best to run/exercise in the AM. Exercise in the PM will screw with your sleep.

Get out of bed earlier and run before work. It is better for you in SO many ways. You will sleep better, have more energy thoughout the day and your stress levels during the day will benefit as well. ALWAYS workout in the AM. It's easy, go to bed earlier and get up earlier.
I wish I could, but I have to be at work at 7am, it takes me almost an hour to get here, and I work at least 10 hours every day. The only chance I get to work out during the week is in the evenings. And it did used to mess with my sleep really badly, but I've gotten past that. I'm so tired when I lay down that even the chihuahuas can't keep me from passing out.
 

The Sauce

Diamond Member
Oct 31, 1999
4,741
34
91
Great example of what we in the biz refer to as "the placebo effect." Let us know if it still works in a month.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,505
146
Originally posted by: Snatchface
Great example of what we in the biz refer to as "the placebo effect." Let us know if it still works in a month.

Google tonic water +cramps.

Tonic water has an ingredient that was used for decades in easing cramps.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,505
146
Originally posted by: Megatomic
Originally posted by: Amused
I hate to say it, but this is why it's best to run/exercise in the AM. Exercise in the PM will screw with your sleep.

Get out of bed earlier and run before work. It is better for you in SO many ways. You will sleep better, have more energy thoughout the day and your stress levels during the day will benefit as well. ALWAYS workout in the AM. It's easy, go to bed earlier and get up earlier.
I wish I could, but I have to be at work at 7am, it takes me almost an hour to get here, and I work at least 10 hours every day. The only chance I get to work out during the week is in the evenings. And it did used to mess with my sleep really badly, but I've gotten past that. I'm so tired when I lay down that even the chihuahuas can't keep me from passing out.

Instead of working out in the evenings, go to bed an hour earilier and get up an hour earlier. Get up at 4am and work out.
 

DangerAardvark

Diamond Member
Oct 22, 2004
7,559
0
0
And out come the armchair skeptics. Now I'm as skeptical as the next guy, but I'm also skeptical of skeptics. Show me the data. Hell, I don't even need a link, just give me something more than a two line rant about fat people or the sinister cabal of pill-peddling doctors and pharmaceutical execs.
 

GasX

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
29,033
6
81
FYI - skeptic or not, tonic water does not cure RLS. It TREATS RLS. If you drank it and never had RLS again it would be a cure...
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,505
146
Originally posted by: Mwilding
FYI - skeptic or not, tonic water does not cure RLS. It TREATS RLS. If you drank it and never had RLS again it would be a cure...

Tonic water treats CRAMPS. If RLS is simply leg cramps, then yes: Tonic water treats it.

 

Megatomic

Lifer
Nov 9, 2000
20,127
6
81
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Megatomic
Originally posted by: Amused
I hate to say it, but this is why it's best to run/exercise in the AM. Exercise in the PM will screw with your sleep.

Get out of bed earlier and run before work. It is better for you in SO many ways. You will sleep better, have more energy thoughout the day and your stress levels during the day will benefit as well. ALWAYS workout in the AM. It's easy, go to bed earlier and get up earlier.
I wish I could, but I have to be at work at 7am, it takes me almost an hour to get here, and I work at least 10 hours every day. The only chance I get to work out during the week is in the evenings. And it did used to mess with my sleep really badly, but I've gotten past that. I'm so tired when I lay down that even the chihuahuas can't keep me from passing out.

Instead of working out in the evenings, go to bed an hour earilier and get up an hour earlier. Get up at 4am and work out.
I'm not a morning person, getting up at 5 is hard enough. :eek:
 

TallBill

Lifer
Apr 29, 2001
46,017
62
91
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Mwilding
FYI - skeptic or not, tonic water does not cure RLS. It TREATS RLS. If you drank it and never had RLS again it would be a cure...

Tonic water treats CRAMPS. If RLS is simply leg cramps, then yes: Tonic water treats it.

RLS isn't leg cramps. Leg cramps are falsely thought to be RLS.
 

LegendKiller

Lifer
Mar 5, 2001
18,256
68
86
Heh, it's amazing what people do to solve common problems. Drug themselves up.

I guess I could say I have suffered from RLS my whole life, as I have had a deep leg ache off and on from childhood. It keeps me up all night sometimes. It only got worse after my 2nd knee surgery.

What do I do? Take a couple advil and try to get some rest.

As far as ADD/ADHD, I think it's bullshit. Why? Because kids have always acted up, especially during situations where they are constrained. Add to the fact that parents spoil kids quite a bit, the fact that the kids are subjected to a constant bombarding of video games and flashy TV, you get problems focusing. IMHO, it has more to do with how we are raising kids rather than how they are hardwired. Add to that the fact that our educational system really tries to fit square pegs into round holes, rather than being more practical for kids not really bound for college, you get a situation where they hate going to physics class when they will end up being trade-people (which isn't a bad thing and not saying they aren't smart), and acting up accordingly.

Overall, it's a societal issue, not a biological one.
 

TallBill

Lifer
Apr 29, 2001
46,017
62
91
Originally posted by: Cdubneeddeal

From what I read of that is RLS is caused by something else. I'm not a doctor but wouldn't it be better to cure whatever is causing the RLS rather than taking a pill to treat RLS?

Yes, but they don't know what causes it or how to get rid of it.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,505
146
Originally posted by: TallBill
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Mwilding
FYI - skeptic or not, tonic water does not cure RLS. It TREATS RLS. If you drank it and never had RLS again it would be a cure...

Tonic water treats CRAMPS. If RLS is simply leg cramps, then yes: Tonic water treats it.

RLS isn't leg cramps. Leg cramps are falsely thought to be RLS.

Yes, I know. That's what I was trying to point out.

People get mild leg cramps and moving the legs makes the cramps go away until they become motionless again and the cramps return. They confuse this with RLS.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,347
19,505
146
Originally posted by: Megatomic
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Megatomic
Originally posted by: Amused
I hate to say it, but this is why it's best to run/exercise in the AM. Exercise in the PM will screw with your sleep.

Get out of bed earlier and run before work. It is better for you in SO many ways. You will sleep better, have more energy thoughout the day and your stress levels during the day will benefit as well. ALWAYS workout in the AM. It's easy, go to bed earlier and get up earlier.
I wish I could, but I have to be at work at 7am, it takes me almost an hour to get here, and I work at least 10 hours every day. The only chance I get to work out during the week is in the evenings. And it did used to mess with my sleep really badly, but I've gotten past that. I'm so tired when I lay down that even the chihuahuas can't keep me from passing out.

Instead of working out in the evenings, go to bed an hour earilier and get up an hour earlier. Get up at 4am and work out.
I'm not a morning person, getting up at 5 is hard enough. :eek:

What time it is, is irrelevant. If you can spend an hour exercising in the evening you can just go to bed earlier, and get up earlier to exercise.

It may be hard at first, but you'll feel MUCH better in the long run.
 

BornStar

Diamond Member
Oct 30, 2001
4,052
1
0
Originally posted by: TallBill
There are no words to describe what I feel in my leg. Varely rarely will it cause spasms, but often I have to move my legs around to ease the "pain". What I feel isn't a cramp or soreness. It just drives me fucking insane. I used to call them "crazy legs".
This is RLS. I never talked to my doctor about it because how do you tell someone about something you can't explain. Your legs just gradually feel like they need to move and it gets worse and worse until you actually move them, then it subsides for about half a second and starts over. I don't know that pain is the word I would use to describe it, it's just annoying.
 

SphinxnihpS

Diamond Member
Feb 17, 2005
8,368
25
91
ADHD is another way of saying, 'bored to death child that needs more time outside doing stuff', but let's drug them instead, to make them easier to deal with. You honestly think we went through recorded history with all these kids having ADHD and no Ritalin, and survived? It's kids being kids in a world where adults can no longer deal with them, period!

RLS is something wrong with your lifestyle. The only people I have ever known to have this are seriously overweight. Has it spread to normal people now, too?
 

911paramedic

Diamond Member
Jan 7, 2002
9,448
1
76
Originally posted by: amicold
Originally posted by: 911paramedic
Originally posted by: halik
RLS is about as real as ADHD
Let me guess, never had RLS so you have no idea what you are talking about.

I'm gonna jump on the BS bandwagon people fucking move cause they're uncomfortable not because they have a disorder. I run, jog, and sprint at least 25 miles a week often near bed time due to my work schedule, and I have no gonorrhea sensation to move my legs or limbs when I lay down.

:cookie:

I guess since you aren't effected by it, it must not exist, thanks for clearing that up Doc.