• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Time for an upgrade, help me choose a path

mike208

Member
1. What YOUR PC will be used for. That means what types of tasks you'll be performing.
My main reason for upgrading is for the new star wars MMO and also to finally get out of windows XP, lol. I do a lot of web browsing, may get into some light photo/video editing. Haven't done much yet, but it sounds like fun. Mostly general use kind of stuff. Lets just say I have been running an Athlon X2 3200+ with 2GB of ram for quite a while now, an it has done what I asked it to, albeit probably slower then what it needs to be. I usually stick to console games, but when a good game comes out thats pc only, I'd like to be able to play it and have it look acceptable. I don't need maxed graphics or 300 frames per second. As long as it plays good and looks ok, I'm happy.

2. What YOUR budget is. A price range is acceptable as long as it's not more than a 20% spread.
I'm sure I will get shot for this, but I haven't really set a budget. I would say I would like to do what I want as cheaply as possible, but then again who doesn't. I'm thinking less then $1000.00, but I may be able to bump that, depending on the best route to take, which is the reason I am posting here. Will explain later.

3. What country YOU will be buying YOUR parts from.
The USA, most likely from microcenter or newegg.

4. IF YOU have a brand preference. That means, are you an Intel-Fanboy, AMD-Fanboy, ATI-Fanboy, nVidia-Fanboy, Seagate-Fanboy, WD-Fanboy, etc.
I don't really have brand preference. I prefer to find the sweet spot. The best price for the performance.

5. If YOU intend on using any of YOUR current parts, and if so, what those parts are.
I don't think I will be carrying over any of my currents with the exception of possibly a hard drive until prices come back down on them. Oh the monitor, keyboard and mouse as well will be reused with this new build.

6. IF YOU have searched and/or read similar threads.
I have been browsing the general hardware, cpu/motherboard forums for a few days now. And I have looked at other peoples build threads.

7. IF YOU plan on overclocking or run the system at default speeds.
I am not against overclocking or unlocking extra cores as the case may be. But it is not something I need to do

8. What resolution YOU plan on gaming with.
As I said above as long as the games look good, thats fine by me. But I have a 23 inch samsung monitor(2343bwx) which uses a dual link dvi cable and has a rather strange native resolution. I believe it is 2048 x 1152. So I would prefer to run at that resolution to maintain good quality visuals. But if running a game at that res will require a crap load of money, I will have to sacrifice and bump the res down or play in window'd mode.

9. WHEN do you plan to build it?
Soon, potentially today, if I get the answers I am looking for.

I haven't put together a full build yet, but I have a couple of questions about parts I am considering.

Video cards I haven't really looked into. From what little I know, it seems as though ATI has come back in the last few years and are putting otu cards comparable to or better then nvidia(maybe I am wrong, please correct me if I am). But they also have so many models that are named so closely alike, I have no idea which to choose. But I admit, i haven't researched video cards much yet. So I may be able to figure this one out on my own in a few minutes.

Newegg currently has some G.Skill Ripjaws X Series 8GB(2x4GB) DDR3 1600 for $29.99. To get into 8GB of DDR3 at microcenter, I am looking at some Kingston HyperX blu 8GB DDR3-1333 for $35.00 bucks, or HyperX blu 8GB DDR3-1600 for $39.99. I am a bit impatient, so I would hate to get everything I need at microcenter today, then have to wait on the memory to ship from newegg to get it working. So is the memory from microcenter a good replacement for the G.Skill? I am willing to pay an extra 10 bucks to not have to wait for it to ship from newegg if its good enough. Or should I possibly find a cheap 2GB of ram to get a running unit this weekend and then order the g.skill from newegg? Or is there an even better ram deal out there that I am not aware of?

Lastly and probably most importantly is the processor and motherboard. As I said earlier microcenter is running some tempting bundle deals right now on both sides. Their current offers are:

AMD
Purchase a Phenom II X4 970 Black edition(139.99), Phenom II X2 560 Black edition($87.99), Phenom II X6 1055T($119.99), Phenom II X6 1090T Black Edition($159.99) and Phenom II X6 1100T black edition($179.99) and you get a Gigabyte GA-78MLT-S2P, Biostar A780L3G or MSI NF725GM-P43 motherboard for free, or $30.00 bucks off any other motherboard. I know there is the possibility to unlock the extra cores on the Phenom II X2 560 black edition($87.99), and I also hear the X6 1055T($119.99) is a good deal.

Intel
$50.00 off anyZ68 or P67 motherboard with purchase of Core i5 2500K($179.99)

Even with the cheapest intel motherboard, I am looking at almost $300.00 to get into the core i5 setup(correction, I was only looking at the motherboards int he ad, they do have some cheaper ones which would get me into a core i5 for closer to $250, which stills puts me above the price of the higher end AMD deals), which I am sure will probably be a better perform then the potential AMD setups. But I have the possibility of getting a Phenom II X2 560 black edition, which has the possibility of unlocking an addition 2 cores for $87.99, or jump to one of the Phenom II X6 models, like the X6 1055T for $119.99, and both of those deals include a free motherboard. So I would definitely be able to get into AMD way cheaper, but how long would an AMD system last me compared to the 2500k intel system? As you can tell by my current rig, I tend to milk my systems for several years past their prime.

Also, I am so out of the loop on these AMD processors. Especially when you add in the fact that I can possibly take the X2 560 up to 4 cores. I have been trying to read some reviews and look at benchmarks. But there are so many variants on both intel and amd's sides, I am having a hard time figure out which option is best for me. I understand fewer faster cores like the core i5 will likely be better for gaming, where as the more, slower cores of some of the amd processors will exceed at more multi threaded applications. I do multi task a lot, and often have way more tabs open in firefox then most users.

I guess I would say I am leaning towards AMD(not sure which one though)because it will be so much cheaper to get into. But I don't want to regret it in 2 years when the system feels sluggish where as the core i5 may still feel blazing fast.

I know I said lastly about 5 paragraphs ago, but one final question, I promise. Is there any reason I should consider a prebuilt machine as opposed to building my own? I am capable of building my own, that is not the problem. But I do need to upgrade to windows 7, which i will have to buy. I am just wondering if there are any good deals out there on a prebuilt that will make it worth not building my own.

Thanks a bunch and happy holidays to everyone.
 
Last edited:
the AMD processors aren't as efficient as the intel
if overclocking, the difference is even more pronounced

furthermore, AMDs performance is way under intels at the moment
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/147?vs=288


http://forums.anandtech.com/showthread.php?t=2211456
ati 6950 2gb w/ some games $230 (AR $30)
http://slickdeals.net/forums/showthread.php?t=3683402
128gb kingston SSD $134 (no rebate)
HDD might want to wait a bit (due to the shortage)

case:
antec 300 illusion $40AR
antec 300 (non illusion has less fans can buy your own later) $35 AR or CM storm scout $60 AR

PSU
seasonic 520w ~$70
corsair cx500 $50AR

optical drive $20 DVD or ~60-80 Bluray


gskill 2x4gb ddr3 1600 $30
(the kingstons use 1.65v at 1600, i would recommend running them at 1333 1.5v or 1600 1.5v if possible)
assuming you do go intel ~$250 w/mobo

~$755 (still need windows, maybe some speakers or headphones)
 
Last edited:
Mobo Asrock Z68 Extreme3 Gen3 $115 AR
CPU i5-2500K $180 (in-store from Microcenter; also, could be there's still the promo i.e. u get $60 off on Z68 motherboards); stick with stock cooler for now, buy aftermarket cooler for OC later whenever you want to
RAM G.Skill RipjawsX $30 <-- grab it before it goes OOS, won't find a better deal
GPU 6870 1GB $150 should run SWTOR without hiccups
HDD Use what you have for storage
SSD Crucial M4 64GB $110 or 128GB $210
ODD You may be able to reuse that
PSU XFX 650W $50 AR (future proof for possible crossfire setup or high end GPU + overclocking)
Case Several options that are good... e.g. Corsair 400R, Fractal Design R3 or Arc Midi, CM HAF series, CM 690 II, Antec P280, Silverstone and Lian-Li cases etc. +1 on the 300 Illusion though, nice deal.

Ends up at around $800 AR with the 128GB SSD
 
Last edited:
Lehtv's build is good, though given your upgrade frequency (or lack thereof), I would go with the $230 AR Twin Frozr II 6950 2GB that fralexandr linked.
 
Lehtv's build is good, though given your upgrade frequency (or lack thereof), I would go with the $230 AR Twin Frozr II 6950 2GB that fralexandr linked.

I can upgrade the video card when needed. I don't game on my computer much, I prefer consoles. But when a PC only game comes along I want to play, I want to be able to play it. I/you guys had talked me into getting the intel combo. But then I talked to some friends at work and almost all of them are running amd, and kept telling me how much cheaper it is and how I could put the money saved to a bigger ssd or better video card.

I like the idea of spending less. But I like the idea of future upgradability. As you pointed out, I don't upgrade too often. Heck, if i could do it on the cheap, I would tempted to just upgrade my video card, processor and ram in the computer i have now. But seeing as how I am still using DDR, an upgrade won't be cheap. But realistically, I know its time for a new machine.

So what I am thinking is if I go with the intel combo, I can probably get a cheap ivy bridge processor a few years down the road as a nice upgrade. Where as I think the AM3 socket for AMD is about done, correct? I like the idea of being able to upgrade the intel setup in the future. But whats to say in 3 or 4 years that we won't be into DDR4 and DDR3 will cost what DDR does now.

So I am still very torn on if it is better to go cheaper with AMD now, or bet on possible future upgradability with intel.
 
AMD makes pretty much no sense from a price/performance point of view until you get into CPUs that are below $100. If the i5 is too rich for your blood, get an i3 2100, it is faster than AMD Phenom II X4's when it comes to gaming.

As for upgrading, socket longevity doesn't even figure into the equation IMHO. On the Intel side, SB->IB isn't going to be worthwhile (unless you go from a $100 SB to a $200 IB) and Haswell is a different socket. AM3+'s future is similarly murky beyond BD.
 
AMD makes pretty much no sense from a price/performance point of view until you get into CPUs that are below $100. If the i5 is too rich for your blood, get an i3 2100, it is faster than AMD Phenom II X4's when it comes to gaming.

As for upgrading, socket longevity doesn't even figure into the equation IMHO. On the Intel side, SB->IB isn't going to be worthwhile (unless you go from a $100 SB to a $200 IB) and Haswell is a different socket. AM3+'s future is similarly murky beyond BD.


I think I can manage the i5 combo. As I said, i was pretty set on it, but I am impressionable, lol, so I ran with what a couple of my coworkers were telling me. But I just went and read another review of the 2500k, and man does it blow AMD out of the water. So I will stick with it.

I replied to another posters thread in which you told them to make sure they get 1.5V ram. But I will post it here too. What is the significance of 1.5V as compared to 1.65V? I really should just order that g.skill from newegg, but I am afraid it won't be here by the time I get the rest of my parts around, and that won't make me happy lol. And I will definitely be building by friday at the latest. I can get some 1.5V ram from microcenter, but I know it will cost me more then 30 bucks for 8GB
 
How does the Biostar / TZ68A+RCH motherboard compare to the big 3(asus, msi, gigabyte)? It was used in the intel holiday 2011 mid range system buyers guide. And microcenter currently has a $10.00 rebate on it. Also, I am not sure if it will apply with the bundle deal. But I may be able to get a discount on it. So in theory I could have it for $102.84, minus the $10 rebate, and minus the $50 bundle discount. For a total cost on the motherboard of $42.84. Total with the 2500k would be $222.83 before tax.
 
Last edited:
I think I can manage the i5 combo. As I said, i was pretty set on it, but I am impressionable, lol, so I ran with what a couple of my coworkers were telling me. But I just went and read another review of the 2500k, and man does it blow AMD out of the water. So I will stick with it.

Sounds good!

I replied to another posters thread in which you told them to make sure they get 1.5V ram. But I will post it here too. What is the significance of 1.5V as compared to 1.65V? I really should just order that g.skill from newegg, but I am afraid it won't be here by the time I get the rest of my parts around, and that won't make me happy lol. And I will definitely be building by friday at the latest. I can get some 1.5V ram from microcenter, but I know it will cost me more then 30 bucks for 8GB

1.5V is the standard DDR3 voltage and what the Sandy Bridge memory controller was designed for. 1.65V will technically work, but it can shorten the life of your memory controller due to the higher voltage. Since 1.5V and 1.65V cost the same, it doesn't make sense to get 1.65V.
 
How does the Biostar / TZ68A+RCH motherboard compare to the big 3(asus, msi, gigabyte)? It was used in the intel holiday 2011 mid range system buyers guide. And microcenter currently has a $10.00 rebate on it. Also, I am not sure if it will apply with the bundle deal. But I may be able to get a discount on it. So in theory I could have it for $102.84, minus the $10 rebate, and minus the $50 bundle discount. For a total cost on the motherboard of $42.84. Total with the 2500k would be $222.83 before tax.

Biostar is fine IMHO, but that board really annoys me because they only put 2 channel audio with no digital out. It might not matter to you though.
 
Biostar is fine IMHO, but that board really annoys me because they only put 2 channel audio with no digital out. It might not matter to you though.

Thanks for the info about the ram voltage. Not sure i feel about the audio on this biostar board. My current gaming setup uses only 2 channel audio, so i dont have a need for better audio, but it would be nice to have just in case. I suppose i could always add in a dedicated sound card later if need be. Or i could go with one of the asus, msi or gigabyte boards. But how does the onboard sound compare to a mid range dedicated sound card?
 
Unless you have reasonably good speakers or headphones (ie. > $100), you won't notice a difference between the onboard and a sound card. The best way to upgrade the audio in a machine IMHO is not to add a sound card, but to get an external amp/DAC device that you can send S/PDIF digital audio to. Note that the TZ68A+RCH does not even have S/PDIF output.
 
Unless you have reasonably good speakers or headphones (ie. > $100), you won't notice a difference between the onboard and a sound card. The best way to upgrade the audio in a machine IMHO is not to add a sound card, but to get an external amp/DAC device that you can send S/PDIF digital audio to. Note that the TZ68A+RCH does not even have S/PDIF output.


I am definitely looking into a good pair of headphones now, trying to find something I can use for both my xbox and PC. Since I like to play a lot while my girlfriend watches tv in the same room. So I want to block her sound from getting to me and mine from hers. And good speakers are not of the question eventually. So I'm thinking maybe I should avoid the biostar and look elsewhere.

Do you have any suggestions for a motherboard. I am getting this at microcenter int he bundle deal with the 2500k, and I don't believe they sell the asrock board that lehtv linked to that you said was good.

Before the biostar, I was considering asus, msi and maybe gigabyte(for some reason I don't like gigabyte, and I really have nothing to base this on that I can recall. Don't know that I've ever used them before, but something in the back of my mind is not licking them, lol, call me crazy)
 
Microcenter is a big Gigabyte reseller, so you'll find a lot of selection. I don' think that there's anything wrong with their boards (I've used a ton in my day). Unfortunately, MC doesn't have the greatest mobo selection listed on their web site. The least expensive Z68 with 6-channel audio and digital out is the GA-Z68XP-UD3.
 
Microcenter is a big Gigabyte reseller, so you'll find a lot of selection. I don' think that there's anything wrong with their boards (I've used a ton in my day). Unfortunately, MC doesn't have the greatest mobo selection listed on their web site. The least expensive Z68 with 6-channel audio and digital out is the GA-Z68XP-UD3.


I will check out that gigabyte. And just to let you know, my microcenter appears to have 2 motherboards that are not listed on the main microcenter site. They are an MSI zz68ma-ed55 mATX($150) and an Asus p8z68-v LX($120), which also appears to have 6-channel audio.

A lot of these motherboards are just so close together, its hard to pinpoint the differences
 
Since they have the LX in stock, I'd grab that. It's actually be board I was looking ofr and was wondering, "what the hell, where is this thing?"
 
Back
Top