Good afternoon,
This is interesting. I have ordered a wide variety of parts from Newegg over the last couple years and theyalways arrived promptly, in decent shape, and the parts were exactly what I'd ordered. Never had to return anything, never was deceived (OEM parts masquerading as retail).
However, I'd always ordered online, never had to speak with someone in person.
Visa guarantees your orders, if you used Visa to purchase. Post another message if you have time, am curious what Newegg will say when you finally get through to them to process the RMA.
Best of luck,
PCM