• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

This guy tried so hard to get killed by a tornado

(Yes, he had plenty of time to accelerate down the road away from it.)

But, if you can't avoid it, I always thought that under a bridge was supposed to be one of the safer areas - get out of the car, climb the hill on the side of the road, get up to the girders of the bridge, and hold on for dear life. Girders protect you from flying debris, and afaik, bridges are relatively tornado-proof.
 
(Yes, he had plenty of time to accelerate down the road away from it.)

But, if you can't avoid it, I always thought that under a bridge was supposed to be one of the safer areas - get out of the car, climb the hill on the side of the road, get up to the girders of the bridge, and hold on for dear life. Girders protect you from flying debris, and afaik, bridges are relatively tornado-proof.

Fail.

What is a wind tunnel?

wtdiagram.jpg


It's a large fan in an area that becomes more narrow in the test section. Because all that air has to squeeze through the more narrow section, the wind accelerates.

What are underpasses? They are usually these nice, sloped banks of dirt leading into the narrow underpass.

If you want to experience a 120mph tornado, avoid the underpass. If you want to experience a 160-180 mph tornado, stay in an underpass.
 
Fail.

What is a wind tunnel?


It's a large fan in an area that becomes more narrow in the test section. Because all that air has to squeeze through the more narrow section, the wind accelerates.

What are underpasses? They are usually these nice, sloped banks of dirt leading into the narrow underpass.

If you want to experience a 120mph tornado, avoid the underpass. If you want to experience a 160-180 mph tornado, stay in an underpass.

A bridge underpass is not an narrowing, enclosed space. The cross section of a bridge underpass is the same all the way through.

pc_az_sr260_tonto_200504-01.jpg


Why would all the air try to move to the tightest part of the embankment? You fail at physics.
 
If you climbed all the way up the bank as he suggested, up in between the girders you would not be subject to the direct debris impact or wind.
 
As the NOAA website mentions (look at slides 4, 7 and 8) hiding under an overpass is a really *BAD* idea.

Not every overpass has exposed girders and not all of those that do are easy to hide in.

In an urban area, a tornado or severe storm will contain a lot more debris, making it much more dangerous.

Lastly, if everyone runs for the underpass, its going to create a massive traffic jam. Everyone else will be stuck inside their vehicles. Afterwards, fire and rescue personnel will have a much more difficult time responding to calls for help.
 

As stated in the caption for slide 11, to our knowledge, there have not been any specific modeling studies done about the airflow interaction between a tornado and an overpass. However, based on our current knowledge of airflow through and around obstacles, such as buildings and other man-made structures, it is possible to indicate the outcome of an interaction between a tornado and an overpass with a fairly high degree of confidence. In general, the wind speed decreases as we approach the surface, becoming zero right at the ground. This is why one of the first and foremost rules in general tornado safety is to get as low as possible, because that is where the wind speed is the lowest! By climbing up underneath the overpass, people are moving into a place where the wind speeds typically will be higher. In addition, under an overpass, it is possible in some situations that when air is forced through the narrow passage underneath the bridge, this might cause an increase in the wind speeds (as mentioned earlier). Further, under different circumstances, the area beneath and just downstream of an overpass might become a debris deposition zone, where piles of debris accumulate, as was the case at the Shields Boulevard overpass on 3 May 1999

In other words, sometimes, maybe, but they don't really know. Frankly, I'll take my chances in the underpass rather than just lying down out in the open.
 
I would just keep driving. From all the amateur storm chaser videos I've seen, tornadoes don't look that difficult to outmaneuver if you're in the path of one. If the tornado is "rain wrapped" and you can't see it, that's another story.
 
I would just keep driving. From all the amateur storm chaser videos I've seen, tornadoes don't look that difficult to outmaneuver if you're in the path of one. If the tornado is "rain wrapped" and you can't see it, that's another story.

The problem isn't the tornado itself. It's the farm animals it's throwing through your windshield. That's the reason I'd go under the bridge, to avoid the debris.
 
Dude is stupid. "Looks it might be headed this way...ho hum. Guess I could duck down." Missed opportunity, Darwin.
This.

(Yes, he had plenty of time to accelerate down the road away from it.)

But, if you can't avoid it, I always thought that under a bridge was supposed to be one of the safer areas - get out of the car, climb the hill on the side of the road, get up to the girders of the bridge, and hold on for dear life. Girders protect you from flying debris, and afaik, bridges are relatively tornado-proof.
No. So much fail.

I would just keep driving. From all the amateur storm chaser videos I've seen, tornadoes don't look that difficult to outmaneuver if you're in the path of one. If the tornado is "rain wrapped" and you can't see it, that's another story.
Tornadoes can move very fast, and can also change direction suddenly.
 
Back
Top