I'll post a short review after a couple of hours when I play today. Its still in my car. Second son will definitely be a purchase for me.
Edit: from another thief thread.
I've played a bit of thief tonite on ps4. I definitely see frames drop during cutscenes. It did say a download was ready to install but I didn't install it and kept playing. So far the atmosphere is interesting, you have to keep quiet and hidden and I haven't played a stealth game in a while, nor am I too good. It's fun sneaking around stealing coins from guards and such. On the master difficulty guards do see you easier than on normal. I did get caught a bunch of times.
One thing I don't like is the controls seem kind of clunky but after sometime they get better once you get used to it.
I like making my way around trying to grab anything unseen. At times I wonder if I should take down someone or not, that's my biggest concern. Not knowing when to use a take down or chance sneaking again.
So far I'm liking the game and its really not as bad as everyone is making it out to be.