There is no such thing as an Athiest

Page 8 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Skyclad1uhm1

Lifer
Aug 10, 2001
11,383
87
91
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
another question for all you who don't believe in God....

What do you do with your guilt?

Why do you need a God for guilt? When you wrong a person you can feel bad towards him or her, and make it up to that person or ignore it.
 

crisp82

Golden Member
Apr 8, 2002
1,920
0
0
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
another question for all you who don't believe in God....

What do you do with your guilt?

Great statement!!!

All atheists are emtionless neanderthals who walk around doing as they please because the have no guilt.

Boy, I would kick ur ass if you were here now!

Just because Atheists don't lokk up to god and abide by his laws, doesn't mean they don't look up to the laws of soceity.
 

ThaPerculator

Golden Member
May 11, 2001
1,449
0
0
What do you think that the doctrine of the non-existance of diety is, if it is not a positive statement that a diety (i.e. a god, any god) does not exist? I'd love to see you wriggle out of that one.

All I know is that I sure as hell didn't make a doctrine about anything. I don't care what "organized" atheists say. I go by the definition.

That's like saying that since some uber-christian said that people buried dinosaur bones all over the earth as a conspiracy for evolution, you believe that and are accountable for that statement. Shut up already.
 

ThaPerculator

Golden Member
May 11, 2001
1,449
0
0
Of course there are. Most atheits are bitter and therefore vocal. Never you mind them

Funny I'm not the one who "vocally" goes door-to-door to sell my religion. I'm not the one who organizes every sunday to put a "voice" to my ideas. I keep my ideas/beliefs inside and unless somebody gives me a reason to respond about them. Basically the only time we come out of the woodwork is when somebody has our views wrong and we point it out that they have the concept wrong. Of course there are the extremists, but in general the far majority of extremists are wrong in all circumstances.

Never close off your mind to the possibility of the unknown. Just don't assume that the unkown will happen, because someone says that it will.

The best quote to close this out... and it works for all the Theists, Agnostics and Atheists.
"God does not play dice" - Albert Einstein
 

meehawl

Member
Dec 13, 2002
70
0
0
Originally posted by: WRXFanaticno im just basing what i personally know about christianity from the bible and from my church

There is no God but Allah, and Mohammed is his Prophet
- Islamic Creed, Koran, ~550 CE

I pledge myself to the Mazdayasnian religion ... which of all religions that exist or shall be, is the greatest, the best, and the most beautiful: Ahuric, Zoroastrian. I ascribe all good to Ahura Mazda [God].
- Zoroastrian Creed, the Hymns of Zarathushtra, 550 BCE

Zoroastrianism was the original monotheistic religion in the Mediterranean region and many of the ideas in Judaism, Christianity, Mithraism, and Islam can be traced back to Zoroastrians. They were the first people, for example, to conceive of a religious narrative as a dualistic story of a battle between two forces of good and evil and associated angelic powers, and also that the creation of the universe would take seven "days". The Zoroastrians still exist today as "Parsees".

http://www.avesta.org/pahlavi/zadspram.html

However, the idea of theophagy, the eating of the body of God by worshippers, and a consequent godly resurrection is a much older idea and can be traced back in written texts to the Osiris Cult in Ancient Egypt, ~ 2000 BCE.

http://en2.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osiris
http://www.medmalexperts.com/POCM/pagan_christs_osiris.html

The Osirists also perfected the ritual of baptism for their new believers:
Initiation into the Mysteries of Isis / Osiris began with the priest reading to the initiate from the ancient sacred books. Then the priest led the initiate to a bath near the temple, where he (or she, the Mysteries were open to either sex) bathed. After bathing he was sprinkled with purifying water brought from Nile.

The Mithraists borrowed the idea of theophagy from the Egyptians at around the same time as the Christians, and this led to a huge degree of rivalry between the young cults in the Roman Empire from around 150AD as both accused the other of stealing their best ideas. But in fact the Mithraists popularized this idea first and the early Christian writers said therefore that "Satan" had deliberately planted the idea several decades before Christianity arrived in order to sow doubt and confusion in the minds of prospective Christians. YMMV.

http://www.truthbeknown.com/mithra.htm

http://en2.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mithraism

It is surmised that the Mithraists worshipped Mithras, as the supreme God of the upper and nether world. Their beliefs apparently included that their god died, was buried in a rock tomb, and was resurrected.

Recall that in some of the Christian resurrection stories, the witnesses see that Jesus has emerged from a cave, and that a rock blocking the entrance has been cast aside...
 

coomarlin

Senior member
Dec 19, 2000
796
0
71
Originally posted by: minendo
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
ok...this is just something i thought about....how do actual athiests exist?
they claim that there is no God, therefore admitting to the fact that they are omniscent (all knowing?), therefore putting themselves in the place of God because only God is all knowing....

any thoughts?
That is the dumbest flamebait I have ever seen posted.

LOL. I agree. Pure flamebait. Looks like the guy got what he wanted. Almost 200 replys.

 

matt426malm

Golden Member
Nov 14, 2003
1,280
0
0
Originally posted by: Soybomb
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
another question for all you who don't believe in God....

What do you do with your guilt?

I keep it in the cabinet, next to the nasty cans of cambells chunky soup. Seriously what are you talking about? I deal with guilt just like I would with any other emotion such as rage, love, confusion, happiness, etc.

Jesus Christ has an entire book written about him. His existance is proven, his miricles documented in a book that is historically accurate and in all ways possible, proven correct.
Phhhhfffft a book? Lando Calrissians been in two movies!! Now thats star power. Lando Bless you!

any thoughts on why there are so many atheists on AT
We're full of geeks and I think most geeks give more weight to science than blind faith. Just because I may not have all the answers does not mean it has to be attributed to a god, its just something we don't understand yet. The notion of a rain god didn't seem too silly to many people once. Now we can explain rain. Someday we may be able to answer questions as to the origin of the universe.

Religion is fine if thats your thing, I've developed my own guidelines and feelings about life and intend to live according to them. I would feel foolish trying to mold my life to please a diety that I have no proof of the existance of.

"I contend we are both Atheists - I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you reject all other gods, you will understand why I reject yours." -Stephen F. Roberts

That is what I was thinking
 

GasX

Lifer
Feb 8, 2001
29,033
6
81
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
ok...this is just something i thought about....how do actual athiests exist?
they claim that there is no God, therefore admitting to the fact that they are omniscent (all knowing?), therefore putting themselves in the place of God because only God is all knowing....

any thoughts?
you are an idiot?

 

matt426malm

Golden Member
Nov 14, 2003
1,280
0
0
Originally posted by: Mwilding
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
ok...this is just something i thought about....how do actual athiests exist?
they claim that there is no God, therefore admitting to the fact that they are omniscent (all knowing?), therefore putting themselves in the place of God because only God is all knowing....

any thoughts?
you are an idiot?


Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
"another question for all you who don't believe in God....

What do you do with your guilt?"



This quote really takes the cake.
 

element

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,635
0
0
"I contend we are both Atheists - I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you reject all other gods, you will understand why I reject yours." -Stephen F. Roberts

Given that quote, I surmise there are no theists. only athiests and agnostics. To be a theist you must beleive in all gods. Or else you are an athiest to people who beleive ina different god than yours.

In other news this is the worst thread I've ever had constipation in. (I couldn't bring myself to crap in it even though it is worthy of none other than said crap.)

BTW what I posted is pure BS, and nothing but pure BS so help me....umm...whatever being may or may not have creared the universe. Man that's a long phrase for god. We need a new word for "possible diety" One that may or may not exist. ~God perhaps? Approximate God? No I dunno something like that. +-God? or, Pod? Perhaps God? hmm that would be PG I guess. Ok from now on PG is what you must call it, and the word God is banned....BAND! so no more crappy threads on thing you know nothing aboot.

While we're at it ban 0.99...=1, people get stuck on that too.

MOTION FOR BAND!
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
Given that quote, I surmise there are no theists. only athiests and agnostics. To be a theist you must beleive in all gods. Or else you are an athiest to people who beleive ina different god than yours.

??? your reading it wrong. and your assuming one can only be one when its not true. you can be an athiest in terms of other gods, but a thiest in terms of your own. understand?
 

coomarlin

Senior member
Dec 19, 2000
796
0
71
Please people lets just let this thread die. It's not worth hogging up space on the AT servers.
 

0roo0roo

No Lifer
Sep 21, 2002
64,795
84
91
Originally posted by: coomarlin
Please people lets just let this thread die. It's not worth hogging up space on the AT servers.

and yet all the other threads on ot are somehow full of substance, wit and insight?
 

element

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
4,635
0
0
Originally posted by: 0roo0roo
Given that quote, I surmise there are no theists. only athiests and agnostics. To be a theist you must beleive in all gods. Or else you are an athiest to people who beleive ina different god than yours.

??? your reading it wrong. and your assuming one can only be one when its not true. you can be an athiest in terms of other gods, but a thiest in terms of your own. understand?

I not only understand, that is exactly what I was saying. I specifically said "athiest to people who believe in a different god than yours."

The whole point I was making albeit slightly in jest, was that both athiests and thiests are wrong. And agnostics simply say bah we don't know. Here is how it really is: god both exists and doesn't exist at the same time.

See it's like Shrodinger's cat thought experiment. If you can't see in the box, we say that the cat is both dead and alive at the same time. A particle you can't verify both exists and doesnt exist at the same time. Hence god both exists and doesn't exist at the same time. You must give merit to both sides because either may be right.

Btw, and I say again this is all in jest and I'm just screwing around. I don't really beleive in the nonsense I'm spewing I'm just yammering to give you something to think about, and counter if you must.
 

matt426malm

Golden Member
Nov 14, 2003
1,280
0
0
Originally posted by: 0roo0roo
Originally posted by: coomarlin
Please people lets just let this thread die. It's not worth hogging up space on the AT servers.

and yet all the other threads on ot are somehow full of substance, wit and insight?

yah lets keep it to constructive posts like **OFFICIAL** -What is in your mouth RIGHT NOW?- thread.
 

astroview

Golden Member
Dec 14, 1999
1,907
0
0
You're right, there is no such thing as an athiest. There are atheists though.

Oh btw your logic is seriously flawed too.
 

Dedpuhl

Lifer
Nov 20, 1999
10,370
0
76
Originally posted by: meehawl
Originally posted by: WRXFanaticno im just basing what i personally know about christianity from the bible and from my church

There is no God but Allah, and Mohammed is his Prophet
- Islamic Creed, Koran, ~550 CE

I pledge myself to the Mazdayasnian religion ... which of all religions that exist or shall be, is the greatest, the best, and the most beautiful: Ahuric, Zoroastrian. I ascribe all good to Ahura Mazda [God].
- Zoroastrian Creed, the Hymns of Zarathushtra, 550 BCE

Zoroastrianism was the original monotheistic religion in the Mediterranean region and many of the ideas in Judaism, Christianity, Mithraism, and Islam can be traced back to Zoroastrians. They were the first people, for example, to conceive of a religious narrative as a dualistic story of a battle between two forces of good and evil and associated angelic powers, and also that the creation of the universe would take seven "days". The Zoroastrians still exist today as "Parsees".

http://www.avesta.org/pahlavi/zadspram.html

However, the idea of theophagy, the eating of the body of God by worshippers, and a consequent godly resurrection is a much older idea and can be traced back in written texts to the Osiris Cult in Ancient Egypt, ~ 2000 BCE.

http://en2.wikipedia.org/wiki/Osiris
http://www.medmalexperts.com/POCM/pagan_christs_osiris.html

The Osirists also perfected the ritual of baptism for their new believers:
Initiation into the Mysteries of Isis / Osiris began with the priest reading to the initiate from the ancient sacred books. Then the priest led the initiate to a bath near the temple, where he (or she, the Mysteries were open to either sex) bathed. After bathing he was sprinkled with purifying water brought from Nile.

The Mithraists borrowed the idea of theophagy from the Egyptians at around the same time as the Christians, and this led to a huge degree of rivalry between the young cults in the Roman Empire from around 150AD as both accused the other of stealing their best ideas. But in fact the Mithraists popularized this idea first and the early Christian writers said therefore that "Satan" had deliberately planted the idea several decades before Christianity arrived in order to sow doubt and confusion in the minds of prospective Christians. YMMV.

http://www.truthbeknown.com/mithra.htm

http://en2.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mithraism

It is surmised that the Mithraists worshipped Mithras, as the supreme God of the upper and nether world. Their beliefs apparently included that their god died, was buried in a rock tomb, and was resurrected.

Recall that in some of the Christian resurrection stories, the witnesses see that Jesus has emerged from a cave, and that a rock blocking the entrance has been cast aside...


shhhhhhhhhh. No one's supposed to know that early Christians stole most of their ideas from other religions.
 

CTho9305

Elite Member
Jul 26, 2000
9,214
1
81
Originally posted by: matt426malm
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
another question for all you who don't believe in God....

What do you do with your guilt?

WHAT, I go to confessional DuH!!!! A. I let it fester inside until I deveop an ulcer B. do something to amend what I feel guilty of C. Forget about it

Nobody ever said atheists wouldn't rather have a god who can make them feel better / they can blame / they can ask for help / gives them hope / etc. I think life would probably be easier if I believed in god... it just so happens that I don't think there is one (or if there is, he sure isn't doing anything significant), and can't just change my beliefs because I'd rather beleive something else. I'd rather not have to believe in, for example, quantum mechanics... it's a pain in the a$$, but the evidence points to it.
 

matt426malm

Golden Member
Nov 14, 2003
1,280
0
0
Originally posted by: CTho9305
Originally posted by: matt426malm
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
another question for all you who don't believe in God....

What do you do with your guilt?

WHAT, I go to confessional DuH!!!! A. I let it fester inside until I deveop an ulcer B. do something to amend what I feel guilty of C. Forget about it

Nobody ever said atheists wouldn't rather have a god who can make them feel better / they can blame / they can ask for help / gives them hope / etc. I think life would probably be easier if I believed in god... it just so happens that I don't think there is one (or if there is, he sure isn't doing anything significant), and can't just change my beliefs because I'd rather beleive something else. I'd rather not have to believe in, for example, quantum mechanics... it's a pain in the a$$, but the evidence points to it.


WHAT, I go to confessional DuH!!! <----(sarcasm)
I was just stunned by wrxfantic's response. Quantum mechanics, relativity, superstring love reading about that stuff. Oh yah I think that beliving in God would be way easier. Well except for waking up before 11 on sunday. lol
 

PaperclipGod

Banned
Apr 7, 2003
2,021
0
0
Originally posted by: 0roo0roo
moral panics sig says it best.

I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours."
-Stephen Roberts

its so simple, so true, it destroys any reason to continue the thread.

considering how many religions there have been throughout time, theres a good chance that even if one is correct, you probably chose wrong:p

 

TheVrolok

Lifer
Dec 11, 2000
24,254
4,092
136
Originally posted by: minendo
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
ok...this is just something i thought about....how do actual athiests exist?
they claim that there is no God, therefore admitting to the fact that they are omniscent (all knowing?), therefore putting themselves in the place of God because only God is all knowing....

any thoughts?
That is the dumbest flamebait I have ever seen posted.

I'm going to stop reading the thread at this point and just completely agree.
 
D

Deleted member 4644

Originally posted by: Fausto
Originally posted by: WRXFanatic
ok...this is just something i thought about....how do actual athiests exist?
they claim that there is no God, therefore admitting to the fact that they are omniscent (all knowing?), therefore putting themselves in the place of God because only God is all knowing....

any thoughts?
I think you should have at least 100 posts under your belt before starting a flame war.

I concur.
 

MillionaireNextDoor

Platinum Member
Nov 16, 2000
2,918
1
0
Originally posted by: Fausto
Originally posted by: conjur
Originally posted by: Moralpanic
they claim that there is no God, therefore admitting to the fact that they are omniscent (all knowing?), therefore putting themselves in the place of God because only God is all knowing....

Well, this is the stupidiest logic i've ever heard before.

As for real athiest... we're ALL born atheist. Nobody is born knowing God, they're taught it.

A friend of mine and I got into a short debate on this a while back.

*IF* a child was raised with NO religious influences, was kept totally unaware of religion and a God or gods or reincarnation or karma or whatever, would that child naturally wonder or believe something created the earth and life upon it?
Who knows? Early man (and even very isolated tribes here and there) have some ideas about what may or may not be beyond human comprehension. Adding knowledge of modern science into that equation might undo the formulation of those kinds of thoughts, however. <shrug>


I see. Well, believers existing today is proof that that child will someday do just that. He/she will naturally seek out the answers. For those who say the believers were taught, I ask a question; who taught the teachers? If it exists now, it surely must've had a beginning since effects cannot be uncaused.

But since effects cannot be uncaused, surely that means effects should not exist without a first cause; a cause that itself is uncaused. Whatever or whoever was that first cause must've had the ability (or authority) to break the rule of causality.

Enjoy your food for thought.