There doesn't seem to be a lot of diversity in the English language.

Martin

Lifer
Jan 15, 2000
29,178
1
81
Not necessarily a bad thing, just an observation of mine. English is spoken very widely today - British Isles, North America, Oceania and by a lot of Indians - but even though its so widespread there isn't much difference apart from accents and a few words (ie lift vs elevator).

I'm using Bulgarian as my basis for comparison here. I've been listening to this CD by Gothart (a Czech band that does modern interpretations of various Balkan folk songs), which includes a few Bulgarian songs, and I have a really hard time making out the lyrics, since they are sung using in the traditional dialects of whichever region the song is from. In fact, I have an easier time understanding the Macedonian songs than some of the Bulgarian ones.

This isn't the case so much any more, since the government has been pushing an 'official' Bulgarian for many decades, but if you go around you'll find people (especially older ones) that speak much differently. The interesting thing is that Bulgaria is quite small and has a small population, so you get situations like a town whose traditional dialect is almost unintelligible in a town 60 miles a way.

I've heard that such traditional German is even more diverse than that - and it makes sense since Germans are so numerous and were separated for so many centuries...
 

Atheus

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2005
7,313
2
0
There are places in Britain where I can't understand most people, especially if I've been out of the country and aren't used to it.
 

SoundTheSurrender

Diamond Member
Mar 13, 2005
3,126
0
0
Its because English only spread within the last 300 or so years I think? Slavic languages for the most part spread over 1,000 years. I speak Polish, can understand a bit of Czech since that is the closet language to Polish. I can understand a bit of Russian after I learned some basic words because a lot of Russian words have the same slavic root sounds or the more basic words are the same as Polish. Tak, Nie (yes and no in Polish), Da, Niet (yes or no in Russian.) I am fascinated with Slavic languages, I wish I could learn them all or at least Russian because I think Cyrillic is awesome.

German and English are part of the same language group. English came from German I think. There are some words that have the same root sound. Montag, Fritag = Monday, Friday. There are many other words that have similar touch.
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
There are people who live in Alabama and Louisiana who speak English, but you'd need a translator to be able to talk with them.
 

Martin

Lifer
Jan 15, 2000
29,178
1
81
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
There are people who live in Alabama and Louisiana who speak English, but you'd need a translator to be able to talk with them.

I haven't been to those states, but I was in West Virginia and Georgia and although it took a minute to adjust, it was alright after that.

I neglected what Atheus mentioned though, since I've heard that Britain had the same regional dialect thing. If I were to make an analogy to what I was talking about, it wouldn't be a great lakes vs southern type of divide, but imagine a town that speaks Elizabethan English and another town 50 miles a way that speaks Cockney.
 

Amused

Elite Member
Apr 14, 2001
57,444
19,893
146
Originally posted by: Martin
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
There are people who live in Alabama and Louisiana who speak English, but you'd need a translator to be able to talk with them.

I haven't been to those states, but I was in West Virginia and Georgia and although it took a minute to adjust, it was alright after that.

I neglected what Atheus mentioned though, since I've heard that Britain had the same regional dialect thing. If I were to make an analogy to what I was talking about, it wouldn't be a great lakes vs southern type of divide, but imagine a town that speaks Elizabethan English and another town 50 miles a way that speaks Cockney.

Some brits I can understand with no trouble. Others are near impossible to understand. Worse than any deep southern accent from the US to me.
 

Atheus

Diamond Member
Jun 7, 2005
7,313
2
0
LOL

Scroll down to "A traditional Scottish Evening"... :laugh:

Originally posted by: Lonyo
Find a Scot and a Texan or somewhere like that.
Make them talk.
:p

This would definitely result in a fight.
 

RichUK

Lifer
Feb 14, 2005
10,341
678
126
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Martin
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
There are people who live in Alabama and Louisiana who speak English, but you'd need a translator to be able to talk with them.

I haven't been to those states, but I was in West Virginia and Georgia and although it took a minute to adjust, it was alright after that.

I neglected what Atheus mentioned though, since I've heard that Britain had the same regional dialect thing. If I were to make an analogy to what I was talking about, it wouldn't be a great lakes vs southern type of divide, but imagine a town that speaks Elizabethan English and another town 50 miles a way that speaks Cockney.

Some brits I can understand with no trouble. Others are near impossible to understand. Worse than any deep southern accent from the US to me.

Southern England FTW.
 

cw42

Diamond Member
Jan 15, 2004
4,227
0
76
many hispanics and blacks seem to have their own version of the english language as well... esp the ghetto thug types.

fo shizzle my nizzle, ima smoke u wit my piece
 

Kadarin

Lifer
Nov 23, 2001
44,296
16
81
Originally posted by: Amused
Originally posted by: Martin
Originally posted by: Astaroth33
There are people who live in Alabama and Louisiana who speak English, but you'd need a translator to be able to talk with them.

I haven't been to those states, but I was in West Virginia and Georgia and although it took a minute to adjust, it was alright after that.

I neglected what Atheus mentioned though, since I've heard that Britain had the same regional dialect thing. If I were to make an analogy to what I was talking about, it wouldn't be a great lakes vs southern type of divide, but imagine a town that speaks Elizabethan English and another town 50 miles a way that speaks Cockney.

Some brits I can understand with no trouble. Others are near impossible to understand. Worse than any deep southern accent from the US to me.

Ever watch the show King of the Hill? People in some parts of Alabama actually talk exactly like Boomhauer.