the witcher sucks

[Terzo]

I enjoyed the story, but the mechanics weren't that great. I also didn't feel like my character became that much more powerful by the end of the game. I only got two of the advanced swords (the drops, never actually made one) and played through the entire game in the beginner's armor. I didn't realize that once I beat chapter 5 I couldn't finish making the dwarf armor (and at that point, it wouldn't matter that much).

Basically, the combat system and equipment could really use an overhaul.

 

[PowerYoga]

Umm, bullshit. You're never more than a couple of minutes from a campfire in town. You're lying.

If I was then I never found it. Why would I lie about my frustrations about the game? No need to get defensive. You have your preferences and I have mine.

 

[motsm]

Umm, bullshit. You're never more than a couple of minutes from a campfire in town. You're lying.

He's either lying, or just kinda stupid, imperceptive, or ignorant to various game features, (Sorry mate, but that's about the only way it's possible). Not to mention you can also sleep at various NPC's houses throughout town that are all over the place.

 

[Rifter]

The game sucked bad, i agree. Was one of the most boring games i have ever played. Like mentioned above the combat system was lame, the equipment was lame. and there was way to much running around for no reason. played it for a few hours but never got into it. was told it got better so tried to rush to that point but just couldnt do it, too boring.

 

[Dumac]

The game was really good but...

Shouldn't be played by those with short attention spans or those spoiled by FPS

If there aren't testosterone fueled explosions everywhere like a Michael Bay film, some types of people get bored.

 

[Nox51]

I don't get the combat system complaints? Isn't it really the same as your run of the mill hack and slash? Just click to attack with the only difference that you actually have to time your attacks? not much difference to me tbh.

 

[Maleficus]

So...

The lesson of the day is "People Who Love FPS's May Not Like RPGs"??


Stop the presses!

I love both, but still hated the witcher.

 

[KeithTalent]

The game was really good but...

Shouldn't be played by those with short attention spans or those spoiled by FPS

If there aren't testosterone fueled explosions everywhere like a Michael Bay film, some types of people get bored.

There is a difference between slow/boring and slow/measured pacing. Some of my favourite films move at a snail's pace, but are paced appropriately with proper plot development, etc. to accomodate this. The Witcher, unfortunately, fell into the former classification.

KT

 

[Mike Gayner]

There is a difference between slow/boring and slow/measured pacing. Some of my favourite films move at a snail's pace, but are paced appropriately with proper plot development, etc. to accomodate this. The Witcher, unfortunately, fell into the former classification.

KT

Wrong.

 

[zinfamous]

The game was really good but...

Shouldn't be played by those with short attention spans or those spoiled by FPS

If there aren't testosterone fueled explosions everywhere like a Michael Bay film, some types of people get bored.

I despise all of that crud with every fiber of my being, but I didn't enjoy the witcher. I much prefer RPG--especially PC RPG. but the witcher....meh. I really, really wanted to like it. It was fun at first, but like I said, way too cumbersome.

maybe it's an age thing, as I find myself unable to devote more than an hour or so at a time to games these days.

 

[zinfamous]

Wrong.

excellent retort, dingleberry.

you are, in fact, wrong.

:awe:

 

[zinfamous]

I think everyone that really, really likes the witcher only likes it because of fake cartoon boobies. they see this as "mature content" and "adult themes"

It somehow makes them think they are playing an "intelligent game."

that's my 2 cents.

 

[Alienwho]

It took me 3 tries before I actually played the game cause I got bored in the first hour. If you can get past the 2 hour mark it turns into a brilliant game.

 

[Dumac]

There is a difference between slow/boring and slow/measured pacing. Some of my favourite films move at a snail's pace, but are paced appropriately with proper plot development, etc. to accomodate this. The Witcher, unfortunately, fell into the former classification.

KT

Everyone disliked the beginning because it lacks what? Action. Yet they overlook the insight you get into the lives of the people, the state of the world, and the character building that will later become extremely relevant. It is also a chance for the main character to explore who he is, as well as get used to technical things like controls.

 

[Mike Gayner]

I think everyone that really, really likes the witcher only likes it because of fake cartoon boobies. they see this as "mature content" and "adult themes"

It somehow makes them think they are playing an "intelligent game."

that's my 2 cents.

Wrong.

 

[Dumac]

I despise all of that crud with every fiber of my being, but I didn't enjoy the witcher. I much prefer RPG--especially PC RPG. but the witcher....meh. I really, really wanted to like it. It was fun at first, but like I said, way too cumbersome.

maybe it's an age thing, as I find myself unable to devote more than an hour or so at a time to games these days.

Like I said, attention span. You probably just have other, more important stuff to do in your life. It is the same reason a lot of adults stop reading...

 

[Dumac]

I think everyone that really, really likes the witcher only likes it because of fake cartoon boobies. they see this as "mature content" and "adult themes"

It somehow makes them think they are playing an "intelligent game."

that's my 2 cents.

I played it without the boobies the first time and loved it.

EDIT: Though I have to admit for other playthroughs, collecting the cards was fun, kind of like "catch em all" from pokemon.

 

[PUN]

After playing the first 1-2hrs of this game, I almost gave up on it. Gave it another try for another few hours and I was up all night, and it still is one of my favorite game of all time.

 

[Dumac]

I don't get the combat system complaints? Isn't it really the same as your run of the mill hack and slash? Just click to attack with the only difference that you actually have to time your attacks? not much difference to me tbh.

The combat system was the least successful part of the game. They at least tried to make it a BIT more involved that just click-click-click by including timing, but the shallowness of the combat caused it to take a backseat behind the characters and story.

I hope they improve combat for Witcher 2. Even if they don't, I will still get the game, as Witcher 1 was a great game despite its lackluster combat.

 

[KeithTalent]

Everyone disliked the beginning because it lacks what? Action. Yet they overlook the insight you get into the lives of the people, the state of the world, and the character building that will later become extremely relevant. It is also a chance for the main character to explore who he is, as well as get used to technical things like controls.

Yes, but the writing is not strong enough to sustain you through this period. Maybe it gets better, I don't know, but there is nothing compelling, writing, character development, or otherwise, to keep me interested in the game. If you are going to start a game with long periods of inactivity (to be honest, I did not feel that was the case with The Witcher, as I recall being in a relatively large brouhaha pretty early on, but for the sake of argument) then you need something to fall back on and in my opinion The Witcher did not have anything compelling to fall back on.

KT

Edit: Yeah, the combat was rough too. Very clunky.

 

[Dumac]

Yes, but the writing is not strong enough to sustain you through this period. Maybe it gets better, I don't know, but there is nothing compelling, writing, character development, or otherwise, to keep me interested in the game. If you are going to start a game with long periods of inactivity (to be honest, I did not feel that was the case with The Witcher, as I recall being in a relatively large brouhaha pretty early on, but for the sake of argument) then you need something to fall back on and in my opinion The Witcher did not have anything compelling to fall back on.

KT

Edit: Yeah, the combat was rough too. Very clunky.

Act 1 was more about setting. I found it interesting learning about the townsfolk. I liked learning the mechanisms of the city, and my character's place in the world. You learn of the common folk's hate, and that is isn't completely unwarranted. You learn of the contrast between the outside of the city and the inside of the city. You learn of poverty and corruption. All of this gives insight into what kind of world The Witcher is set in.

Character wise, you form a relationship with a witch, someone who, like you, is an outsider and an outcast. You get introduced to Shani (iirc), and learn some of her character, a brief appetizer to get you interested. You begin to form opinions of the Church, which will be a very important player later on.

I found act 1 to be the least interesting, but still interesting. I appreciate it more after having beat the game.

It really is just about tastes. The Witcher isn't a game for everyone, and often receives polar reviews.

 

[Anteaus]

The only part of the game I really didn't like was the interface/controls. Either the mouse was too sensitive or not enough and movement felt clunky. The story and RPG elements were great as far as i'm concerned tho. Graphics were really good too considering the developer it came from.

 

[Nox51]

I can't comment on the characters or the development since this is the second time I am playing and never got further than act 1. I originally stopped because I loaned the game from a friend during a busy period for me and didn't have much time to play anything and had to return it to him.

Again, for the combat, I'm still not with you all. I wouldn't say it's particularly good or bad, just clicking... standard fare for rpg games.

I shall make my opinions of the later game known when I get there.

 

[Modular]

maybe it's an age thing, as I find myself unable to devote more than an hour or so at a time to games these days.

This is probably it. I can't get myself to load up Dragon Age at all anymore because I just don't have the time to devote to it. Doesn't mean it's a bad game, just one that doesn't fit my current lifestyle. I'm going to finish it someday though...I hope.

 

[mooncancook]

I love the Witcher, NWN, NWN2, DA:O, going to play Witcher2, DA2 for sure. Also love KOTOR, ME too. I have great patience for games with a decent story