Argh!
Why does Costner get such a bad rap? I actually like a lot of the guy's movies.
For Love of the Game - Excellent flick, A+. They got the book down, and even added some to it.
The Postman - hey, a little long, sure, and the final fight with Will Patton was somewhat lame, but it was a cool flick. The book was better, but they couldn't have afforded the special effects (cyborgs a la The Terminator, etc.).
Robin Hood - cool flick. A good date movie.
Dances With Wolves - Easily one of the greatest movies of all time.
Waterworld - I actually own it on DVD. I like it, and I'm not ashamed to admit it. It's a hell of a lot better than the piece of shi+ that is Starship Troopers.
Tin Cup - hilarious.
The Bodyguard sucked, but it wasn't because of Costner. And Wyatt Earp isn't that great, but that's only because it's judged against the far superior Tombstone. And who can forget Bull Durham and Field of Dreams?
And as far as The Untouchables, yes, Costner was great in it. And yes, he played Elliott Ness. Sean Connery and "Bobby D" probably did a better acting job, Andy Garcia was solid, and Charles Martin Smith was awesome as the accountant-turned-crimefighter.