Originally posted by: BD2003
Originally posted by: kb3edk
What's the state of PC gaming?
Well, if you're a Linux or Mac user it's pretty sorry right now. But as a Windows gamer I'm pretty happy where the market's at. Samduhman up near the top of the thread mentions Xbox 360, and how it's stealing away a large portion of the Windows gamer user base. Well that's the "glass half empty" take on the situation.
The "glass half full" opposite of it is that for every gamer we lose to 360 due to upgrade/bug fatigue, we are probably gaining another gamer who has "outgrown" his/her console and is moving to Windows for greater performance and flexibility. Rather than ridicule my 360-playing friends I tell them how much I like 360 games like BioShock, Oblivion, and Gears Of War and then point out to them how I think each of these games is better on Windows than 360, and that's why I game on a PC. You can at least HAVE this conversation with a 360 gamer, unlike other consoles out there. Well, unless you're trying to sell a Wii gamer on the merits of Peggle or something
Are those games really *better* though? Theres plenty of ways one could argue just the opposite. I dont disagree that there are certain aspects in which they are superior, but if I'm being perfectly honest, I find the concept of "graduating" from console to PC a bit ridiculous.
Top PC Games of 2007:
1. PC World Of Warcraft: Burning Crusade Expansion Pack*, Vivendi 2.25mm
2. PC World Of Warcraft, Vivendi 914K
3. PC The Sims 2 Seasons Expansion Pack, Electronic Arts 433K
4. PC Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare*, Activision 383K
5. PC Command & Conquer 3: Tiberium Wars*, Electronic Arts 343K
6. PC Sim City 4 Deluxe, Electronic Arts 284K
7. PC The Sims 2, Electronic Arts 281K
8. PC The Sims 2, Bon Voyage Expansion Pack Electronic Arts 271K
9. PC MS Age Of Empires III, Microsoft 259K
10. PC The Sims 2 Pets Expansion Pack, Electronic Arts 236K
The glass isnt half full, its almost empty. The gamers ARE leaving. Whether or not you believe the PC or Console is superior, PC gaming is a niche composed of WoW and Sims players. Both of which are great games for sure, but hardly the kind of hardcore games that going to get console gamers to "move up" to the PC.
There comes a point in every console cycle about 2-3 years in, where the PC graphics have evolved to the point that theyre so superior (at least on the top end), that the consoles begin to look really weak, and all the "PC gaming is dead" talk really goes away. I dont see that happening nearly as much this time around, because it seems like rather than the consoles getting second hand PC ports of games like Doom 3 and HL2, the PCs are the ones getting the second hand ports.
Let me put it this way: I want to believe that the PC is superior...I'd love the option to throw more money at gaming and get a better experience out of it. But its just not the simple anymore IMO.
That's not quite accurate though. Let's take a look at some more sources
http://ve3d.ign.com/articles/n...ling-PC-Game-of-August
PC sales in August-
1) Bioshock - 2K Games
2) World Of Warcraft: Burning Crusade Expansion Pack - Vivendi
3) World Of Warcraft - Vivendi
4) Guild Wars Eye Of The North Expansion Pack - NCsoft
5) Civilization IV: Beyond The Sword Expansion Pack - 2K Games
6) The Sims 2 Deluxe - Electronic Arts
7) Age Of Empires III - Microsoft
8) Madden NFL 2008 - Electronic Arts
9) Warcraft III Battle Chest - Vivendi
10) Microsoft Flight Simulator X Deluxe - Microsoft
Console sales in august -
1) Madden NFL 08 - Xbox 360 - Electronic Arts
2) Madden NFL 08 - Playstation 2 - Electronic Arts
3) BioShock - Xbox 360 - 2K Games
4) Madden NFL 08 - Playstation 3 - Electronic Arts
5) Play With Remote - Wii - Nintendo of America
6) Guitar Hero 2 With Guitar - Playstation 2 - Red Octane
7) Metroid Prime 3: Corruption - Wii - Nintendo of America
8) Guitar Hero 2 With Guitar - Xbox 360 - Red Octane
9) Mario Strikers: Charged - Wii - Nintendo of America
10) Mario Party 8 - Wii - Nintendo of America
Let's take a look at your argument again. Hmm, it appears to me that Wow and The Sims only take up 2 slots on the PC side. In fact, The PC list has a pretty wide range of different games - we have Bioshock beating the WoW players (imagine that), Age of Empires, some NFL, WC3 (RTS), a flight sim, the Civ 4 expansion, etc.
Looking at the console sales, it appears that console gaming is a niche made of sports and party games. For console gaming, the glass isn't half full, it's nearly empty!
You see, it's easy to take a set of data and manipulate it to say whatever you want.
Let's take a look at January
http://ve3d.ign.com/articles/n...S-PC-Games-Sales-Chart
1) Call Of Duty 4: Modern Warfare - Activision
2) World Of Warcraft: Battle Chest - Vivendi
3) World Of Warcraft: Burning Crusade Expansion Pack - Vivendi
4) World Of Warcraft - Vivendi
5) Crysis - Electronic Arts
6) The Orange Box - Electronic Arts
7) The Sims 2 Deluxe - Electronic Arts
8) Pirates Of The Burning Sea - Sony Online Entertainment
9) Warcraft III Battle Chest - Vivendi
10) Unreal Tournament 3 - Midway
11) SimCity Societies - Electronic Arts
12) The Witcher - Atari
13) Hellgate: London - Electronic Arts
14) The Sims 2 Bon Voyage Expansion Pack - Electronic Arts
15) Microsoft Flight Simulator X Deluxe - Microsoft
16) SimCity 4 Deluxe - Electronic Arts
17) World In Conflict - Vivendi
18) The Sims Complete Collection - Electronic Arts
19) Guitar Hero III: Legends Of Rock with Guitar - Aspyr Media
20) Civilization IV: Gold Edition - 2K Games
Once again, it looks like your "niche" comment doesn't have any bearing in reality. I see a pretty wide variety of games on there. Only a few spots are taken by WoW or the Sims; the majority of the spots are taken by various other games.