Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: SSSnail
Originally posted by: JS80
Originally posted by: SSSnail
Heh, just a touch on the high interest savings, WAMU is actually offering 5% on their no minimum deposits account.
my friend who's a quant analyst for a hedge fund that does ABS/MBS predicts wamu will go bankrupt (he predicted last month
TMA's portfolio is worthless and I laughed at him).
Mortgage at this point in time is completely predictable. What indications do your friend have on making that assertion?
He says most of wamu's loan portfolios are alt-a and estimates they are "worthless" (i.e. 20 cents on the dollar). He's probably exaggerating but I agree with him wamu is a shvtty bank. Their target demographic is young people and minorities so would make sense if they go broke (however unlikely).
That's practically impossible.
1. You'd have to have 100% of all mortgages default today, so no interest is received.
2. You'd have to have 20% recoveries on those mortgages, meaning that every house would have to be only worth 20% of what the mortgage was.
3. There'd have to be no PMI and no other assets that could be seized.
Realistically, there'll be ~20% losses to Subprime and lower-tier Alt-A mortgages. Of that you're probably going to recover ~50% after costs. If you figure that 10% of the rest of the portfolio will default, with a 60% recovery.
For speculative purposes lets say that their portfolio is composed of 40% of the former and 60% of the latter. That means that WAMU will suffer 8.4% net losses. Lets say they hold a portfolio of $40bn, which is pretty high, that means they will suffer a 3.36bn loss.
Yeah, that'll put a diversified bank right under water.
I think your friend was...umm...talking out of his ass. Not sure what quant models he was running for his ABS/MBS portfolios, nor the assumptions used, but I think that he's over-reacting. I'm not a "quant" but I know my way around cashflows models, CPR/CDR/PSA, interest rate changes upon prepayment curves, amortization of mortgages, recovery models based upon MSA codes and legal jurisdictions, stress mutliples for rating agency criteria...etc.
Even if you double or triple the losses that's only 10bn, which is nothing to sneeze at, but isn't a company destroying loss
Now, to an undiversified bank, that's a hell of a lot of money, especially since other banks will shut down their credit lines, your CP conduits will sustain losses, and you'll have to rely on your deposits for funding, but it isn't unsurmountable to a bank like WAMU.
It's not going to be a great time for those banks, but not Armageddon.