The debate over these cartoons of Muhammad is ridiculous.

Page 15 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Vic

Elite Member
Jun 12, 2001
50,422
14,337
136
Originally posted by: LumbergTech
Originally posted by: Vic
Anti-culturism is the new racism, that's all. It's simple enough to see because racism was always based on cultural prejudices anyway. Skin color was just the excuse. Now that people aren't supposed to hate the skin color, they're attacking the cultures directly. And conveniently, religious hate has become fashionable again, and what is culture (historically) but religion? Bigotry dies hard.
I just dont feel its my obligation to limit what cartoons i draw because of their arbitrary designation of the divine, that doesnt mean that i think that people should create these type of things with the sole purpose of harassing a group who shares a belief
I'm not saying that anyone needs to be limited. Just that if you go around talking sh!t about other peoples' mothers you shouldn't be surprised when someone gets pissed off by it.
 

Sunner

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
11,641
0
76
Let's see.
I'm an atheist.
I honestly don't give a crap about religious laws, Christian, Muslim, Hindu, or otherwise.
If I feel like burning a cross in my backyard, I will, if I feel like drawing a of Muhammad fornicating with the pope, I will, etc.
Actually I probably wouldn't just cause there would be no big point in doing that, but I do reserve my right to do so, and if someone else doesn't like that, too bad.

To me, many of the things that go on in Muslim countries is weird, barbaric, or both.
Women forced to wearing burqa's(sp?)? Screwed up to me, but hey, it's their country, just don't involve me in it.
Someone in Iran saying Sweden is a hellhole full of infidels? I'll think he's a moron and quite possibly a psychopath, but still, he has the right to say what he wants.
Think most if not all of the chicks I know are whores and sluts for dressing the way they do and actually having pre-marital sex? Fine, I think you're a fvcking moron, but still, as long as you don't come here and yell it to their face it's your right to think so.
Etc, live and let live.

They don't need to live by my standards, and I sure won't live by theirs, and if some Muslim living in my country doesn't like that he can move, that's his right.
I live by the Swedish laws, because I live in Sweden, if I moved to Iran I would respect their laws and traditions, but as long as I live here, I just don't give a crap about their laws and traditions.
Think that makes me an ignorant asshole? That's fine with me too, it's certainly your right to think I'm an ignorant asshole, I won't threaten to behead you or anything for thinking so.
 

marvdmartian

Diamond Member
Apr 12, 2002
5,443
27
91
Originally posted by: slash196
I seem to be the only one who knows this, so it's time for a little lesson in Islam. It is ABSOLUTELY FORBIDDEN to depict the Prophet in ANY WAY, be it cartoon, painting, what have you. To do so is an insult to all of Islam, and has been interpreted as such. I thought this was fairly common knowledge but apperantly it isn't.

To make an analogy, it would be like me pooping on a picture of Jesus on national television. This whole country would go (somewhat justifiably) completely insane. People would be calling for my blood. Exact same thing. The newspaper should have known this and should issue an apology for insulting, deliberately, more than a billion people. End of freaking story.

Okay, first problem. That is Islamic law. Not the entire world follows Islamic law. US law says it's illegal to hijack an airliner, yet it happened on 9/11, didn't it? Should the US have then killed every member of the Islamic faith in retaliation? To tell the truth, very few people outside the Islamic faith were probably aware of that "law", AND an apology has already been issued, numerous times. So now where is your basis of protest??

Second, my faith says, "Thou shall not kill". Yet your Islamic bretheren in Iraq, and other places, has no problem in killing dozens of people (Islamics AND non-Islamics) with a car bomb. How can you expect the world to respect your religion if you're not willing to extend the same courtesy??

Bottom line (at least in my eyes)?? The least tolerant religion in the world demands tolerance from everyone else, and is more than willing to show their intolerance in ways that are unacceptable to the remainder of the world. If Islam wants to be respected in this world, they'd better first learn respect for everyone else. :roll:

And finally, a billion people? Big deal. China has that many in one country, and if I remember right, India's not far behind. You need us far more than we need you, and since we have the biggest guns and most of the money, you'd do well to remember that fact. The rest of the world is pretty much comprised of peace loving people, but remember that just about anyone will strike back, eventually, when pushed far enough.
 

cirrrocco

Golden Member
Sep 7, 2004
1,952
78
91
I just have to say there's a lot of ignorance on both sides.

For those who think that matter of the cartoon should just be shrugged off, where's the decency to show some empathy for those who were insulted.

And for those out on those streets, it's fine you want to demonstrate, but do it peacefully. You will still be heard.

 

DidlySquat

Banned
Jun 30, 2005
903
0
0
Originally posted by: cirrrocco
I just have to say there's a lot of ignorance on both sides.

For those who think that matter of the cartoon should just be shrugged off, where's the decency to show some empathy for those who were insulted.

And for those out on those streets, it's fine you want to demonstrate, but do it peacefully. You will still be heard.


idiot read the thread, muslim and arab media insult judaism and christianity in far worse ways every day. Fact is different people have view which are insulting to other people. So what ?
 

Sunner

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
11,641
0
76
Originally posted by: cirrrocco
I just have to say there's a lot of ignorance on both sides.

For those who think that matter of the cartoon should just be shrugged off, where's the decency to show some empathy for those who were insulted.

And for those out on those streets, it's fine you want to demonstrate, but do it peacefully. You will still be heard.

I'm sorry they feel insulted. <--- There's my empathy.
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
Originally posted by: Vic
Anti-culturism is the new racism, that's all. It's simple enough to see because racism was always based on cultural prejudices anyway. Skin color was just the excuse. Now that people aren't supposed to hate the skin color, they're attacking the cultures directly. And conveniently, religious hate has become fashionable again, and what is culture (historically) but religion? Bigotry dies hard.
...like a Phoenix.
 

OutHouse

Lifer
Jun 5, 2000
36,410
616
126
say this to a muslim mad about the stupid cartoon.

"its Gods will that he allowed that cartoon to be published."
 

dahunan

Lifer
Jan 10, 2002
18,191
3
0
Originally posted by: cirrrocco
I just have to say there's a lot of ignorance on both sides.

For those who think that matter of the cartoon should just be shrugged off, where's the decency to show some empathy for those who were insulted.

And for those out on those streets, it's fine you want to demonstrate, but do it peacefully. You will still be heard.

Their extremist actions leave no room for empathy. They look like dangerous and scary brainwashed slaves whose minds are in bondage to their religious law.

 

Jmman

Diamond Member
Dec 17, 1999
5,302
0
76
But, but, but, this is the PROPHET we are talking about........






\sarcasm
 

Cerb

Elite Member
Aug 26, 2000
17,484
33
86
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: Taejin
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: Taejin
We don't believe in your prophet. I couldnt care less if your prophet was a divine being or a dirty leper.
we dont want you to believe just repect!-- i cudnt care less if u have ears or not, i want to listen to music! (cont. from last post)
Well guess what - no one has to give you that respect. Free speech demands tolerance, not respect. And if some Muslims want to demand respect with fear and bombs - they aren't gonna get any.

You morons don't fvckin get it. People have a right to publish what they want. It's free speech. Your religion or any other religion, ideal or whatever DOES NOT MATTER. Does that make any sense? For crying out loud, no wonder your religion has problems with violent members.
u r just one of those ppl who just believe the news and the muslims are bad so they dont deserve respect, i wonder how cud they program u!? did they put a chip in ur head or wut? is it free to attack israel in ur country? do they let anyone even talk about their religion? they will just send them msgs and warnings..other ppl deserve the same..muslims deserve respect, we love our prophet more than our selves and we will defend against any one attacks him even if a robot like u comes and says its freedom, NO ITS NOT...
So, one kind of speech is OK, but not a kind that you disagree with?
 

mordantmonkey

Diamond Member
Dec 23, 2004
3,075
5
0
Um, regarding the OP. Depictions and portraits of muhammad are widely available, even is muslim countries. Whether or not it is sacreligious depends on to what sect of islam you adhere.
 

DidlySquat

Banned
Jun 30, 2005
903
0
0
Originally posted by: Jmman
But, but, but, this is the PROPHET we are talking about........






\sarcasm

Their prophet is a terrorist - hey why don't they protest worldwide about what I just said ? how is what I just said different than the opinion of the guy who drew up mohammad with a bomb in his turban ? is it only because that was a drawing that their illeterate people can understand, as opposed to verbally written article which expresses much more disrespect ? If so I can point you to plenty of those (e.g. disrespectful drawings about islam and mohammad) as well - depicting him like an animal etc. Why only protest this one cartoon ? there are many others which are worse
 

1EZduzit

Lifer
Feb 4, 2002
11,833
1
0
Originally posted by: dahunan
Originally posted by: cirrrocco
I just have to say there's a lot of ignorance on both sides.

For those who think that matter of the cartoon should just be shrugged off, where's the decency to show some empathy for those who were insulted.

And for those out on those streets, it's fine you want to demonstrate, but do it peacefully. You will still be heard.

Their extremist actions leave no room for empathy. They look like dangerous and scary brainwashed slaves whose minds are in bondage to their religious law.

I have empathy for the Muslims, but not the ones calling for violence and my empathy is wearing thin when I hear so few Muslims willing to defend free speech. Some of those cartoons are funny and some are objectionable, but not objectionable enough to justify the violence they are calling for.

Just as we people raised in the western culture do not fully understand the depth of the insult to Islam believers, they do not understand our total believe in free speech. It is a true cultural clash.

It's hard (if not impossible) for us to relate that they would feel as strongly about a cartoon as we do about our right to free speech and vice versa. Since they are trying to control OUR press in OUR land then it seems to me that they are just trying to control us. They need to realize that it's not like we moved to their country and started a newspaper just to insult them.

We have our right to have our beliefs also. If those beliefs conflict with theirs then I would suggest they remove themselves from the host country instead of trying to change it to suit them. Only 4% of Denmark is Muslim, now whose law should take precedent?

 

Alaa

Senior member
Apr 26, 2005
839
8
81
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
idiot read the thread, muslim and arab media insult judaism and christianity in far worse ways every day. Fact is different people have view which are insulting to other people. So what ?
such a big lie stop sayin these stupid things
Originally posted by: Cerb
So, one kind of speech is OK, but not a kind that you disagree with?
where is respect when everybody say wut he wants to? its like hitting us and asking not to talk cuz its freedom!
 

erwos

Diamond Member
Apr 7, 2005
4,778
0
76
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
idiot read the thread, muslim and arab media insult judaism and christianity in far worse ways every day. Fact is different people have view which are insulting to other people. So what ?
such a big lie stop sayin these stupid things
Where the hell have you been? Islamic press routinely pulls up blood libel connotations against Jews (as represented by that hook-nosed fellow!). Go ANYWHERE - MEMRI, HonestReporting, etc., and you'll find those pictures.

-Erwos
 

CanOWorms

Lifer
Jul 3, 2001
12,404
2
0
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
Aisengard, I think linuxator is also talking about arab muslims and trying to say that even they are not all bad. While I agree with him on that point, the real point here why so many of the arab muslims (not the majority, but relatively a lot nonetheless - e.g. hundreds of thousands) go and protest about a cartoon, and also engage in violence and threats ? Again, I'm not saying its the majority, just a lot of people, and I understand they are probably being led by a few (I believe most of them have not even seen the cartoons). Sure, they are in a "different political situation" which I guess means they live under dictators which many times have an interest in inciting these protests to divert public anger at the regime itself.

So you think the west should understand that they are doing it because of their "different political situation" and accept it ?
am living in egypt and i didnt even hear that anyone made any violence, we jst want an apology cuz wut they did is to mess with our religion while we respect urs, we have christians here and others, we all live in peace..only u ppl think that there is so much violence in the mid east which is not true..u can attack with a cartoon including any luk of arabs but not the prophet!

Sorry, but people have different beliefs. You believe that the prophet should not be drawn. Some people believe that flags should not be burned. Some people don't believe in eating meat. A non-homogenous society cannot exist with everyone following everybody else's religious or sacred rules.

A religions is nothing but a set of personal beliefs. The belief not to draw Mohammed can be just as sacred as the belief not to burn a country's flag.
 

Alaa

Senior member
Apr 26, 2005
839
8
81
Originally posted by: erwos
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
idiot read the thread, muslim and arab media insult judaism and christianity in far worse ways every day. Fact is different people have view which are insulting to other people. So what ?
such a big lie stop sayin these stupid things
Where the hell have you been? Islamic press routinely pulls up blood libel connotations against Jews (as represented by that hook-nosed fellow!). Go ANYWHERE - MEMRI, HonestReporting, etc., and you'll find those pictures.

-Erwos
i dont have to see pics am living in the mid of the arab world in egypt and all they do is to show jewish killing arabs which is something normal nowadays so everybody hates jewish, only cartoons about their president or ppl in charge which is so far not an insult for the religion itself! no insult against chrisrianity nobody here in talks about it!!
 

Alaa

Senior member
Apr 26, 2005
839
8
81
Originally posted by: CanOWorms
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
Aisengard, I think linuxator is also talking about arab muslims and trying to say that even they are not all bad. While I agree with him on that point, the real point here why so many of the arab muslims (not the majority, but relatively a lot nonetheless - e.g. hundreds of thousands) go and protest about a cartoon, and also engage in violence and threats ? Again, I'm not saying its the majority, just a lot of people, and I understand they are probably being led by a few (I believe most of them have not even seen the cartoons). Sure, they are in a "different political situation" which I guess means they live under dictators which many times have an interest in inciting these protests to divert public anger at the regime itself.

So you think the west should understand that they are doing it because of their "different political situation" and accept it ?
am living in egypt and i didnt even hear that anyone made any violence, we jst want an apology cuz wut they did is to mess with our religion while we respect urs, we have christians here and others, we all live in peace..only u ppl think that there is so much violence in the mid east which is not true..u can attack with a cartoon including any luk of arabs but not the prophet!

Sorry, but people have different beliefs. You believe that the prophet should not be drawn. Some people believe that flags should not be burned. Some people don't believe in eating meat. A non-homogenous society cannot exist with everyone following everybody else's religious or sacred rules.

A religions is nothing but a set of personal beliefs. The belief not to draw Mohammed can be just as sacred as the belief not to burn a country's flag.
they r just burning flags to protest against wut they did.. so this is just a reply they didnt start!
 

CanOWorms

Lifer
Jul 3, 2001
12,404
2
0
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: CanOWorms
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
Aisengard, I think linuxator is also talking about arab muslims and trying to say that even they are not all bad. While I agree with him on that point, the real point here why so many of the arab muslims (not the majority, but relatively a lot nonetheless - e.g. hundreds of thousands) go and protest about a cartoon, and also engage in violence and threats ? Again, I'm not saying its the majority, just a lot of people, and I understand they are probably being led by a few (I believe most of them have not even seen the cartoons). Sure, they are in a "different political situation" which I guess means they live under dictators which many times have an interest in inciting these protests to divert public anger at the regime itself.

So you think the west should understand that they are doing it because of their "different political situation" and accept it ?
am living in egypt and i didnt even hear that anyone made any violence, we jst want an apology cuz wut they did is to mess with our religion while we respect urs, we have christians here and others, we all live in peace..only u ppl think that there is so much violence in the mid east which is not true..u can attack with a cartoon including any luk of arabs but not the prophet!

Sorry, but people have different beliefs. You believe that the prophet should not be drawn. Some people believe that flags should not be burned. Some people don't believe in eating meat. A non-homogenous society cannot exist with everyone following everybody else's religious or sacred rules.

A religions is nothing but a set of personal beliefs. The belief not to draw Mohammed can be just as sacred as the belief not to burn a country's flag.
they r just burning flags to protest against wut they did.. so this is just a reply they didnt start!

So that makes it ok?

The newspaper that published the cartoons because of self-censorship among the community after the murder of Theo Van Gogh by a Muslim extremist. So this is just a reply that they didn't start as well.
 

DidlySquat

Banned
Jun 30, 2005
903
0
0
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: erwos
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
idiot read the thread, muslim and arab media insult judaism and christianity in far worse ways every day. Fact is different people have view which are insulting to other people. So what ?
such a big lie stop sayin these stupid things
Where the hell have you been? Islamic press routinely pulls up blood libel connotations against Jews (as represented by that hook-nosed fellow!). Go ANYWHERE - MEMRI, HonestReporting, etc., and you'll find those pictures.

-Erwos
i dont have to see pics am living in the mid of the arab world in egypt and all they do is to show jewish killing arabs which is something normal nowadays so everybody hates jewish, only cartoons about their president or ppl in charge which is so far not an insult for the religion itself! no insult against chrisrianity nobody here in talks about it!!


An insult is an insult even it's about a person's character, family or religion. What is the difference ? in fact for many people insulting their family is worse than insulting their religion. And denying the holocaust is also offensive to many jews, not to mention declaring intent to destroy a person's country is highly offensive.

 

erwos

Diamond Member
Apr 7, 2005
4,778
0
76
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: erwos
Originally posted by: Alaa
Originally posted by: DidlySquat
idiot read the thread, muslim and arab media insult judaism and christianity in far worse ways every day. Fact is different people have view which are insulting to other people. So what ?
such a big lie stop sayin these stupid things
Where the hell have you been? Islamic press routinely pulls up blood libel connotations against Jews (as represented by that hook-nosed fellow!). Go ANYWHERE - MEMRI, HonestReporting, etc., and you'll find those pictures.

-Erwos
i dont have to see pics am living in the mid of the arab world in egypt and all they do is to show jewish killing arabs which is something normal nowadays so everybody hates jewish, only cartoons about their president or ppl in charge which is so far not an insult for the religion itself! no insult against chrisrianity nobody here in talks about it!!
So you really don't think that portraying all Jews in a blood libel cartoon isn't disrespectful to Judaism and all Jews? Because, really, I think most all Jews would consider it disrespectful as hell. Blood libels were used as excuses for deadly pogroms throughout the Middle Ages - heck, they're still dredged up from time to time in Middle Eastern papers. The only reason you don't know about this is that Jews don't go around rioting and burning down embassies every time it happens.

You need to educate yourself, and eradicate your ignorance. A good bit of the Arab (and to a lesser extent, Muslim) press is virulently anti-Semetic, not just anti-Israeli. The fact that you can't see that is disturbing, to say the least, and really should give readers of the forum an example of the cultural issues in play.

-Erwos
 

Alaa

Senior member
Apr 26, 2005
839
8
81
Originally posted by: CanOWorms
So that makes it ok?

The newspaper that published the cartoons because of self-censorship among the community after the murder of Theo Van Gogh by a Muslim extremist. So this is just a reply that they didn't start as well.
we r not extremist, why do u give me ur reply while am not the one u want? those are just ppl who are said to be muslims but they do other things than the religion says so y do u punish real muslims for someone who is only CALLED muslim?!?
 

CanOWorms

Lifer
Jul 3, 2001
12,404
2
0
Originally posted by: Alaa

we r not extremist, why do u give me ur reply while am not the one u want? those are just ppl who are said to be muslims but they do other things than the religion says so y do u punish real muslims for someone who is only CALLED muslim?!?

Those are not real Danes, why do you punish real Danes for someone who is only called a Dane?

People aren't being punished by drawing Mohammed.