The big decision: HELP ME DECIDE!!

DesignDawg

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,919
0
0
Hey all,

My wife is getting a new car tomorrow, most likely. We have 2 cars and a motorcycle right now, and when she gets this car, we will have 4 vehicles total. --Not a good idea. I'm now stuck with the BIG DECISION: WHICH CAR DO I KEEP? Here are the options:

My car: I have a 1987 Toyota Camry LE. LE is the top model, and if you've been in an 87 Camry LE, you know that they are STILL DAMN NICE cars, even by brand new car standards. However, there are some downsides. First, the car has about 185,000 miles on it. Not surprising, since it's a toyota, that it's still running, right? Well, also, it has a fairly new engine I put in a couple years ago. --has about 60-65,000 miles on it. So, the CAR has a lot of miles, but the engine is fairly new. BAD THINGS about the car: Front end damage. Quite a bit. I ran it into a ditch and banged it up really bad. Didn't have enough insurance to get it fixed. Also, the paint on the hood is almost GONE. The damage includes the grille, the bumper, the hood, and the left front quarterpanel. --And the whole car could use a paint job. Inside, the car is immaculate. --But no A/C. The physical AC system works, but the "brain" of the AC, a little circuit board under the dash, needs to be replaced for the air to work. Also, the car needs new tires and an alignment within the next 5,000 miles.
So, basically, the car RUNS good, and is very dependable, but it's a visual wreck, and could stand some significant body work and a new paint job.

My other choice: Heather and I share a 1989 Firebird Formula. The car has 111,000 miles, but has been METICULOUSLY maintained with records from mile one. NEVER missed an oil-change, tune-up, NONE of it. Heather's dad bought it new OFF THE TRUCK, and took good care of it. It's a forumla with a 5.0 litre V8, the interior is immaculate, the engine is perfect, the A/C works, and there is NO body damage.
Bad things abour it are, the hood needs painted. The clear coat peeled completely off a year ago, and this BADLY detracts from the vehicle's otherwise near-flawless exterior. Also, one of the headlight motors (flip-up) is dead, so the lights stay propped up. I could easily get a used part for pretty cheap to fix that, though.
Also, OF COURSE, the Firebird gets about 1/3 the gas mileage as the camry.

So which to choose? Keep in mind, whichever one I choose can be fixed up with the money from SELLING THE OTHER. The firebird's blue book value is a bit higher than the camry's right now, but that really doesn't help. That just tells me that I could sell the bird for enough to fix up the camry back to good condition. --And I certainly could get enough for my camry (even at wholesale) to paint the hood on the Firebird and fix the lights (and power antenna, which I forgot to mention). Whichever car I choose to go with, it will have a Premier deck with a pioneer 6-disc changer, so the factory stereo isn't a factor in this decision. The only other option I can think of is to sell BOTH cars and hope to have enough to buy a decent used car with a little better balance of remaining life, gas mileage, and dependability. Maybe a used low-miles accord, or a slightly newer, better camry or something? :( I HATE having to deal with this crap.

Ricky
DesignDawg
 
Oct 9, 1999
15,216
3
81
well DD

Sell the camry, for one you dont seem to like to deal with teh front end damage. Plus it might cost more to fix it than what you will get from the firebird.
So. What I can suggest get rid of the camry, you can fix the motor of the firebird relatively easy. The book (hayes manual = $50) and then the motor (new could run you upto $100. A paint job at a local Maaco will run you about 300$.

As for the antenne, you can get it fixed by yourself for a few bucks or give it to a audio store can get it done for under 100$ (including the antenne).

or as you suggested ride the mobike for a few days and sell both cars.. and get a nice 1997 / 1998 /1999 American Car (Buick?)
 

DesignDawg

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,919
0
0
True on a lot of those points... But working on the camry is very easy. I put the engine in myseif, and rebuilt it from the block up, so I know my way around it really well. Also, something else I thought of is, it may be hard to sell the camry. May be VERY hard. The body damage is pretty large, and the car can NOT be inspected (thus, can't be legally driven) without the front left blinker, which was ripped off. A new bumper would have to be bought. My only chance may be to sell it to a junkyard, but I know I would get royally ripped doing that. This is really tough. :(

Ricky
DesignDawg
 

Yo Ma Ma

Lifer
Jan 21, 2000
11,635
2
0
Well, since you're buying a new car, I guess I'd boot the car that didn't look good. If it's a really hard decision, then maybe you don't need the 3rd car yet?
 

DesignDawg

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,919
0
0
Well, it's not a matter of us not needing the 3rd car. My wife DOES need the 3rd car. She needs safety, reliability, and saving on gas wouldn't hurt things much. She commutes to work, and she is terrified of driving the firebird. Not that there's anything wrong with it, she just doesn't like the size, the power, the RWD, the lack of airbags, etc... I think, since I do little driving anyway, and I ride my motorcycle whenever it's warm enough, the best car to keep would be the one that's in the best shape, and with the lowest miles. That's the firebird. It's been kept up so well, I think it has plenty of life left in it. Putting a little into it will restore it back to practically-showroom-quality. Gas won't be as big a factor, because I work 2.5 miles from my home, and we would drive my wife's car mostly when we are out together.
I'm just really concerned with being able to sell the camry. It's worth more than I think I can get for it, so it bothers me that I would be getting a bad deal out of it. Plus, having to wait for it to be sold would suck. That's what made the decision hard int he first place. All along, we have planned for me to just take over the firebird. --But faced with the reality of having to sell the camry, I thought, if I can sell the firebird for a pretty decent price, I can put that money into the camry and keep driving it. :Q I wish it wasn't so tough. I'm leeeeeeeaaaning toward keeping the firebird, and that seems to be the general concensus in this thread as well....

Ricky
DesignDawg
 

Yo Ma Ma

Lifer
Jan 21, 2000
11,635
2
0
I see now, that does make the decision more difficult, especially expecting to not get the price you want on the Camry.
 

Dameon

Banned
Oct 11, 1999
2,117
1
0
Maaco is for cars you plan on selling so they will get out the door, not for cars you keep.
 

DesignDawg

Diamond Member
Oct 9, 1999
3,919
0
0
Well, we don't have a maaco here anyway. Why is it for cars you plan on selling? Is it just some sh!tty paint job that looks OK, but only lasts a few weeks, so you save money by not having to get a good paint job, and then you screw the customer because they get it and the paint peels off a month later? That sucks. I pray that I am never the victim of any of these practices.

Ricky
DesignDawg
 

Czar

Lifer
Oct 9, 1999
28,510
0
0
Keep the camry.

What I would do is spend some money repearing both cars and sell them both, then buy a new one with that money.