• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Temple of Elemental Evil... good?

Maetryx

Diamond Member
Maetryx here, 😎

Has anyone here played the Temple of Elemental Evil on PC? I play tabletop D&D 3.5 edition and I'm wondering how the game plays from that perspective. My local Sams Club has it on the shelf for $16.88. If anyone has some comment about the playability, graphics, comparision to tabletop D&D, and just overall "funness", I would appreciate them.
 
Search archived threads here for an old thread on it. From that and reviews it looks only fair, no where near the quality of classics like Fallout 1-2, Planescape: Torment and Baldur's Gate 1-2, it's more like a buggy version of a hack-n-slash like Icewind Dale.
 
I loved it and finished it twice before the patch was released. It was buggy but I loved the combat and overall feel of the game.Now with thepatch I guess alot of the bugs are gone. It is a little lighter on story than games like Balders Gate (wich I didnt really like much)...but, its supposed to be. Its TToEE on the comp and that was originally a hack and slash....whoever followed the game before release knew this already.

I would say get it for that price.....if you are a D&D fan I really dont see anyway you will go wrong.
 
Grab it quick at that price. I paid $40 and felt it was worth it, even with the bugs. You will pull your hair out over seeing the unpolished gem that Atari tossed out. I give Troika props for an EXCELLENT engine. I hope more games are released using it.

I never played the PnP module, but everyone says it's fairly faithful. If you are a D&D fan like me, it's a GREAT game. I never played a Bard, Barbarian, or Monk before, but ToEE inspired me to create all kinds of crazy party configs to see what synergies I could create.

Make sure you grab the official patch and check out the Circle of Eight (www.co8.org) fan patches. Atari should be shot for rushing this game. It's truely a buggy classic.
 
wow... that price is a steal. i've been looking at the game for awhile, since troika's a pretty good team (and yes, atari should be shot for rushing the game). i must admire the original developers of fallout 1 & 2. 🙂
 
Originally posted by: CubicZirconia
This is a turn-based game right? Not like Baldur's Gate or Icewind Dale or Planescape and so on?


Correct. When combat starts each participant is lined up in order of their initative & modifiers and take their turns accordingly. Everyone has an "hourglass" which will drain according to how far they move and what actions they perform in their turn.

TOEE's most serious gameplay flaw it is the fact that it followed the original D&D module too closely. The game gives you an opening quest based on your alignment which is just a basic reason to eventually find your way to the temple. It doesn't really give you much of a sense of accomplishment because the storyline isn't really there. In the sense of a computer RPG this is probably bad, but if you have a background in D&D it isn't too horrible. Also some of it's interpretations of the D&D rules are a little annoying. A wizard must pay component costs each time he casts identify, which is the same cost as paying a merchant to do it. There isn't a deep description of many magic items & weapons(even after being identified) which basicly leaves you to look it up on the net if you aren't sure what effects SO-N-SO's blessed hammer has.

Some of the strengths are excellent graphics, the combat engine, and replayability. The graphics are killer, the spells look sooo good and all of the characters and monsters are animated with a very high attention to detail. One of the characters in my party was the town drunk, every time he would stand idle he would sway back and forth like he was about to pass out:beer:. As far as replay value there are tons of things affected by you alignment, and many different quest options are opened by your secondary skill choices and levels. I didn't even begin to dabble in magic weapon or wand crafting, but I understand you can create some pretty potent equipment.

If you are already familiar with the 3.5 rules you should have a good idea as to how to swing combat in your favor in most instances. I would tell you to get it, it is well worth the $18 you would pay. Make sure you apply the patch, and check out the Circle of Eight patch that DefDC mentioned to see if it addresses anything you might be bothered by(I used it myself to help curb the "greed" of some NPC's).
 
I also enjoyed it a great deal.....though I haven't yet finished the game. Certainly at $17, it's a great deal.
 
Worth buying at that price,I played most of it with the official patch and it was very stable for me,I finally got to finish it in the end 🙂,it`s not a bad game IMHO,combat is turn based but a lot of gamers prefer that,I found the hardest thing was at the beginning when all my characters were real wimps,but once you start going up a few levels you start to really enjoy the game.



 
Back
Top