I forgot this was my thread.
I ended up with a Honda NHX110 which worked for my purposes. I want to sell that and get a Vespa GTS250 or some type of Aprilia. I just can't be bothered to figure out a clutch on a bike, even though I drive a manual car.
I noticed it now and while way to late, can say you did good. I own several motorcycles, to many. I have my H-D, had 2 Sportsters (883 and 1200 both where sold), and a Vulcan 800 (and 750), had a Shadow 750, Boulevard C50 and V-Star 650. I started out years ago on dirt bikes, YZ, Esinors, etc.. My first street bike was Kaw 750LTD-TWIN, bought Brand new, loved it, was my only transport for 4 months in the summer (ND sorta excludes full time riding but i know a couple hardcore who do). I then had a Honda 750.. Time and bikes came and went. As i aged I didnt drive for almost 10 years (Bikes) and in the last 10 have bought almost all the ones i listed above. I wanted a Crusier, but stayed away from the HD's and went Metric, Of all the Metrics I liked my Vulcan the best (keep in mind it needed one mod, sprocket change to make Highway driving better). The V-Star was nimble and best hop on and ride in town bike. I hate to say the Shadow was my least favorite of the 4 metrics, and I cant put any finger on why, all had there good and bad points but the Shadow just seemed to be the wallflower, nothing stood out either way. The Boulevard was close to the Vulcan but in the end, I kept it.. Yes I bought them all used for $3-4 grand and tried them all to decide and pretty much broke even and kept the one i liked the most. You cant judge a bike by a 15 minute ride.
But you chose wisely my son! I have a Honda ELITE 125 scooter that in town i ride way more than any of the bikes, its quick enough for town traffic no work no chokes, no nothing, start and instantly go, lots of storage and 80-90 MPG is nice too.. its just sit and go..
I wouldn't recommend the HD's for anybody starting, even the 883 sporty, the 1200 is to much to start for sure. I know the love/hate between metics and HD.. dont listen to either side, test and ride.. after you ride the scooter a bit a bigger bike might be in order (me, i wont ever be without a scooter, but they are not for the road ) I loved my metrics and the 800-900 CC bikes are pretty easy to handle, stepping up to HD 1200 sporty or bigger is something i wouldn't do unless you know its what you want, I love my SuperGlide, and my next bike will most likely be a newer copy of it but there are times I wish it weighed what my vulcan did.
Scooters are fun! am really waiting on the nice weather to get all my bikes out.