• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Teacher Washes Child?s Mouth With Soap; Suspended

Riprorin

Banned
Teacher Washes Child?s Mouth With Soap; Suspended

Chalonda Roberts (Rochester, NY) 06/09/04 - A Rochester school teacher was suspended with pay after she allegedly washed out a third grade student's mouth with soap.

The student's guardian wants the teacher fired.

A school nurse reported teacher Lori Thomas for violating district policy. Thomas said the district's reaction to her disciplinary action is unfair.

She said that when a student used vulgar language with a classmate, she took him to the nurse's office to discipline him--so he would not be embarrassed in front of the whole class.

Thomas said, "I put a drop of soap on his lip and washed it away immediately. I know he didn't even taste the soap, and I told him I did not want to hear filth coming out of his mouth again."

Thomas has been picketing in front of district offices for three days to get support from the community and from parents. She also wants to send a message to the district that she wants her job back. According to policy, Thomas was supposed to suspend the student.

The district said her actions could have endangered the child.

Thomas said, "Even though I have parent support and the district knows the parents support me, I was supposed to suspend that child and put him out on the street."

Thomas does not, however, have support from the guardian of the child in question.

Rosemary Warren, the student's guardian, said "Do you think she should keep her job or not? No, not if she's got to do that. If she does that to mine, she'll do it to somebody else's child."

Thomas said she's a strict disciplinarian, but she's well-liked by parents and students and she has dozens of signatures on a petition, as well as letters from her students.

She said for now, if she can't teach from the classroom she'll teach by example.

District officials are still investigating the incident.

Thomas will meet with the Rochester Teachers Association lawyer sometime this week.
 
Chalonda Roberts (Rochester, NY) 06/09/04 - A Rochester school teacher was suspended with pay after she allegedly washed out a third grade student's mouth with soap.

Suspended with pay? Isn't that just like a vacation?
They're rewarding her. They should change the title to "Teacher Washes Child's Mouth with Soap; Earns Vacation"
 
I'm a little wary of just taking her word for what she did. If it was really limited to what she claims, she probably should have been reprimanded but not suspended. The fact of the matter is that public schools are generally supposed to be corporal punishment-free zones, and I don't necessarily trust teachers to make judgment calls about what level of corporal punishment is appropriate. If parents are comfortable with this kind of treatment, they can enroll their kids in private schools.
 
OMG, the people of P&N are actually agreeing with each other :shocked:

In unrelated news, the temprature in hell has been steadily dropping.....
 
that's so fvcked up.

it's not as if the student was using bad language directed at the teacher, and it wasn't disrupting the classroom. I cursed when I was that young, and I turned out mostly fine... If the parents don't mind the kid cursing, the teacher should miind her own fvcking business about the issue.
 
Originally posted by: loki8481
that's so fvcked up.

it's not as if the student was using bad language directed at the teacher, and it wasn't disrupting the classroom. I cursed when I was that young, and I turned out mostly fine... If the parents don't mind the kid cursing, the teacher should miind her own fvcking business about the issue.

If the parents don't mind the child cursing then they should teach him not to do it in front of others who might not like it 😉
 
Originally posted by: TechJunkie95242
Some soap can be fatal if digested, she was in the wrong anyhow. I would give her the can and punch her in the face.

Over the years I got to be quite a connossieur of soap. Though my personal preference was for Lux, I found that Palmolive had a nice, piquant after-dinner flavor - heavy, but with a touch of mellow smoothness. Life Buoy, on the other hand... YECCHH!
 
Originally posted by: TechJunkie95242
Some soap can be fatal if digested, she was in the wrong anyhow. I would give her the can and punch her in the face.

That is a good idea. Is that what you do to your girlfriends?
 
Welcome to the world of public school administration.
Home of the "zero thought" .....er..... "zero-tolerance" policies
🙂 😉
 
she should have just smacked the kid in the face.

Aww, heck, why stop there, may as well just beat him to death. 😀
Anyway, yeah, she was wrong, they must have a diciplinary policy in place to deal with a kid cursing and I highly doubt it includes soaping the mouth. Hell, haul out the dunce cap and let the floggings commence while we're at it....
 
Suspension would only give the kid something to brag about to his little play yard buddies about how much of a bad ass he is being suspended at 7 years old. Thus encouraging more behavior of the same type. I was a school kid too so I know how it is.
A smack in the face would be shameful for him, something his buddies could laugh at him about and not something he would ever want to happen again. The point is not to hurt the kid, a little physical pain is nothing he will get over that and have learned not to swear again.
Problem Solved.
 
Developing and maintaining a relationship with the teachers, faculty and administrators at your child's school all but eliminates these types of situations from ever occuring. A similar situation occured with my youngest son after he uttered a word that he must have heard his mother say 😉. The mouth washing ensued AFTER a phone call was made to my wife. This was the beginning of the year, agreed upon course of action that we had set up with the school where they would call and gain concurrence (or solicit input) before any disciplinary action, that could be delayed, would be taken. More parents should try getting involved. It really works.
 
Originally posted by: X-Man
Originally posted by: TechJunkie95242
Some soap can be fatal if digested, she was in the wrong anyhow. I would give her the can and punch her in the face.

Over the years I got to be quite a connossieur of soap. Though my personal preference was for Lux, I found that Palmolive had a nice, piquant after-dinner flavor - heavy, but with a touch of mellow smoothness. Life Buoy, on the other hand... YECCHH!

Great movie 🙂. In fact, it's one of the few holiday movies I enjoy watching over and over.

cumhail
 
Originally posted by: TechJunkie95242
Some soap can be fatal if digested, she was in the wrong anyhow. I would give her the can and punch her in the face.

Violence begets violence. I don't really agree with the teacher in this case. If there was a chronic problem with the child in question cursing, then I'd say she was right. If it was a one time thing, I think sending the child to the principle's office (like happened to me whenever I cursed in school) would be much more appropriate.
 
People have no idea of the power of words...there's no reason to use soap, of all things. My mom yelled at me a lot when I was a kid and I turned out just fine.
 
Originally posted by: TechJunkie95242
Some soap can be fatal if digested, she was in the wrong anyhow. I would give her the can and punch her in the face.


Perhaps cutting the kid's tounge out would be acceptable to you?
 
one has to question the judgement of a person that would even consider doing this as a teacher. did she think this was somehow allowable behavior by teachers? what planet does she live on? if she's so out of touch on this, one wonders what else shes done.
 
Back
Top