sub $1500 gaming machine

jerome12345

Member
Mar 21, 2004
163
0
0
i DONT want AMD
i DONT want nvidia
but i do want comments and suggestions
is anything not worth the money or ridiculously expensive
are there better components out there for similar prices
some components that i would like better alternatives for: case, psu, others too

CRT and LCD recommendations too

and what can i do to make it under 1500
thanks
jerome
 

Runner20

Senior member
May 31, 2004
478
0
0
Everything looks good, although if you get the 128MB version of the Radeon 9800 Pro you may save a bit of money
 

EaeBing

Junior Member
Jun 8, 2004
23
0
0
You can knock off $50 by getting a generic no-name modem. There is no difference in performance between a US Robotics modem and a no-name whitebox $10 modem.

A cheaper alternative to a Plextor CDRW is a Liteon which you can get for around $40.00 and performs just as well
 

Markfw

Moderator Emeritus, Elite Member
May 16, 2002
27,291
16,126
136
You DONT want AMD but you DO want a gaming machine.... When you make up your mind which you really do want, then I will answer. :disgust:

Really, you need to be more open minded.
 

Runner20

Senior member
May 31, 2004
478
0
0
Originally posted by: Markfw900
You DONT want AMD but you DO want a gaming machine.... When you make up your mind which you really do want, then I will answer. :disgust:

Really, you need to be more open minded.

Maybe he just likes Intel better, whats wrong with that?
 

Mo0o

Lifer
Jul 31, 2001
24,227
3
76
Dont intel boards usualy have better overall compatibility with hardware?
 

Acanthus

Lifer
Aug 28, 2001
19,915
2
76
ostif.org
Originally posted by: Mo0o
Dont intel boards usualy have better overall compatibility with hardware?

Intel chipsets generally have more compatibility, but dont confuse that will all pentium 4 motherboards. After all we have VIA, SiS and ALi screwing up the pentium 4s reputation as well ;)
 

Jeff7181

Lifer
Aug 21, 2002
18,368
11
81
Originally posted by: jerome12345
i DONT want AMD
i DONT want nvidia
but i do want comments and suggestions
is anything not worth the money or ridiculously expensive
are there better components out there for similar prices
some components that i would like better alternatives for: case, psu, others too

CRT and LCD recommendations too

and what can i do to make it under 1500
thanks
jerome

Comment: You're an idiot if you refuse to consider AMD or nVidia as an option even.
Suggestion: Consider AMD or nVidia... else go hang out at THG if all you want to hear is "hellz ya dawg... Intel and ATI are da shiznit!"

Seriously though... I like to be rational... and your decision making "process" (if you can even call it that) is not rational.
 

Connoisseur

Platinum Member
Sep 14, 2002
2,470
1
81
Although I am an AMD fan myself, I will try to help. Given your restrictions for a fast cheap gaming machine, I would suggest buying a P4 2.4C and overclocking it. I've heard many ppl can get these processors to aroune 3 ghz easily with a decent heatsink. That'll save you a bunch of money over top of the line 3ghz models. For PSU I would suggest the ThermalTake 480w silent purepower as I have one myself and I love it. Very quiet and cool and very steady voltage rails. Also at newegg I believe you can get it for about $60 shipped. For case, if you want absolute sturdiness and quality go for an Antec (sonata) or a Lian Li. If you're willing to consider other options go with companies such as Aspire and Chenming. They sell very nice cases for cheap prices. I'm sorry I can't help you out with a P4 mobo because frankly I don't know anything about them. Sound card, I would suggest getting an Audigy 2 zs if you can afford it and if you have a decent speaker/headphone setup. Hope it helps.
 

dudeman007

Diamond Member
Apr 6, 2004
3,243
0
0
Looks pretty sexy to me. Thing is...I got the same system as you..the only diff was that I got a 3.2 cpu, retail fan, and different case/psu. My cost....1420. Oh but then instead of a raptor, I got a sata 120 gb samsung. Eh..then also...don't get the 256 9800 pro. Not worth it.

BTW...I just read all the posts about people telling him to go amd. Leave him alone jeez. Some people would just rather stick with intel. Intels can game jeez...its not just the amds. YOU PEOPLE need to be open minded and understand that he likes intel
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
I can put together a system just as good with a 19" LCD using all intel/ATI parts for less.
 

MichaelZ

Senior member
Oct 12, 2003
871
0
76
is it just me or is this deja vu? hopefully this doesn't turn into another intel vs amd thread. *shrugs*
 

Nebor

Lifer
Jun 24, 2003
29,582
12
76
For $1500 you can get an AMD 64 system that will spank that one up one side and down the other (particularly in gaming) PLUS 19" Flatscreen viewsonic CRT. I priced all this out for a friend a week ago.

And in case you didn't know, Corsair is jointly owned by AMD and NVIDIA. ;)
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
First you're wasting serious cash on mobo, IS7 is just as fast for half. Second you can get a 2.4C for less and OC with retail HS to 3.2C at a minimum. Third your video card is a rip. Fouth you don't need two cd roms, just get a combodrive. Fith Raptor is a waste if your on a budget... see anands review. Sixth get microsofts optical combo KB/mouse. half price and way better. Seventh Thermaltake sucks donkey nuts, look at that crappy 12V rail which both the processor and Vid card use. Eight a $10 soft modem is just as good. Ninth Zalman sucks and is expensive use retial HSF. Tenth the 3200DDR you have sucks, you want bandwidth or low latency and what you have in you cart gives you neither:)...I could go on...


Anyway here's what I'd build for $1500 *with* a sweet 19" LCD within your criteria.

COOLER MASTER Centurion 4 Silver ATX Mid-Tower $64.00

Samsung Beige 52X24X52X16 CDR-W/DVD Combo Drive $45.00

NEC 1.44MB Black Internal Floppy Drive $9.50

SAMSUNG 80GB 7200RPM IDE Hard Drive, Model SP0802N $67.50

Two sticks A-DATA 184 Pin 512M DDR PC-4000 $216.00

BenQ FP951 19" LCD Monitor ? $549.00

ABIT "IS7" i865PE Chipset Motherboard for Intel Socket 478 CPU - $91.00

ENERMAX 350W Power Supply for AMD K7 & Pentium4, Model "EG365P-VE(FM)" $45.00

Intel Pentium 4/ 2.4C GHz 800MHz FSB, 512K Cache, Hyper Threading Technology -$169.00

POWERCOLOR ATI RADEON 9800PRO Video Card, 128MB DDR, 256-bit, DVI/TV Out, 8X AGP, Model "XR98-C3" -$206.00


Product total: $1,450.00

Then add your $10 modem and Microsofts optical black combo and your *Still* less than $1500
 

Nebor

Lifer
Jun 24, 2003
29,582
12
76
Originally posted by: Zebo
First you're wasting serious cash on mobo, IC7 is just as fast for half. Second you can get a 2.4C for less and OC with retail HS to 3.2C at a minimum. Third your video card is a rip. Fouth you don't need two cd roms, just get a combodrive. Fith Raptor is a waste if your on a budget... see anands review. Sixth get microsofts optical combo KB/mouse. half price and way better. Seventh Thermaltake sucks donkey nuts, look at that crappy 12V rail which both the processor and Vid card use. Eight a $10 soft modem is just as good. Ninth Zalman sucks and is expensive use retial HSF. Tenth the 3200DDR you have sucks, you want bandwidth or low latency and what you have in you cart gives you neither:)...I could go on...


Anyway here's what I'd build for $1500 *with* a sweet 19" LCD within your criteria.

COOLER MASTER Centurion 4 Silver ATX Mid-Tower $64.00

Samsung Beige 52X24X52X16 CDR-W/DVD Combo Drive $45.00

NEC 1.44MB Black Internal Floppy Drive $9.50

SAMSUNG 80GB 7200RPM IDE Hard Drive, Model SP0802N $67.50

Two sticks A-DATA 184 Pin 512M DDR PC-4000 $216.00

BenQ FP951 19" LCD Monitor ? $549.00

ABIT "IS7-E" i865PE Chipset Motherboard for Intel Socket 478 CPU - $83.00

ENERMAX 350W Power Supply for AMD K7 & Pentium4, Model "EG365P-VE(FM)" $45.00

Intel Pentium 4/ 2.4C GHz 800MHz FSB, 512K Cache, Hyper Threading Technology -$169.00

Celestica ATI RADEON 9800PRO 128MB DDR, DVI/TV-Out, 8X AGP, Model "GOLD EDITION RADEON 9800PRO" $206.00


Product total: $1,450.00

Then add your $10 modem and Microsofts optical black combo and your *Still* less than $1500

I'm guessing you got all those posts in OT or P&N, because you're way off.

1) Maybe he needs the extras that accompany a top end motherboard, ie: extra sata connectors, gigabit lan. I'd still recommend the IC7 Max 3 over the Asus, just because I had serious problems using the Asus myself.

2) The price difference between the 3.0 and 2.4 is now negligible, you'd pretty much be a food to get the 2.4C.

3) The Celestica video card you suggested doesn't specify if the memory is 256-bit, and it is dangerous to assume that it isn't. The safer bet would be with the Sapphire version which specifies 256-bit and also goes for $206.

4) Yeah, one combodrive is likely a good idea, unless he's some kind of software pirate.

5) Agreed, raptor is a waste. Mainly bragging rights. I'd rather have twice as much space.

6) The only thing better than the MX Duo is the di Novo. THe MX Duo is simply an awsome combo, which looks and works great. It can usually be had for cheaper elsewhere though. Is the optical combo you speak of even wireless?

7) Yup, TT doesn't make anything worth buying. An Antec, Fortron or Seasonic would be a MUCH better choice.

8)Yeah, a modem is a modem. But does anybody remember the days when Winmodems were worse because they used processor power, and our processors were actually slow enough that it mattered?

9) Saying "Zalman sucks" is just idiotic. I don't think they make a single product that isn't awsome, and near the top of it's class. The 7000Cu is a great choice for most users. And advising the use of stock cooling AND overclocking in one post is beyond me.

10) Higher bandwidth ram would be nice. Timings don't really make much of a difference. But some PC3700 would let you top out that 3.0 nicely when overclocking.

11) A-DATA Ram? At least you could narrow down your system's instability pretty quickly.
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Originally posted by: Nebor
Originally posted by: Zebo
First you're wasting serious cash on mobo, IC7 is just as fast for half. Second you can get a 2.4C for less and OC with retail HS to 3.2C at a minimum. Third your video card is a rip. Fouth you don't need two cd roms, just get a combodrive. Fith Raptor is a waste if your on a budget... see anands review. Sixth get microsofts optical combo KB/mouse. half price and way better. Seventh Thermaltake sucks donkey nuts, look at that crappy 12V rail which both the processor and Vid card use. Eight a $10 soft modem is just as good. Ninth Zalman sucks and is expensive use retial HSF. Tenth the 3200DDR you have sucks, you want bandwidth or low latency and what you have in you cart gives you neither:)...I could go on...


Anyway here's what I'd build for $1500 *with* a sweet 19" LCD within your criteria.

COOLER MASTER Centurion 4 Silver ATX Mid-Tower $64.00

Samsung Beige 52X24X52X16 CDR-W/DVD Combo Drive $45.00

NEC 1.44MB Black Internal Floppy Drive $9.50

SAMSUNG 80GB 7200RPM IDE Hard Drive, Model SP0802N $67.50

Two sticks A-DATA 184 Pin 512M DDR PC-4000 $216.00

BenQ FP951 19" LCD Monitor ? $549.00

ABIT "IS7-E" i865PE Chipset Motherboard for Intel Socket 478 CPU - $83.00

ENERMAX 350W Power Supply for AMD K7 & Pentium4, Model "EG365P-VE(FM)" $45.00

Intel Pentium 4/ 2.4C GHz 800MHz FSB, 512K Cache, Hyper Threading Technology -$169.00

Celestica ATI RADEON 9800PRO 128MB DDR, DVI/TV-Out, 8X AGP, Model "GOLD EDITION RADEON 9800PRO" $206.00


Product total: $1,450.00

Then add your $10 modem and Microsofts optical black combo and your *Still* less than $1500

I'm guessing you got all those posts in OT or P&N, because you're way off.

But then you agree with 75%

1) Maybe he needs the extras that accompany a top end motherboard, ie: extra sata connectors, gigabit lan. I'd still recommend the IC7 Max 3 over the Asus, just because I had serious problems using the Asus myself.
IS7 has gigabit, he's only buying one drive..doubt he needs more than 4 SATA connectors
2) The price difference between the 3.0 and 2.4 is now negligible, you'd pretty much be a food to get the 2.4C.

Same chip cheaper

3) The Celestica video card you suggested doesn't specify if the memory is 256-bit, and it is dangerous to assume that it isn't. The safer bet would be with the Sapphire version which specifies 256-bit and also goes for $206.

True that card i thought was 256..I usually do recommend 256 but erred here, fixed

4) Yeah, one combodrive is likely a good idea, unless he's some kind of software pirate.

we agree

5) Agreed, raptor is a waste. Mainly bragging rights. I'd rather have twice as much space.

We agree
]
6) The only thing better than the MX Duo is the di Novo. THe MX Duo is simply an awsome combo, which looks and works great. It can usually be had for cheaper elsewhere though. Is the optical combo you speak of even wireless?

7) Yup, TT doesn't make anything worth buying. An Antec, Fortron or Seasonic would be a MUCH better choice.

we agree

8)Yeah, a modem is a modem. But does anybody remember the days when Winmodems were worse because they used processor power, and our processors were actually slow enough that it mattered?
we agree

9) Saying "Zalman sucks" is just idiotic. I don't think they make a single product that isn't awsome, and near the top of it's class. The 7000Cu is a great choice for most users. And advising the use of stock cooling AND overclocking in one post is beyond me.

Dude it offers terrible cooling I bet worse cooling than Stock HSF and it's forty freaking dollars, I could buy a processor for that, what a waste. go over to overclockers.com and see how low it's rated..besides he does'nt need an aftermarket HS., I overclock 600Mhz axp with a $8 HSF. I do understand that would be "beyond" your realm of comprehension though since you buy into Zalman's Hyped and overpriced products.

10) Higher bandwidth ram would be nice. Timings don't really make much of a difference. But some PC3700 would let you top out that 3.0 nicely when overclocking.

we agree

11) A-DATA Ram? At least you could narrow down your system's instability pretty quickly.
Prove it. Adata ram with the hynix stick are just awesome. They love voltage and regularly run upwards of 250FSB 1:1 cas 3 not 4 unlike the stuff you'd recommed

Now wheres your sub $1500 effort?
 

Nebor

Lifer
Jun 24, 2003
29,582
12
76
My sub $1500 effort doesn't qualify, it's an AMD 64.

And he doesn't need PC4000, it would be silly to buy a 2.4C. Corsair 3700 w/ Cas 3 should be just fine.

And while the Zalman isn't the best, it offers a good compromise between quiet and efficient, and is certainly better than the stock cooler.

EDIT: And the base IC7 motherboard doesn't have any LAN whatsoever, much less CSA gigabit lan...
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Originally posted by: Nebor
My sub $1500 effort doesn't qualify, it's an AMD 64.

And he doesn't need PC4000, it would be silly to buy a 2.4C. Corsair 3700 w/ Cas 3 should be just fine.

And while the Zalman isn't the best, it offers a good compromise between quiet and efficient, and is certainly better than the stock cooler.



The hynix memory will allow him to run that 2.4C at 250MHZ 1:1. Equaling a 3.0C but will run apps/games much faster than the 3.0C/3200ram he was looking at in the first place because of the higher bandwidth. My recommendation is based on his price limitation and platform he want to stay under so I had no choice but to drop to a 2.4C an this ram and still stay within bugetary constraints. As a bonus, it will be faster than what he orginally had.

Zalman is alright stuff but it's very overpriced which has no place in this setup. I run Zalman passive NB sinks on all my mobos, Run a passive Zalman cooler on video card and have a Zalman PSU. I just think it's no where near what it's worth unless you mention you want a silent system to me.;)... edit I forgot I also have a zalman flower on a barton 1.25 @ 1.2 volts with no fan at all..
 

Nebor

Lifer
Jun 24, 2003
29,582
12
76
Originally posted by: Zebo
Originally posted by: Nebor
My sub $1500 effort doesn't qualify, it's an AMD 64.

And he doesn't need PC4000, it would be silly to buy a 2.4C. Corsair 3700 w/ Cas 3 should be just fine.

And while the Zalman isn't the best, it offers a good compromise between quiet and efficient, and is certainly better than the stock cooler.



The hynix memory will allow him to run that 2.4C at 250MHZ 1:1. Equaling a 3.0C but will run apps/games much faster than the 3.0C/3200ram he was looking at in the first place because of the higher bandwidth. My recommendation is based on his price limitation and platform he want to stay under so I had no choice but to drop to a 2.4C an this ram and still stay within bugetary constraints. As a bonus, it will be faster than what he orginally had.

Zalman is alright stuff but it's very overpriced which has no place in this setup. I run Zalman passive NB sinks on all my mobos, Run a passive Zalman cooler on video card and have a Zalman PSU. I just think it's no where near what it's worth unless you mention you want a silent system to me.;)... edit I forgot I also have a zalman flower on a barton 1.25 @ 1.2 volts with no fan at all..

Fanless cooling of a Barton? That's impressive. You know the SPCR groupie chicks will do anything for you now. And they're virtually silent! :p ;)

By the way, for the same money, you could get an A64 system that would walk all over the p4s... But this guy's a fool.
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Originally posted by: Nebor
My sub $1500 effort doesn't qualify, it's an AMD 64.

And he doesn't need PC4000, it would be silly to buy a 2.4C. Corsair 3700 w/ Cas 3 should be just fine.

And while the Zalman isn't the best, it offers a good compromise between quiet and efficient, and is certainly better than the stock cooler.

EDIT: And the base IC7 motherboard doesn't have any LAN whatsoever, much less CSA gigabit lan...

No one's recommend the IC7, IS7.:)
 

Zebo

Elite Member
Jul 29, 2001
39,398
19
81
Originally posted by: Nebor
Originally posted by: Zebo
Originally posted by: Nebor
My sub $1500 effort doesn't qualify, it's an AMD 64.

And he doesn't need PC4000, it would be silly to buy a 2.4C. Corsair 3700 w/ Cas 3 should be just fine.

And while the Zalman isn't the best, it offers a good compromise between quiet and efficient, and is certainly better than the stock cooler.



The hynix memory will allow him to run that 2.4C at 250MHZ 1:1. Equaling a 3.0C but will run apps/games much faster than the 3.0C/3200ram he was looking at in the first place because of the higher bandwidth. My recommendation is based on his price limitation and platform he want to stay under so I had no choice but to drop to a 2.4C an this ram and still stay within bugetary constraints. As a bonus, it will be faster than what he orginally had.

Zalman is alright stuff but it's very overpriced which has no place in this setup. I run Zalman passive NB sinks on all my mobos, Run a passive Zalman cooler on video card and have a Zalman PSU. I just think it's no where near what it's worth unless you mention you want a silent system to me.;)... edit I forgot I also have a zalman flower on a barton 1.25 @ 1.2 volts with no fan at all..

Fanless cooling of a Barton? That's impressive. You know the SPCR groupie chicks will do anything for you now. And they're virtually silent! :p ;)

By the way, for the same money, you could get an A64 system that would walk all over the p4s... But this guy's a fool.

LOL No it's not all that impressive. I sorta cheat doing it. While the Antec Aria case only has one fan, the 120mm inside PSU, it happens to be located right next to flower which automatically whisks air past flower as it's passing though case.

Anyway the setup is totally silent just for internet browsing/office use inside bedroom on 24/7.

Potential noise makers:

Mobo - Shuttle MN31N on-board vid/sound with modded passive northbridge.
Chip- Mobile 2600 @1.2Ghz (200x6) passive zalman flower
Harddrive- Fujitsu 60GB 5400RPM Notebook Hard Drive suspended with bungie cord acrross CD rom bay.
CD- None, that's what home networks are for


Also it's a 45W version of barton with a zalman copper flower @ 1.2GHz and ~1.20 Volts. My guess is it uses about 20W.

Default Watts * (Overclocked or Underclocked Mhz \ Default Mhz) * (Overclocked or Underclocked Vcore \ Default Vcore)^2 = Overclocked or Underclocked Watts