Originally posted by: BlueFlamme
Comparing GPA outside of a specific course at a specific school during the same semester under the same professor is a waste of time. Two personal examples:
Digital Logic. My professor tought this as a weeding out course and my final grade after lots of work was a B-. My classmates had another professor who was a joke that same semester, they couldnt' even answer some of my relatively easy questions and they sailed through with As.
Probability, Statistics, and Reliabilty. I took this during summer semester in order to help me squeeze in a second minor. It was slightly difficult but I had that professor before and she was a lot easier than in my other course with her and I ended with an A. Next semester the same friends from the example above struggled to get Bs with the same professor I had (these friends have GPAs of 3.98, 3.8, and 3.65). My knowledge was on par with their knowledge, but since I was taking it with a bunch of people who had already failed her once, I got better grades.
It gets even worse when you're comparing degree programs. My wife has a degree in English. I love to read, I just don't like to analyze it. Most people would consider Engineering far superior than English. I believe I could have completed an English degree, but I guarantee I would have had a few sub-Bs when I hit the senior literature classes.
As far as different colleges, yes, there can be a large skill difference between similar degrees. That being said, getting up on a high horse just because of what college you went to is a joke. It looks good on a resume, but what matters most in a degree (generically) is the ability to learn. There are several specific fields such as engineering, medical, and legal that require a degree in that field because of the responsibility to the public, it wouldn't do to have bridges collapsing, patients dying, and bad laws being passed. (and of course it helps to know a subject to plan on teaching)
There will always be people who graduated from a big name university who you are smarter than, and there will always be someone who has no higher education who is smarter than you, so don't focus on where you stand but on what you are working on.