SPOILERS BELOW!!!!!!!!!
I bought it about two weeks ago at $20. Spent almost a week solid of nearly every spare minute playing it. Beat it 4 times. It's fun but here are the problems.
1. TOO DAMN MANY/LONG/UNAVOIDABLE cutscenes! I swear, about half the playtime is watching cutscenes. First time it's fine, but you can't turn the damn things off for replays, and most of them the text can't even be skipped through.
2. No sex cutscene. Oh theres a sex scene... but it goes from you seducing her to her telling you how awful it was. with a 3 second blank screen in between. You don't see so much as a snuggle.
3. Running. Oh dear god so much running. The teleport function doesnt work in 90% of the places you'd use it. And half the time it doesn't let you teleport back for whatever reason.
4. Dark side is for pansies. You want to be a dark jedi? Ok you sacrifice everything for power, shrink away from your comrades and display a growing distaste for mankind. WRONG! You threaten old people, act like a petty street thug and lie about how much you love the light side. Oooo ominous.
5. REALLY imbalanced. Soldier/Guardian can drop the end boss (on normal) without using a single healthpack or even bothering to stop him from healing (he has like 8-12 full heals he uses at about 40% health each) Scoundral/consular can't freaking kill him without running around and tossing grenades everytime he holds still for a second.
6. No attack ground with nades command
7. You can't have more than one character doing noncombat activities at a time. So whenever I want to bash a twelve foot wide door down. I bash on it for two freaking minutes while my two companions twiddle their damn thumbs.
8. At no point do you get to control your entire group in a sweet mass-battle .
9. STUPID AI and no balancing feature for the game. So when I was a guardian/soldier I could Kill the endboss at the first encounter in ONE round of combat. I would attack him, he'd go down to 1VP and then freeze me and run off. I'd find him, again knock him down to 1vp instantly. Then a cutscene where I'm frozen and he's telling me how even my entire group is no match for him (Mind you I can solo kill him in less than a second at this point in the game). Then I... I ! run away from him.
10. Really small and pointless zones. Manaan is so damn small the whole damn thing could have fit inside one, two zones tops. But instead we get about ten zones just for the freaking town. Most of them have one or two npc's and otherwise are just wastes of time running to and from zones on either side. Tattoine has like three zones and some buildings... but the zones are huge and 99% empty space. Takes about three minutes of nothing but running to get to where you are going.
11. Confusing maps + knight speed. With all that running knightspeed is a godsend. You run about 150% as fast as usual. But your vision is blurred in what I describe as "The stupidest game effect EVER"! I've ran in circles through manaan more than once.
12. Crummy equipment. The equipment is just plain crap in the game. Largely because it's so short.
13. Useless sidequests. Unless you really need ls or ds points, quests are mostly useless. The exception being swoopraces which pay out in big amounts of cash.
14. A couple really stupid puzzles
15. occasionally there is a problem with a memory leak
Im sure I could think of more, but I'm tired. Anyway, even with all those problems it is a decent game good for at least two plays (one light, one dark). But you can tell they really stretched it with some filler that will be quite irritating the second time around.