• We’re currently investigating an issue related to the forum theme and styling that is impacting page layout and visual formatting. The problem has been identified, and we are actively working on a resolution. There is no impact to user data or functionality, this is strictly a front-end display issue. We’ll post an update once the fix has been deployed. Thanks for your patience while we get this sorted.

Star Trek vs BSG vs Stargate SG-1 or Atlantis

S

Skriptures17

Member
Here it is the ultimate tpoic. Since today is the season premier of BSG i thought to myself which one do people like better BSG or Star Trek. Let me know what you think and why. after further review i decided to put SG on this question too. Also if you like ST name your SERIES , TOS , ds9 etc.
 
poll??

BSG for the cinematography and writing but ST for it's impact on society and general ideas they present
 
Originally posted by: Skriptures17
Here it is the ultimate tpoic. Since today is the season premier of BSG i thought to myself which one do people like better BSG or Star Trek. Let me know what you think and why.
Click to expand...

What star trek? Do you mean the star trek universive in general, or a specific series?
 
I liked TNG a lot. I'd need a couple more seasons from BSG before I can more accurately judge which is better but until then TNG.
 
I do not like BSG. I do like ST. Therefore, I like ST better. I also like SG better, but that's off the topic of this off topic thread.
 
Originally posted by: RedCOMET
Originally posted by: Skriptures17
Here it is the ultimate tpoic. Since today is the season premier of BSG i thought to myself which one do people like better BSG or Star Trek. Let me know what you think and why.
Click to expand...

What star trek? Do you mean the star trek universive in general, or a specific series?
Click to expand...

you a smart man and i see you have love for ST to even want it clered up that way, okay if you pick ST then pick your series, tng, tos or DS9(which i love)
 
I thought this was about an interstellar free-for-all with Adama and Galactica vs. Kirk and old Enterprise vs. Picard and new Enterprise?

I'll take Kirk any day of the week.
 
Originally posted by: dainthomas
I thought this was about an interstellar free-for-all with Adama and Galactica vs. Kirk and old Enterprise vs. Picard and new Enterprise?

I'll take Kirk any day of the week.
Click to expand...

you're insane...

the old enterprise had a horrible script, horrible acting/directing, and laughable storyline.

BSG is a superior show in every sense
 
ST: DS9
SG: SG1
ST: TNG
SG: Atlantis
ST: OS
.
.
.
.
.
.
ST: Enterprise
.
.
x^10000000000000
.
.
ST: Voyager

Have not seen BSG so can not give ranking.
 
Originally posted by: DanTMWTMP
Originally posted by: dainthomas
I thought this was about an interstellar free-for-all with Adama and Galactica vs. Kirk and old Enterprise vs. Picard and new Enterprise?

I'll take Kirk any day of the week.
Click to expand...

you're insane...

the old enterprise had a horrible script, horrible acting/directing, and laughable storyline.

BSG is a superior show in every sense
Click to expand...
he wasn't talking about the script, acting, directing, or storyline. he thought it was about an actual fight and therefore chose Kirk and the old Enterprise whom he feels would kick more ass.
 
Originally posted by: DanTMWTMP
Originally posted by: dainthomas
I thought this was about an interstellar free-for-all with Adama and Galactica vs. Kirk and old Enterprise vs. Picard and new Enterprise?

I'll take Kirk any day of the week.
Click to expand...

you're insane...

the old enterprise had a horrible script, horrible acting/directing, and laughable storyline.

BSG is a superior show in every sense
Click to expand...

I disagree. However, I was talking about an actual space battle.

Edit: Thanks HN! 😀
 
for me i love all these shows very dearly. (cep enterprise, geez that was a piece............no no no wait voyager that was the trash of man if i ever see janeway imma slap that chickenhead) for star trek my fav show was DS9, my fav captian was kirk(str8 @$$ kicker)
I think sg-1 is a real good show with comedic lines that at times go soo good with the show you forget how corny it can get sometimes(tho this past season was a bit over the top for me). Atlantis, i dunno about it seems well................ yeah neway.
But the king of them all is BSG. The writing is super, the acting is almost classic in the sense of the golden age of hollywood, and the way they flim it is turly a work of art. May the lords of Kobal guide this show thur a high rated season.
 
Originally posted by: Skriptures17
Originally posted by: RedCOMET
Originally posted by: Skriptures17
Here it is the ultimate tpoic. Since today is the season premier of BSG i thought to myself which one do people like better BSG or Star Trek. Let me know what you think and why.
Click to expand...

What star trek? Do you mean the star trek universive in general, or a specific series?
Click to expand...

you a smart man and i see you have love for ST to even want it clered up that way, okay if you pick ST then pick your series, tng, tos or DS9(which i love)
Click to expand...


You forgot VOY and ENT
 
bsg is the only sci fi show i like, but i started watching sg-1 because of it. sg-1 can be kinda silly though.

"Hallowed are the Ori"
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

TRENDING THREADS

Back
Top