speedzter3 firewire/usb2.0 enclosure any good?

[wz78]

has anyone used the speedzter3 firewire enclosure? my maxtor firewire is having the clicking and hanging problem. i read some post on the net, it seems to be the power switch/supply problem. since it's already out of warranty, i'm thinking just get a new enclosure and swap the hard drive. now i'm trying to decide between the icecube and the speedzter3. please someone give me an advice if you have experience with either one of the enclosures.

thanks in advance

 

[RichieZ]

I have the icecube, works great. I also looked the the speedzter3, these enclosures are expensive becasue they look nice and becasue of the size. If I could do it again I would buy one of the cheap ones at compugeeks, some of them use the same firewire chipset (oxford 911) and I think all the USB2 are the ISD300 (junk, its slow).

 

[wz78]

thanks for the info. guess i'll get one from compugeeks.