Nah. Real gamers play in 240p in 15kHz RGB!
People arguing about pixels are most likely the CoD chumps. 1080p is just another number to brag about next to their K/D.
Xenoblade Chronicles on Wii U on a 1080p panel looked like crap, as did Xenogears on a 10 foot 1080p screen (this was before I got all hardcore retro with RGB monitors). But Xenogears was one of the most unforgettable games I've ever played. 240p upscaled to 1080p and all the PS2->PS1 BC glitches as annoying as they were, has no impact on that. I should replay it though in RGB on a real PS1.
Cell shaded games like this, Ni no Kuni, Tales of, etc resolution isn't really isn't as important.