Siddhartha
Lifer
Originally posted by: Termagant
Previous waves of immigrants didn't know English but eventually their children learned it. Is this only an issue now because Mexicans have darker skin than say Italians or Poles?
Originally posted by: Termagant
Previous waves of immigrants didn't know English but eventually their children learned it. Is this only an issue now because Mexicans have darker skin than say Italians or Poles?
Originally posted by: Shivetya
multiple languages divide a people, they also can keep certain minority groups down. Perhaps thats the real reason, if people get hampered by the language they will turn more to the government for relief.
Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
Rename the US dialect of English to American and make it the official language.
Originally posted by: BoberFett
Neither will coddling non-English speakers by making everything multi-lingual.Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
Originally posted by: BoberFett
I'm confused. Requiring all government business to be conducted in one language is a barrier, but having half of the country unable to talk to the other half is not? You should probably holding off on calling other people "twats" until you've thought about your opinion for a while and realize how stupid it is.Originally posted by: 2Xtreme21
Because it would do nothing but take away rights from people. The government's job is to better the lives of its people. Adding a useless language barrier wouldn't help anyone except for you twats who think you're better than everyone else, yet still probably couldn't find any given country on a map.
Making English the official languages doesn't magically make those who can't speak English fluent.
Why are we being generous to people who can't be bothered to learn the [unoffical] national language? I'd rather see the government spend the money we currently spend on catering to non-English speakers on providing free English classes.In addition, most of the bilingual stuff featured at the federal level are not required to be bilingual, obviously. They were made bilingual to be generous to those who don't speak English.
That's all well and good until those people are a significant percentage of the population, which you admit isn't true in PA. Try going to some parts of SoCal or Miami and try to get by without speaking Spanish.Living in western Pennsylvania, I don't encounter too many people who don't speak English-- especially in the quantities that those of you living in the southwest do, but if someone approaches me and begins to speak Spanish, I wouldn't have a problem telling him I don't speak it. It's up to him to then find someone who does, or learn enough English to allow me to understand him. It shouldn't be mandated by anyone but himself.
Having a single national language helps to unify a country. Just look at Quebec. Are you ready to let parts of the US secede?
Originally posted by: Pacemaker
I don't have a problem when other people want to speak a different language, but when I go to McDonalds and I have to be able to speak spanish to order (happens in Miami all the time) that is not ok. I don't mind if they speak both, but to not speak English at a business is just not ok.
Originally posted by: Vich
Originally posted by: Pacemaker
I don't have a problem when other people want to speak a different language, but when I go to McDonalds and I have to be able to speak spanish to order (happens in Miami all the time) that is not ok. I don't mind if they speak both, but to not speak English at a business is just not ok.
Exactly. Unbelievable.
Originally posted by: Pacemaker
I don't have a problem when other people want to speak a different language, but when I go to McDonalds and I have to be able to speak spanish to order (happens in Miami all the time) that is not ok. I don't mind if they speak both, but to not speak English at a business is just not ok.
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
Rename the US dialect of English to American and make it the official language.
That won't work because the U.S. will be renamed Unestados De Mexico
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: Vich
Originally posted by: Pacemaker
I don't have a problem when other people want to speak a different language, but when I go to McDonalds and I have to be able to speak spanish to order (happens in Miami all the time) that is not ok. I don't mind if they speak both, but to not speak English at a business is just not ok.
Exactly. Unbelievable.
Why is that not ok? Don't all you right wing people worship the free market? By your own ideology, they are providing a service to meet a market (spanish speaking McDonalds eaters). If what they are doing is bad, they will go out of business.
I have noticed that not one person has provided a SINGLE point in this thread that has not been a repeat of some doom and gloom pronouncement made about one of a half dozen groups of immigrants in decades and centuries past that turned out to be racist lies. They were racist and xenophobic then, and they are racist and xenophobic now. That's right... I'm calling you racists. You can wrap it in the American flag if you want, you can wrap it in the "defense of American culture", or in defense of our hard earned tax money, but we both know what you're really saying is that America is becoming a place where the way of life of all the Decent White Folk is threatened. You know what? If it's that great, it will endure... and maybe we need to relearn that legendary tolerance we always pat ourselves on the back for having.
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
Rename the US dialect of English to American and make it the official language.
That won't work because the U.S. will be renamed Unestados De Mexico
Originally posted by: sdifox
Originally posted by: dmcowen674
Originally posted by: Schadenfroh
Rename the US dialect of English to American and make it the official language.
That won't work because the U.S. will be renamed Unestados De Mexico
Estados Unidos Mexicanos is the official name of Mexico... so Id on't know what you are trying to say there. I am all for making Amerikinsky the official language of USA.
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: Vich
Originally posted by: Pacemaker
I don't have a problem when other people want to speak a different language, but when I go to McDonalds and I have to be able to speak spanish to order (happens in Miami all the time) that is not ok. I don't mind if they speak both, but to not speak English at a business is just not ok.
Exactly. Unbelievable.
Why is that not ok? Don't all you right wing people worship the free market? By your own ideology, they are providing a service to meet a market (spanish speaking McDonalds eaters). If what they are doing is bad, they will go out of business.
I have noticed that not one person has provided a SINGLE point in this thread that has not been a repeat of some doom and gloom pronouncement made about one of a half dozen groups of immigrants in decades and centuries past that turned out to be racist lies. They were racist and xenophobic then, and they are racist and xenophobic now. That's right... I'm calling you racists. You can wrap it in the American flag if you want, you can wrap it in the "defense of American culture", or in defense of our hard earned tax money, but we both know what you're really saying is that America is becoming a place where the way of life of all the Decent White Folk is threatened. You know what? If it's that great, it will endure... and maybe we need to relearn that legendary tolerance we always pat ourselves on the back for having.
Originally posted by: BoberFett
Wow, the racist card. Good argument. That would be true, except that I have no problem with English speaking Mexicans, only ones that can't be bothered to learn our language. I get along just fine with my neighbors and they're Mexican. They also speak English and have jobs and own a business, which goes a long way towards me liking a person.
No, you're still wrong. I have no problems with Mexicans in Mexico speaking Spanish. Hell, that's the Official Language there, and if I were to move to Mexico I wouldn't expect them all to speak English just to benefit me. I only have a problem with Mexicans who move to the US and then expect everyone else to accommodate them.Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BoberFett
Wow, the racist card. Good argument. That would be true, except that I have no problem with English speaking Mexicans, only ones that can't be bothered to learn our language. I get along just fine with my neighbors and they're Mexican. They also speak English and have jobs and own a business, which goes a long way towards me liking a person.
Ahh, so you don't have a problem with Mexicans as long as they speak the language you want them to. You're right... no problems there!
Originally posted by: BoberFett
No, you're still wrong. I have no problems with Mexicans in Mexico speaking Spanish. Hell, that's the Official Language there, and if I were to move to Mexico I wouldn't expect them all to speak English just to benefit me. I only have a problem with Mexicans who move to the US and then expect everyone else to accommodate them.Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BoberFett
Wow, the racist card. Good argument. That would be true, except that I have no problem with English speaking Mexicans, only ones that can't be bothered to learn our language. I get along just fine with my neighbors and they're Mexican. They also speak English and have jobs and own a business, which goes a long way towards me liking a person.
Ahh, so you don't have a problem with Mexicans as long as they speak the language you want them to. You're right... no problems there!
But don't let me stop you from playing the racist card. It makes it that much easier for everyone to see how flimsy your arguments are.
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BoberFett
My argument is that you're racist. Don't worry, it's the same stance that many many generations of past Americans have had, including many of our illustrious founding fathers. So don't worry... you're in good company.
Wow, the racist card again. Good one. Why don't you call me gay and retarded while you're at it? That would be the trifecta of childish comebacks.
Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BoberFett
No, you're still wrong. I have no problems with Mexicans in Mexico speaking Spanish. Hell, that's the Official Language there, and if I were to move to Mexico I wouldn't expect them all to speak English just to benefit me. I only have a problem with Mexicans who move to the US and then expect everyone else to accommodate them.Originally posted by: eskimospy
Originally posted by: BoberFett
Wow, the racist card. Good argument. That would be true, except that I have no problem with English speaking Mexicans, only ones that can't be bothered to learn our language. I get along just fine with my neighbors and they're Mexican. They also speak English and have jobs and own a business, which goes a long way towards me liking a person.
Ahh, so you don't have a problem with Mexicans as long as they speak the language you want them to. You're right... no problems there!
But don't let me stop you from playing the racist card. It makes it that much easier for everyone to see how flimsy your arguments are.
My argument is that you're racist. Don't worry, it's the same stance that many many generations of past Americans have had, including many of our illustrious founding fathers. So don't worry... you're in good company.
So why hasnt congress made English the official language yet?