From what I see is that ID isn't realy doing anything wrong.
They say "It will be done when it will be done"
Everybody is like WTF? I want to give them money NOW! give me give me give me.
the say: 'Well, Like we said before we aren't sticking to any date and you'll know when it will be finished when we finish it, because well tell you. It will be done when it is done. With something like this it's realy hard to tell and we want to make a great game.'
Everybody says: haha Duke nukem forever ahah ahah ahah.
they say: '...'
Everybody says: It's vaporware, blah blah blah, ID's falling behind. blah blah, quake was great, but who cares nowadays.
Then they go! Ahah we will create a bunch of fan sites and talk about ID and Doom3 all day long because we have no life!
For months and months people set up rumor after rumor after rumor. Dishonest companies see a way to take money from gullable eager children by the pre-order scams.
then they go: 'We have a demo for a trade show. It's here to show that it's not vaporware and because lots of people are curious'
then they also say: 'Don't forget though that there is a lot of work needed to be done. So don't expect it out anytime soon'
Then people go, YA! Finally a demo, lets all download a video with trent reznor talking about ID. This means that Doom3 is comming out soon!!!!! Woopy. (time to place our advanced pre-order and buy that new Nvidia 5700 for playing DOOM 3, because it will be kick-ass.)
A few months later....
hey, ID said that they would release it soon!!!!
They said "no we didn't say that. It will be finished when it's finished, duh. Remember?"
Hey HL2 will kick Doom3's @ss WOOP WOOP. Id's dead id's screwed. What a bunch of a-holes.
Meanwhile HL2's release date come and goes and still no HL2.
Now guys are saying "You fell for ID's BS again. When will people stop being so stupid?"
I am saying "You fell for your OWN BS. ID never said that they were going to release anything on anydate ever."
Over and over again they said it may be finished buy this or that time. BUT REMEMBER IT'S NOT SET IN STONE OR ANYTHING. I will be done when it gets done.
The only reason it's a cleche' phrase is because ID has to repeat themselvers OVER AND OVER AND OVER AND OVER again.
But people only hear what people want to hear. They hear April 15th, they assume that must be correct.
And now your pissed at ID, because you misconstrued a imaginary date set by people who have no part in creating the game in the first place?
id never did anything wrong or ever try to deceive anybody about the release date. They are a victom of their own fame, people make up what they want about id (symptom of celeberty worship?) and when it doesn't happen they get angry at id. It's stupid.
Personally I never gave Doom3 a second thought. I look forward to playing it, but I am not going to get pissed about it. Why should I care about id or what they do anyways? It doesn't make sense. My universe isn't going to collasp because I can't play it, there are plenty of other things to do.