So I've test driven four cars so far...

CurseTheSky

Diamond Member
Oct 21, 2006
5,401
2
0
Cliffs:
- 23 year old looking for used car in $10-14k range; hate SUVs / hatchbacks, prefer coupes but "need" sedan due to 5 year old; always driven domestic (but read below)
- Test drove new 2009 V6 Fusion SE as a reference; loved it but new is too pricey
- Test drove used Mazda3 2.3L with 97k miles; loved it, but mileage too high
- Test drove used 2008 Focus SES with 30k miles; not a fan of angry hamsters fighting light headwinds
- Test drove used 2007 V6 Mustang; hated it, just like I suspected.
- Looking in the area for '07 or '08 used V6 Fusion SE, but also considering Mazda3 S; sales rep calling me back tomorrow to report findings.

To give a brief background, I'm 23 years old, and after pulling some strings and playing my cards right, I'm going to be graduating with a Bachelors of Science (Computer Science) in two weeks. I'm currently driving a 2003 Malibu LS with 69k miles and a fair share of problems and minor annoyances. I don't need a "new to me" car, I want one. I wouldn't shed a tear ridding myself of the commonly known problems with the Malibu, though, like the leaking head or intake gasket (oil in the coolant, yay), shudders during every upshift, etc. Most of my experience has been with GM cars, and taste wise, I prefer cars and large trucks; I despise SUVs, hatchbacks, vans, wagons, etc. Passenger wise, I have my girlfriend and her 5-year-old son; while I prefer coupes, they're not the most practical.

Earlier this week, I test drove a 2009 Fusion V6 SE. It was out of my price range, but they let both my dad and I drive it since we were both looking. The 221 HP 3.0L V6 definitely had a smoother power band than both of our 2003 Malibus. The Malibus have great torque on the low end but very flat mid range; they pick up nicely around 3.5-4000 RPMs, with the sacrifice of gas mileage of course. The roads were a little wet, and I actually was having trouble not spinning the tires, speeding, and feathering it around the parking lot. For a family sedan, I was impressed with the power. On the other hand, the 6 speed auto was also nice step up from the 4 speeds we're used, though does shift a bit sloppy. The interior wasn't bad; not the best I've seen, but not too cheap feeling or tacky like many cars I've been in. The materials reminded me somewhat of an older Lincoln or Chrysler for some reason. In the end, I reluctantly walked out of the dealership wishing I could take one home without test driving a single other car.

Today, I went back down to the dealer hoping to find a used 2007 V6 Fusion SE with under 40k miles (prefer under 25k) for around $12k, give or take. Unfortunately, there's dozens of used I4 Fusions available, but hardly any of the sixes. I know the I4 is more than adequate, but I also know myself, and in the end I'd find SOME reason not to be happy with it. The sales rep called several dealerships within a ~100 mile radius, got a few hits (most of which were already sold), but ultimately couldn't find anything right off the bat. In the mean time, they convinced me to test drive a few other cars.

The first car was a 2006 Mazda3 with 97k miles. I told them I had no interest in something with that high mileage, but they wanted me to try it anyway to get a feel for it. I've always driven domestic cars, and other than makes or models far out of my price range, I haven't been overly impressed with anything foreign that I've been in yet. With that said, when I climbed into the car, I already had a bias against it. I was LOOKING for a reason not to like it. For a car with 100k miles, I would have never know; the ride was outstandingly smooth and the car looked great. If they told me it was brand new I wouldn't have second guessed it (other than the fact that it was an '06). The 2.3L felt very torquey for an I4, and the transmission, while automatic, was actually fun to play with ("sport shift" or whatever they call it). The handling was probably the best out of all the cars I drove, and the car looked sharp to boot. The interior, while plainer (in my opinion) than the Fusion was still very pleasing; I liked the gauge cluster in particular. After driving it for only 5-10 minutes, I feel silly for having the bias I had before. I... liked this car? Amazing.

We were still waiting for other dealerships to call back, so they convinced me to jump into a 2008 Focus SES sedan - I had been considering one any way, so why not. The interior was actually very pleasing, better than the Fusion SE in some ways. The handling, like the Mazda3, felt much more responsive and refined than the larger Fusion (or my Malibu). The problem came as soon as I pulled out onto a semi-busy street... the power. Or the lack thereof. While the Mazda3's 2.3L 160 HP I4 felt like 160 horses at a gallop, the Focuses 2.0L 140 HP I4 felt like a bunch of angry hamsters fighting desperately just to get out of their own way. Ok, I guess that's a little carried away - the car actually did exactly what it was supposed to - get me from point A to point B. But man, the first time I put my foot into it, watch it drop back into 1st and jump up to 5k RPM, I wanted to laugh. All that noise for what seemed like nothing. For someone looking for a cheap car with decent gas mileage and a decent interior that has no interest in power, it would be great. For me, well, I'm not sure how I could switch between the Mustang and that when the weather got bad. Maybe if I could fit two of those 2.0 I4s in the engine compartment...

Finally, since we had time to kill, we jumped in a 2007 (08?) V6 Mustang, automatic. Again, I had a huge bias against it already; if I'm going to get a two door, I want something sporty. If I'm going to get a Mustang, I want a manual V8. I sucked it up and gave it the benefit of the doubt anyway. The V6 wasn't as peppy as the Fusion, though the 5 speed automatic seemed to shift a lot cleaner than the Fusion's 6 speed. The interior, while not horrible, wasn't as nice as any of the above cars. The "classic" styling didn't do much for me - when you have the real thing sitting back at home, it just seems so overdone. When I told the sales rep I was restoring a '66, he actually apologized - maybe he figured everyone in their early 20s swoons over driving a Mustang. While the GTs are very nice (and very out of my price / sane insurance range), The V6 was nothing to write home about.

Finally, we sat down to discuss more options and follow up with other dealerships. I had him call on a few Mazda3s while he was at it, though they tend to be priced a bit out of my range for anything decent (2.3L "S" mode, ~30k miles or less). He asked me to make a choice between the two cars - V6 Fusion and Mazda3 - so he could focus on one or the other. I reluctantly asked him to keep looking for a good deal on a Fusion, and left it at that. He's going to call me before noon tomorrow to let me know what he's found and we'll go from there; in the mean time I'm going to do more research of my own so I know exactly what to expect for a price. Overall, all of the reps I've talked to have been very honest with the pricing, though not as flexible as some dealerships. We'll see what happens, I guess.
 

Mermaidman

Diamond Member
Sep 4, 2003
7,987
93
91
:confused:
Why are you having the dealer search for a used car for you? What's his incentive for finding the car you want? You should be looking on Autotrader.com, Craigslist, cars.com, eBay, etc.
 

CurseTheSky

Diamond Member
Oct 21, 2006
5,401
2
0
They get commission on any sale, as far as I know, so that's his incentive. On my end, it lets him do some of the dirty work for me - believe me, I've checked autotrader, cars.com, and a couple of others - finding exactly what I'm looking for in this price range isn't easy.

My dad, who just picked up his new 2009 V6 Fusion SE / sport package tonight, also gets a cash bonus for "referring me" to the dealership, up to $500 IIRC (probably more like $200 in this case). He's already agreed to throw that into the down payment, which is a plus for me as well.
 

DivideBYZero

Lifer
May 18, 2001
24,117
2
0
Originally posted by: angry hampster
Why don't you pull your nose out of your ass and look at other stuff besides domestics? Check out VW's Passat, Honda's Accord V6, and Nissan's Maxima/Altima 3.5.

Stop fighting that headwind, NOW!
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Certainly avoid buying new, especially a domestic.

I'd frankly keep that Malibu until you can buy something more fun. Going from it to another daily hauler/grocery getter just doesn't seem like a great use of money.

You could consider a late model Maxima. I saw an 08 with very few miles (it was maybe 15k miles I think) for under $16k. That car would smoke the ever-living hell out of the cars you test drove in performance, comfort, levels of pimpaciousness, and it's not going to be any more expensive to maintain. Gas mileage is a tiny bit worse, obviously. You need to go private party to get the best deals. That maxima contrasts with a similar vintage bottom of the line Altima at a dealer, but that's what you pay for going to a dealer.
 

Gibson486

Lifer
Aug 9, 2000
18,378
2
0
ummm...I am pretty certain you can buy a used mazda3 s with under 60K for 14K easily .....
 

StageLeft

No Lifer
Sep 29, 2000
70,150
5
0
Originally posted by: Gibson486
ummm...I am pretty certain you can buy a used mazda3 s with under 60K for 14K easily .....
Yeah, I'd expect that 2006 Mazda 3 with 100k to be way, way below $10k.

 

adlep

Diamond Member
Mar 25, 2001
5,287
6
81
Through the Autotrader, you will be able to find a low millage 7gen Accord (06-07) or a low millage 07-08 Fusion SE for about $13,000.
The 07-08 Mazda 6 will also be available within this price range.

The 06-07 Accord has an interior that you will like


Your autotrader search radius should be at least 100 miles though.
Tell me your zipcode and I will find you a few offers in your area :)

Edit: Thee are plenty of Mazda 3 available for around $13,000
 

MiataNC

Platinum Member
Dec 5, 2007
2,215
1
81
Mazda3 with lower miles

2005-2008 Mazda 6 (Mercury Milan, Ford Fusion, and Mazda6 all basically the same car mechanically)= They make a 5-Door "hatch" model that looks exactly like a normal 4 door sedan. Perfect if you have kid stuff to haul. Comes with the 2.3L found in the 3 or an optional V6. Manual trans avail with both engine configs. Tons of Mazda6's coming off lease and out of rental fleets.

2004-2006 Mazda RX-8 = Hard on gas (13-15mpg city @20 highway). Seating for 4 with "suicide" rear doors. Engine warranty extended to 8 years 100K. Phenomenal handling. Unique look and tons of "class".

 

Arkaign

Lifer
Oct 27, 2006
20,736
1,379
126
Sorry to hear about your experience with the '08 Focus, though I agree. The 4-speed auto in that thing desperately needs to be replaced (which it will in the 2011 model). The Focus with a 5spd is infinitely more pleasing to deal with.

I have an '08 Focus S Coupe w/5Spd, added a Steeda SRI got an ECU flash, which judging from others with the same mods show gains on the dyno of 11-15hp, looking at the range of results. It weighs a lot less than the Mazda3, and I can outrun my friend's '06 Mazda3S by about a car length by the time I hit 75mph. His is stock other than a K&N filter. Not that a Mazda3s or Focus are fast by any means. Still slower than V6 Camry ;)

Focus or Mazda3 are best with manual, but the Mazda3 auto is a world better than the Focus's antiquated 4-speed setup. It really does rob the car of the fun factor.
 

TehMac

Diamond Member
Aug 18, 2006
9,976
3
71
Originally posted by: angry hampster
Why don't you pull your nose out of your ass and look at other stuff besides domestics? Check out VW's Passat, Honda's Accord V6, and Nissan's Maxima/Altima 3.5.

And BMWs.