just buy a refurbed dell and slap in a better video card.
I'd wait for Sandy Bridge at this point, or go with AMD as I initially suggested. AMD still makes a very nice CPU. Now, since your goal is 3 years (that's shooting a little high, but it might be possible), Sandy Bridge is going to be the most powerful thing, and it's coming out very shortly.
I hear you, and that's why you should slow things down and simplify.
If your priority is gaming, focus on gaming benchmarks. Anything else will be confusing. On Intel's side, I would wait for sandy bridge (or, if you can't, get an i5 750/760). For AMD, I would get a Phenom II X4 955 and overclock it. If you're not into overclocking, go Intel for sure. Here are the head to head benchmarks of the 955 and the i5 750: http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/88?vs=109 Focus on the gaming benchmarks at the bottom.
For your video card, since you've expressed an interest in Nvidia, go with them. They have a number of good options - in fact, I would say they've won the current round of video cards. The GTX 570 is extremely strong, and the GTX 460 1GB is an excellent midrange option.
Everything else is fungible. Pick a motherboard you like, RAM you like, and a good HDD (western digital or samsung F3). Pick a case that appeals to you. That's it. Those decisions are much easier than the CPU/GPU.
Thanks Axon...
What about adding to any of these barebone kits? :
http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/category/category_slc.asp?CatId=2846&name=Pre-Assembled-Barebones&
That link is busted. Why do you want a barebone kit? Less assembly for you? Might as well buy a pre-built, then.
EDIT: Oh, TD's barebones are essentially prebuilds.
The build I gave you will probably last you 3 years with a video card and some more ram. Honestly, the video card is always the first thing to be holding you back. I always figure a new graphics card will last 2 years playing on mostly max settings, then it'll start to lag behind for that 3rd year, and prolly be able to limp along for the 4th, but at that point you'll be able to get a card with 10x the performance for like a quarter of what you paid for the first one. Now you'll probably need more RAM in 2-3 years. All this is just speculation of course, which is why we were all so hesitant to come out and say "THIS IS THE ANSWER TO ALL YOUR HOPES AND DREAMS!" but yeah...
I AM an AMD fan...
I'm in OVERLOAD right now with all the research...LOL!
The build I gave you will probably last you 3 years with a video card and some more ram. Honestly, the video card is always the first thing to be holding you back. I always figure a new graphics card will last 2 years playing on mostly max settings, then it'll start to lag behind for that 3rd year, and prolly be able to limp along for the 4th, but at that point you'll be able to get a card with 10x the performance for like a quarter of what you paid for the first one. Now you'll probably need more RAM in 2-3 years. All this is just speculation of course, which is why we were all so hesitant to come out and say "THIS IS THE ANSWER TO ALL YOUR HOPES AND DREAMS!" but yeah...
Psst... Radeons are AMD now. :sneaky:
